Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided June 26, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Abrams v Abrams	Index No. 654992/22\|Appeal No. 4635\|Case No. 2023-06379\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03857
TRB Acquisitions LLC v Yedid	Index No. 651160/21\|Appeal No. 3975\|Case No. 2024-06552\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03872
Matter of R.H. v M.C.H.	Docket No. O-8770/20, O-00638/21\|Appeal No. 4050\|Case No. 2023-06685\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03871
People v Rockeem M.	Ind No. 70087/20 70673/22\|Appeal No. 4638\|Case No. 2023-05980\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03870
People v Cabrera	Ind No. 1407/21\|Appeal No. 4634\|Case No. 2022-05759\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03869
People v Lowndes	Ind No. 71074/23\|Appeal No. 4644\|Case No. 2023-03936\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03868
People v Joudeh	Ind No. 3882/16\|Appeal No. 4641\|Case No. 2019-02033\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03867
McCoy v Lvovsky	Index No. 309605/11\|Appeal No. 4642\|Case No. 2023-04355\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03866
Matter of J'Quan M. v Zhonvel B.	\|Docket No. V-38339-23/23A\|Appeal No. 4636\|Case No. 2024-06705\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03865
Hasan v Macerich Co.	Index No. 151984/20\|Appeal No. 4637\|Case No. 2024-02301\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03864
Goon v Grand Cent. Partnership, Inc.	Index No. 161492/17\|Appeal No. 4640\|Case No. 2023-06001\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03863
Cooper v Arbor Realty Trust, Inc.	Index No. 651611/23\|Appeal No. 4639\|Case No. 2024-06749\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03862
Burrows v 75-25 153rd St., LLC	Index No. 160082/20\|Appeal No. 17103-17104\|Case No. 2021-04654 2022-02533\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03861
AT&T Mobility Holdings B.V. v Grupo Salinas Telecom	Index No. 650330/20\|Appeal No. 4645-4646-4647\|Case No. 2024-07800 2024-07902 2025-01653\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03860
Matter of Anonymous v Sattler	Index No. 156646/24\|Appeal No. 4648\|Case No. 2025-01744\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03859
American Infertility of N.Y., P.C. v Kushnir	Index No. 655306/18\|Appeal No. 4643-4643A\|Case No. 2024-05780\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03858

**Cases Decided June 24, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Arena Ltd. SPV, LLC v Chalets LLC	Index No. 655311/23\|Appeal No. 4630-4631\|Case No. 2024-04520, 2024-04523\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03759
Wyse v Amtrust N. Am., Inc.	Index No. 652401/20\|Appeal No. 4632\|Case No. 2024-05964\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03783
Wollman v Seven Seas Union Sq. LLC	Index No. 160682/20\|Appeal No. 4626\|Case No. 2024-04099\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03782
Toomer v New York City Hous. Auth.	Index No. 154831/18\|Appeal No. 4621\|Case No. 2024-03476\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03781
Spin Capital, LLC v Golden Foothill Ins. Servs., LLC	Index No. 650582/22\|Appeal No. 4609-4610-4610A\|Case No. 2024-03348, 2024-07473\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03780
Slabakis v Poyiadjis	Index No. 655855/18\|Appeal No. 4616-4617-4618\|Case No. 2024-05204, 2024-06458, 2024-07114\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03779
Rubin v Sabharwal	Index No. 650839/17\|Appeal No. 4608\|Case No. 2024-04463\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03778
Providence Constr. Corp. v Silverite Constr. Co. Inc.	Index No. 650967/19, 595311/19\|Appeal No. 4614\|Case No. 2024-04168\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03777
People v Fearing	Ind. No. 393/20\|Appeal No. 4607\|Case No. 2021-00633\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03776
People v Frasier	Ind. No. 721/20\|Appeal No. 4625\|Case No. 2024-01510\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03775
People v Bryan	Ind. No. 71865/22\|Appeal No. 4611\|Case No. 2023-02079\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03774
People v Vega	SCI No. 75/20\|Appeal No. 4612\|Case No. 2020-02147\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03773
People v Dockery	Ind. No. 70172/22\|Appeal No. 4603\|Case No. 2023-01713\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03772
People v McCall	Ind. No. 833/20\|Appeal No. 4620\|Case No. 2023-05635\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03771
People v Maldonado	Ind. No. 340/18\|Appeal No. 4627\|Case No. 2019-2853\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03770
People v Sims	Ind. No. 1253/21\|Appeal No. 4628\|Case No. 2024-01955\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03769
People v Tarazona	Ind. No. 72271/22\|Appeal No. 4615\|Case No. 2023-00629\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03768
People v Thomas	Ind. No. 11516/19, 1122/21\|Appeal No. 4623-4623A\|Case No. 2022-04211\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03767
Palmer v City of New York	Index No. 162271/15\|Appeal No. 4629\|Case No. 2024-02297\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03766
Martinez v City of New York	Index No. 152989/23\|Appeal No. 4531\|Case No. 2025-01075\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03765
Matter of J.M. (Jennifer L.)	Docket No. NA-32719/18, NA-08345/19, NA-08162/20\|Appeal No. 4605-4605A\|Case No. 2022-05411, 2023-06081\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03764
Matter of Jeselle K.J. v Alexis J.	Docket No. V-19960/13, G-37582/19\|Appeal No. 4622\|Case No. 2024-05095\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03763
Idahosa v MFM Contr. Corp.	Index No. 654637/21\|Appeal No. 4633\|Case No. 2024-03801\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03762
Chatham Capital Mgt. IV LLC v Platinum Asset Funding LLC	Index No. 157977/20\|Appeal No. 4624\|Case No. 2024-03092\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03761
Associated Indus. Ins. Co., Inc. v Farahnik	Index No. 157415/22\|Appeal No. 4619\|Case No. 2024-03721\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03760

**Cases Decided June 17, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Board of Mgrs. of the Alfred Condominium v Miller		Index No. 653433/20\|Appeal No. 4592\|Case No. 2024-04837\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03647
Weatherspoon v Mazal Ubracha 101 LLC		Index No. 155330/21\|Appeal No. 4590\|Case No. 2024-04926\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03662
Matter of Stuyvesant Town-Peter Cooper Vil. Tenants Assn. v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 154097/21\|Appeal No. 4588\|Case No. 2023-01164\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03661
Rosario v Hallen Constr. Co., Inc.		Index No. 157141/21\|Appeal No. 4600\|Case No. 2025-00682\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03660
Prospect Capital Corp. v Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP		Index No. 653941/22\|Appeal No. 4601\|Case No. 2024-06500\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03659
People v Webbert		Ind. No. 70890/21\|Appeal No. 4587\|Case No. 2024-00449\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03658
People v Celleri		Ind. No. 1848/21\|Appeal No. 4594\|Case No. 2023-04282\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03657
People v Hernandez		Ind. No. 2635/16\|Appeal No. 4591\|Case No. 2019-03413\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03656
People v Bell		SCI No. 30163/18\|Appeal No. 4595\|Case No. 2019-2012\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03655
People v Rivera		Ind. No. 71374/23\|Appeal No. 4599\|Case No. 2024-01069\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03654
One River Run Acquisition, LLC v Milde		Index No. 653389/22\|Appeal No. 4596-4597\|Case No. 2024-06572, 2025-00959\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03653
Matter of Nguyen	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-02276\|Case No. 2025-02393\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03652
Matter of Lek v Ramseur		Appeal No. 4602\|Case No. 2025-02558\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03651
Matter of Garda CL Atl., Inc. v New York City Off. of Admin. Trials & Hearings		Index No. 162286/23\|Appeal No. 4250 & M-01099\|Case No. 2024-03636\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03650
Daniello v J.T. Magen & Co. Inc.		Index No. 158947/19, 595110/22\|Appeal No. 4593\|Case No. 2024-05100\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03649
Matter of D. M. v B. L. J.		Docket No. O-03089/20, O-03089/20A, O-03089/21B, O-03089/21C\|Appeal No. 4589\|Case No. 2024-06655\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03648

**Cases Decided June 12, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Kevin J.B. v Tanisha H.		Index No. P-05632/24\|Appeal No. 4576\|Case No. 2024-06625\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03628
Yang v Knights Genesis Group		Index No. 651118/21\|Appeal No. 4578-4578A\|Case No. 2024-03461\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03641
Tucker v All Metro Home Care Servs., Inc.		Index No. 302333/14\|Appeal No. 4575\|Case No. 2024-01121\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03640
Roberts v City of New York		Index No. 817268/21\|Appeal No. 4585\|Case No. 2024-04777\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03639
People v Maycock		Ind No. 4538/17\|Appeal No. 4579\|Case No. 2019-05317\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03638
People v Diaz		Ind No. 4857/16\|Appeal No. 4584\|Case No. 2023-01003\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03637
People v J.H.		Ind No. 89/11\|Appeal No. 4581\|Case No. 2024-05695\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03636
People v Cedeno		Ind No. 1132/19\|Appeal No. 4583\|Case No. 2022-2018\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03635
People v Stokes		Ind No. 70803/21\|Appeal No. 4574\|Case No. 2023-03142\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03634
PanWest NCA2 Holdings LLC v Rockland NCA2 Holdings, LLC		Index No. 653890/20\|Appeal No. 4586\|Case No. 2023-04703\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03633
Matter of Keith	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-01645\|Case No. 2023-02706\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03632
HSBC Bank USA v Amponsah		Index No. 35262/13\|Appeal No. 4577\|Case No. 2025-00666\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03631
Ceratosaurus Invs., LLC v B2C Alternative Equity, LLC		Index No. 653758/24\|Appeal No. 4582\|Case No. 2025-00830\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03630
Berrones v 130 E. 18 Owners Corp.		Index No. 159487/19 595362/20\|Appeal No. 4580\|Case No. 2024-03971\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03629

**Cases Decided June 10, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
2 Cap Invs., LLC v Frog Invs., LLC		Index No. 850074/22\|Appeal No. 4548\|Case No. 2024-05290\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03525
U.S. Bank N.A. v Chait		Index No. 850196/22, 850037/15 \|Appeal No. 4560-4562\|Case No. 2024-01743, 2024-02102, 2024-02103\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03549
Staff v Luen Nam Realty Corp.		Index No. 160114/20\|Appeal No. 4555\|Case No. 2024-03437\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03548
Singer v de Blasio		Index No. 158766/20\|Appeal No. 4566-4567\|Case No. 2024-01788, 2024-02298\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03547
Matter of Lulu J.S. v Rahmel H.H.		Case No. 2024-04581\|Docket No. V-19070-13/16, V-18877-13/16, V-18877-13/16\|Appeal No. 4549\|Case No. 2024-04581\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03546
Reyes v City of New York		Index No. 157358/21\|Appeal No. 4572\|Case No. 2024-03474\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03545
Matter of Promenade Nelson Apts. LLC v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 153870/23\|Appeal No. 4550\|Case No. 2024-00403\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03544
People v Hiciano		Ind. No. 71052/21\|Appeal No. 4565\|Case No. 2023-05124\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03543
People v McGowan		Ind. No. 70658/21\|Appeal No. 4547\|Case No. 2023-04332\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03542
People v Daniel		Ind. No. 1189/21\|Appeal No. 4554\|Case No. 2023-05321\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03541
People v Lazareth P.		SCI No. 70444/20\|Appeal No. 4571\|Case No. 2021-00447\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03540
People v Davis		Ind. No. 6994/81\|Appeal No. 4568\|Case No. 2020-02475\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03539
People v Cordero		Ind. No. 1042/19\|Appeal No. 4552\|Case No. 2022-04348\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03538
People v O'Toole		Ind. No. 4931/16\|Appeal No. 4557\|Case No. 2020-02165\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03537
People v Walls		Ind. No. 1120/19\|Appeal No. 4559\|Case No. 2022-05282\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03536
People v Wood		Ind. No. 74348/22\|Appeal No. 4570\|Case No. 2023-03406\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03535
Miracle NY Props. LLC v Nayber 18 LLC		Index No. 656463/23\|Appeal No. 4564\|Case No. 2024-05495\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03534
MevRam Servs., LLC v Quadrum Hospitality Group, LLC		Index No. 652871/23\|Appeal No. 4551\|Case No. 2024-03042\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03533
Metropolitan Partners Group Admin., LLC v Nerney		Index No. 650013/25\|Appeal No. 4273-4273A\|Case No. 2025-00907\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03532
Matter of Park	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2024-04195, 2024-05275\|Case No. 2021-00479\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03531
JLJ Prods., LLC v Amazon.com Servs., LLC		Index No. 650943/23\|Appeal No. 4556\|Case No. 2025-00217\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03530
Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's v Itzhak Nissanoff Inc.		Index No. 652565/20\|Appeal No. 4553\|Case No. 2024-03765\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03529
Bykovtseva v DTH Capital, Inc.		Index No. 151838/22\|Appeal No. 4558-M-2358\|Case No. 2024-07606\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03528
Matter of N.C.M. (Christian A.)		Docket No. N-5470-2/21\|Appeal No. 4563\|Case No. 2024-02868\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03527
Matter of 268 W. 12th Owners Corp. v Kunst		Index No. 154569/22\|Appeal No. 4569\|Case No. 2024-05160\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03526

**Cases Decided June 5, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Tahari v Narkis		Index No. 650671/21\|Appeal No. 4534-4535\|Case No. 2024-06199 2025-01361\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03395
Real World Holdings LLC v 393 W. Broadway Corp.		Index No. 160732/15\|Appeal No. 4533\|Case No. 2024-03480\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03394
Matter of B.F. v Administration for Children's Servs.		Docket No. NA-06074/21 NA-11365/22\|Appeal No. 3350-3350A\|Case No. 2023-05047\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03393
Matter of Olga R. v Olga I.M.		Case No. 2024-07155\|Docket No. V-12913/24\|Appeal No. 4532\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03392
People v Cruzado		SCI No. 73892/23\|Appeal No. 4530\|Case No. 2023-06308\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03391
People v Osias		Ind No. 892/20\|Appeal No. 4536\|Case No. 2022-02716 2023-04356\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03390
People v Rackover		Ind No. 1616/17\|Appeal No. 4539-4540\|Case No. 2019-1916 2023-01757\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03389
McCann v Ship Wrecked Bar & Grill, Inc.		Index No. 151982/19\|Appeal No. 4541\|Case No. 2024-05726\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03388
Matter of Schwartz	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-00526\|Case No. 2022-05338\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03387
Matter of Perry	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-00366\|Case No. 2023-02705\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03386
Matter of Miller	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-01809\|Case No. 2023-04231\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03385
Matter of Jenkins	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-01727\|Case No. 2024-02309\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03384
Matter of George	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-02031\|Case No. 2024-05180\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03383
Island Consol. v Grassi & Co.		Index No. 451469/23\|Appeal No. 4542\|Case No. 2025-00561\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03382
H.G. v New York City Tr. Auth.		Index No. 21567/17\|Appeal No. 4544\|Case No. 2024-04431\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03381
Gamma USA, Inc. v Pavarini McGovern, LLC		Index No. 655472/23\|Appeal No. 4538\|Case No. 2024-06455\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03380
Century Indem. Co. v Brooklyn Union Gas Co.		Index No. 603405/01 403087/02\|Appeal No. 3551-3552\|Case No. 2024-00848 2024-00850\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03379
Barcia v Costco Wholesale Corp.		Index No. 159881/15\|Appeal No. 3855\|Case No. 2024-00012\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03378

**Cases Decided June 3, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Abramov v 230 PAS SPE LLC	Index No. 153359/22\|Appeal No. 4490\|Case No. 2024-04809\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03271
Nazor v Sydney Sol Group, Ltd.	Index No. 156920/19\|Appeal No. 4489\|Case No. 2024-00237\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03295
Zhakiyanov v Ogai	Index No. 652148/24\|Appeal No. 4519\|Case No. 2024-06942\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03294
Windward Bora, LLC v Zorrilla	Index No. 21958/20\|Appeal No. 4510\|Case No. 2024-01175\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03293
Theroux v Resnicow	Index No. 154642/17\|Appeal No. 4525\|Case No. 2023-04831\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03292
Skyview Capital, LLC v Conduent Business Servs., LLC	Index No. 650761/20\|Appeal No. 4507\|Case No. 2024-00327\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03291
S. S. v Rockefeller Univ. Hosp.	Index No. 159929/23\|Appeal No. 4521\|Case No. 2024-03637\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03290
People v Vega	Ind. No. 2638/00\|Appeal No. 4494\|Case No. 2022-03637\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03289
People v Wilson	Ind. No. 762/20\|Appeal No. 4523\|Case No. 2023-00070\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03288
People v Duzant	Ind. No. 2123/18\|Appeal No. 4515\|Case No. 2023-01441, 2024-05638	2025 NY Slip Op 03287
People v Avila	Ind. No. 70739/23\|Appeal No. 4520\|Case No. 2023-05131\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03286
People v Perez	Ind. No. 72468/23\|Appeal No. 4488\|Case No. 2024-06075\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03285
Matter of DeMaio	Motion No. 2025-02998\|Case No. 2024-07350\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03284
NG 645 Madison Ave LLC v Vanguard Constr. & Dev. Co., Inc.	Index No. 158495/19, 595954/19, 595759/21\|Appeal No. 4506\|Case No. 2024-02428\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03283
Leftt v Blodgett	Index No. 811234/23\|Appeal No. 4518\|Case No. 2024-07348\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03282
Kyowa Seni, Co., Ltd. v ANA Aircraft Technics, Co., Ltd.	Index No. 650589/17\|Appeal No. 4495-4496-4497-4498-4499-4500-4501-4502\|Case No. 2018-03935, 2024-04761, 2024-06238, 2025-00534\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03281
Matter of M. H. (Ricardo D.)	Docket No. N18706/22, N18707/22, N18708/22\|Appeal No. 4517\|Case No. 2024-02359\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03280
Grove Equities LLC v Diaz	Index No. 152316/23\|Appeal No. 4522\|Case No. 2024-01587\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03279
Gillard v Citigroup	Index No. 159920/22\|Appeal No. 4508\|Case No. 2023-03250\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03278
Fortson v Thompson	Index No. 31232/19\|Appeal No. 4516\|Case No. 2025-00518\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03277
EXRP 14 Holdings LLC v LS-14 Ave LLC	Index No. 652698/22\|Appeal No. 4526-4527 & M-02564\|Case No. 2024-02502, 2025-01306\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03276
Matter of Cucs Hous. Dev. Corp. IV v Aymes	Index No. 159303/18\|Appeal No. 4503\|Case No. 2024-00620\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03275
Charles Condominiums, LLC v Victor RPM First, LLC	Index No. 657040/19\|Appeal No. 4492-4493\|Case No. 2024-03282, 2025-00712\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03274
Blinbaum v Chan	Index No. 151012/20, 595156/21\|Appeal No. 4529\|Case No. 2024-03651\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03273
Matter of Anheuser-Busch in Bev SA/NV v BBSR, LLC	Index No. 160735/24\|Appeal No. 4509\|Case No. 2025-00253\|	2025 NY Slip Op 03272