Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided October 30, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Anandaraja v Icahn Sch. of Medicine at Mount Sinai	Index No. 159045/22\|Appeal No. 5082\|Case No. 2025-01214\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06015
Matter of Verma v Department of Educ. of the City of N.Y.	Index No. 156602/19\|Appeal No. 5098\|Case No. 2024-03889\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06042
Matter of J.S. (M. Christian C.)	Index No. 30871-74/23\|Appeal No. 5072-5072A\|Case No. 2024-06063\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06041
Matter of T.M.S. v K.R.G.	Docket No. O-07498/23\|Appeal No. 5087-5087A\|Case No. 2024-04578 2025-00355\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06040
Rosario v Gentry Tenants Co-op	Index No. 155290/15 595785/16\|Appeal No. 5067\|Case No. 2024-03632\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06039
Reyes v 45 & 47 Wadsworth Ave. Co., LLC	Index No. 27196/16\|Appeal No. 5073\|Case No. 2024-03926\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06038
Ramirez v 79-05/07/09 Jackson Hgts. Prop. LLC	Index No. 809408/21\|Appeal No. 5100\|Case No. 2024-07721\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06037
Rahal v Taormina	Index No. 365553/23\|Appeal No. 5090\|Case No. 2024-07651\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06036
Pilapanta v Hudson 888 Owner, LLC	Index No. 152726/20 595476/20\|Appeal No. 5080\|Case No. 2024-06417\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06035
People v Clarida	Ind No. 2858/17\|Appeal No. 5081-5081A\|Case No. 2019-04061 2024-01331\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06034
People v Bryan	Ind No. 1378/16\|Appeal No. 5064\|Case No. 2021-02052\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06033
People v Ortiz	SCI No. 74810/23\|Appeal No. 5071\|Case No. 2024-00624\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06032
People v Elvin	Ind No. 71128/23\|Appeal No. 5092\|Case No. 2024-00817\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06031
People v Buchanan	Ind No. 247/19 509/18 1100/18\|Appeal No. 5085-5085A-5085B\|Case No. 2019-05333\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06030
People v Tracy	Ind No. 2956/18\|Appeal No. 5103-5103A\|Case No. 2023-00298 2023-04973\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06029
Muroff v Heerdt	Index No. 805358/17\|Appeal No. 5106\|Case No. 2024-00146\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06028
Medina v Medina	Index No. 810353/23\|Appeal No. 5065\|Case No. 2024-05854\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06027
Matter of D.M. v B.L.J.	Index No. O-03089/20- O-03089/20A-21C\|Appeal No. 5097M-5173\|Case No. 2025-04319\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06026
Leslie J. Garfield & Co., Inc. v Evans	Index No. 651854/21\|Appeal No. 5105\|Case No. 2024-06130\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06025
Leslie Digital Imaging LLC v Empower Info. Sys., Inc.	Index No. 652634/22\|Appeal No. 5083-5084\|Case No. 2023-06567 2023-06568\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06024
Innovative Sec., LTD. v OBEX Sec. LLC	Index No. 650685/23\|Appeal No. 5091\|Case No. 2025-00073\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06023
Hereford Ins. Co. v 21 Century Chiropractic Care	Index No. 150314/22\|Appeal No. 5079\|Case No. 2024-06498\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06022
Matter of Alisa H. v Ayanna B.	Docket No. V-3085-86/21\|Appeal No. 5066\|Case No. 2025-00119\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06021
Genna v Klempner	Index No. 100530/16\|Appeal No. 5093-5094-5095\|Case No. 2023-02464 2023-06111 2024-00139\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06020
Matter of Bejjani	Index No. 3663/09\|Appeal No. 5068-5069-5070\|Case No. 2023-04560, 2024-02919, 2024-05706\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06019
Espinal v Metropolitan Transp. Auth.	Index No. 157193/24\|Appeal No. 5088\|Case No. 2025-02269\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06018
Diamond Films Netherlands Cooperatief U.A. v TV Azteca S.A.B. De C.V.	Index No. 655384/20\|Appeal No. 5086\|Case No. 2024-05974\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06017
AT&T Mobility Holdings B.V. v Grupo Salinas Telecom, S.A.	Index No. 650330/20\|Appeal No. 5074-5075-5076-5077-5078\|Case No. 2025-02280 2025-02298 2025-02811 2025-02813 2025-02818\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06016

**Cases Decided October 28, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 382 McDonald LLC v New York City Indus. Dev. Agency	Index No. 161947/23\|Appeal No. 5058\|Case No. 2024-04647\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05914
Pritchett v American Golf Corp.	Index No. 33798/19\|Appeal No. 5061\|Case No. 2025-00596\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05929
Peralta v Hunter Roberts Constr. Group LLC	Index No. 159317/18, 595238/19\|Appeal No. 5051\|Case No. 2024-05358\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05928
People v E.R.	Ind. No. 1478/19\|Appeal No. 5104\|Case No. 2024-07795\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05927
People v Berry	Ind. No. 70894/23\|Appeal No. 5044\|Case No. 2024-01273\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05926
People v Lafrem	Ind. No. 1155/10\|Appeal No. 5052\|Case No. 2024-00474\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05925
People v Gee	Ind. No. 3494/17, 910/19\|Appeal No. 5060-5060A\|Case No. 2022-01503, 2022-01505\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05924
Pacheco v Georgetown Eleventh Ave. Owners LLC	Index No. 157529/17\|Appeal No. 5045\|Case No. 2024-07332\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05923
Lovett v 2600 Seventh Ave. Realty, LLC	Index No. 100515/24\|Appeal No. 5059\|Case No. 2025-00715\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05922
Kapitus Servicing, Inc. v Ragtime Gourmet Corp.	Index No. 653529/22\|Appeal No. 5057\|Case No. 2025-03545\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05921
Giangrande v Gracie Gardens Owners Corp	Index No. 160533/22\|Appeal No. 5055\|Case No. 2024-01882\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05920
Matter of Regla F. v Dustin F.	Index No. V-01883/25, O-02238/25\|Appeal No. 5046-5047\|Case No. 2025-02565, 2025-02566\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05919
D.R. v City of New York	Index No. 70349/21\|Appeal No. 5054\|Case No. 2024-03492\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05918
Cortes v Camplone	Index No. 27301/17\|Appeal No. 5053\|Case No. 2025-00665\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05917
Clares v 600 W. 183rd St. Realty Corp.	Index No. 451198/18\|Appeal No. 5062-5062A\|Case No. 2024-05099, 2025-02424\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05916
Astraea NYNY LLC v Ganley	Index No. 650082/21\|Appeal No. 5048-5049-5050\|Case No. 2024-00406, 2024-02296, 2024-04014, 2024-07940\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05915

**Cases Decided October 23, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Bodenchak v 5178 Holdings LLC		Index No. 152916/24\|Appeal No. 5021\|Case No. 2025-00400\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05875
Zimmerman v 410-57 Corp.		Index No. 653569/20\|Appeal No. 5023\|Case No. 2024-03895\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05912
Matter of Yakuel v New York City Taxi		Index No. 154689/23 161865/23\|Appeal No. 5029-5030\|Case No. 2024-04816, 2024-03051\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05911
Wilmington Sav. Fund Socy. FSB v Scaffidi		Index No. 35032/13\|Appeal No. 5020\|Case No. 2024-03959\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05910
Will B. Sandler Disclaimer Trust v Swersky		Index No. 651015/23\|Appeal No. 5012\|Case No. 2024-01151\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05909
Vasquez v Bronx Lebanon Hosp. Ctr.		Index No. 24567/20\|Appeal No. 5042\|Case No. 2024-02985\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05908
Matter of Salis v Zolin		Index No. 156523/24\|Appeal No. 5013\|Case No. 2025-00309\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05907
Sabr Chems. Group, LLC v Northeast Chems., Inc.		Index No. 650608/19\|Appeal No. 5043\|Case No. 2024-07639\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05906
Reyes v Benton		Index No. 152207/22\|Appeal No. 5019\|Case No. 2024-06152\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05905
Matter of Reclaim the Records v City of New York		Index No. 156960/23\|Appeal No. 5038\|Case No. 2024-03512\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05904
Matter of G.M.R. (A.R.)		Docket No. B-04647-49/21\|Appeal No. 5009-5009A\|Case No. 2025-01160\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05903
People v Smith		Ind No. 279/20 SCI No. 48/19\|Appeal No. 4982-4982A\|Case No. 2021-03101\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05902
People v Hatten		Ind No. 74835/23\|Appeal No. 5007\|Case No. 2024-06230\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05901
People v Downey		Ind No. 1799/20\|Appeal No. 5025\|Case No. 2023/06750\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05900
People v Powell		SMZ No. 74647/22\|Appeal No. 5022\|Case No. 2023-06489\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05899
People v Luna		Ind No. 72223/23\|Appeal No. 5041\|Case No. 2023-03957\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05898
People v Golphin		Ind No. 70954/22\|Appeal No. 5031\|Case No. 2022-04545\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05897
People v Diallo		Ind No. 72743/22\|Appeal No. 5016\|Case No. 2024-03756\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05896
Peck v Milbank LLP		Index No. 152290/22\|Appeal No. 5040\|Case No. 2024-05450\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05895
Nationstar Mtge. LLC v O'Connor		Index No. 35397/13\|Appeal No. 5028\|Case No. 2025-00941\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05894
Matter of Ni	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-03537\|Case No. 2025-02048\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05893
Matter of Lubliner	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-04323\|Case No. 2025-04857\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05892
Matter of Jacques	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-04224\|Case No. 2025-04771\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05891
Matter of Biniakewitz	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-04094\|Case No. 2024-07164\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05890
Martinez v Martinez		Index No. 159286/21\|Appeal No. 5026\|Case No. 2024-06747\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05889
Mancilla & Fantone, LLP v Liu		Index No. 450521/24\|Appeal No. 5008\|Case No. 2025-00514\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05888
Matter of M.M. (Chelsea B.)		Docket No. NN-01571/25\|Appeal No. 5037\|Case No. 2025-01784\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05887
Lee v Lee		Index No. 365055/18\|Appeal No. 5017\|Case No. 2024-04532\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05886
Matter of Law Firm of Jennifer Zuch, P.L.L.C. v Lemus		Index No. 656077/23\|Appeal No. 5032\|Case No. 2024-07200\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05885
Kassai v Trump Mgt. Inc.		Index No. 161322/18\|Appeal No. 5011\|Case No. 2025-00199\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05884
Matter of Peter K. v Mayumi M.		V-5183-23/23A\|Docket No. V-5183-23/23A\|Appeal No. 5018\|Case No. 2024-07683\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05883
HSBC Bank USA, N.A. v Wu		Index No. 850209/16\|Appeal No. 5033-5034-5035\|Case No. 2024-02127, 2024-06304\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05882
Matter of Yorbis H.		Docket No. D-10841/24\|Appeal No. 5027\|Case No. 2025-01238\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05881
Glover v Astor Ct. Owners Corp.		Index No. 156138/21\|Appeal No. 4729\|Case No. 2024-06353\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05880
Doe v Matta		Index No. 161657/23\|Appeal No. 5024\|Case No. 2024-05303\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05879
Cullins v Ihemaguba		Index No. 23688/17\|Appeal No. 5014\|Case No. 2024-03742\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05878
Contreras v Parkash		Index No. 811899/22\|Appeal No. 5039\|Case No. 2024-04701\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05877
Bonilla v BPP St Owner LLC		Index No. 160246/19\|Appeal No. 5036\|Case No. 2024-03517\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05876

**Cases Decided October 21, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Allmen v Kimmel	Index No. 305326/18\|Appeal No. 5004-5005-5006\|Case No. 2024-04536, 2024-04541, 2024-05289\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05759
U.S. Bank N.A. v Tiburcio	Index No. 32237/17\|Appeal No. 4997\|Case No. 2024-06097\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05779
Suarez v City of New York	Index No. 26291/20\|Appeal No. 4993\|Case No. 2024-06591\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05778
People v Gibbs	Ind. No. 1411/20, 2118/21\|Appeal No. 4986\|Case No. 2024-07638\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05777
People v Marte	Ind. No. 4081/19\|Appeal No. 4992\|Case No. 2023-00785\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05776
People v Johnson	Ind. No. 72108/24\|Appeal No. 5002\|Case No. 2024-03828\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05775
Owen v Johnson	Index No. 365421/20\|Appeal No. 4999-5000\|Case No. 2024-07483, 2025-02061\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05774
McGregor v Manhattan Nursing Home Realty, Inc.	Index No. 158715/21\|Appeal No. 4990\|Case No. 2025-01240\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05773
Matter of M.A.F. (M.F.)	Docket No. B-4618/21\|Appeal No. 4988\|Case No. 2024-04189\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05772
Malekan v Malekan	Index No. 652507/23\|Appeal No. 5003\|Case No. 2025-01984\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05771
Matter of Liberty Mobility Link v Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J.	Index No. 151814/24\|Appeal No. 4987\|Case No. 2025-02403\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05770
Lema v 1148 Corp.	Index No. 450904/18, 450865/18, 150221/18, 150316/18\|Appeal No. 4989\|Case No. 2025-01461\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05769
Godfrey-Peters v Dangelo	Index No. 800050/24\|Appeal No. 5001\|Case No. 2025-00178\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05768
Gamble v MTA Bus Co.	Index No. 801074/24\|Appeal No. 4998\|Case No. 2025-00918\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05767
Matter of I.G. (D.V.)	Docket No. NN-19245/23, NN-19246/23\|Appeal No. 4996\|Case No. 2023-06751\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05766
Matter of Freedom Care LLC v New York State Dept. of Health	Index No. 161036/24\|Appeal No. 4859 & M-04795, M-05008\|Case No. 2025-02532\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05765
Matter of Flores-Grgas v New York State Off. of Children & Family Servs.	Index No. 100007/24\|Appeal No. 4995\|Case No. 2024-05700\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05764
Embarq, L.L.C. v Bank of N.Y. Mellon Trust Co., N.A.	Index No. 651404/23, 153442/23\|Appeal No. 4252-4253\|Case No. 2024-02665, 2024-05235\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05763
Bennigson v Salvation Army	Index No. 650416/23\|Appeal No. 4991 & M-04995, M-05115, M-05116\|Case No. 2024-04235\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05762
Arencibia v SilverLining, Inc.	Index No. 659588/24\|Appeal No. 4524 & M-4044\|Case No. 2025-00723\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05761
Ancart v Crespo	Index No. 651303/23\|Appeal No. 4994\|Case No. 2025-01701\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05760

**Cases Decided October 16, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 383 W. Broadway Corp. v Solomon	Index No. 152351/21\|Appeal No. 4977-4978-4979\|Case No. 2024-03063 2024-06312 2024-06313\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05741
White v Turitz	Index No. 805070/20\|Appeal No. 4974\|Case No. 2024-06287\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05758
Rivera v ShopRite of Bruckner Blvd.	Index No. 813506/22\|Appeal No. 4967\|Case No. 2025-00697\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05757
Phillips v Uber Tech., Inc.	Index No. 42032/23\|Appeal No. 4983-4984\|Case No. 2024-03607 2025-01064\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05756
People v Calderon	Ind No. 3507/19\|Appeal No. 4806\|Case No. 2022-00046\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05755
People v Rivera	Ind No. 3635/16\|Appeal No. 4968\|Case No. 2019-04979\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05754
People v Gouldbourne	Ind No. 70800/24\|Appeal No. 4972\|Case No. 2024-05626\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05753
People v Holmes	Ind No. 74216/22\|Appeal No. 4969\|Case No. 2024-03834\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05752
People v Showers	Ind No. 2356/15\|Appeal No. 4981\|Case No. 2024-00565\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05751
People v Concepcion	Ind No. 72742/22\|Appeal No. 4975\|Case No. 2022-04917\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05750
People v Cabrera-Fernandez	Ind No. 2808/17\|Appeal No. 4976\|Case No. 2023-03553\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05749
People v Young	Ind No. 423/21\|Appeal No. 4964\|Case No. 2024-00219\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05748
People v Holley	Ind No. 2286/18\|Appeal No. 4973\|Case No. 2022-02962\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05747
Moises-Ortiz v FDB Acquisition LLC	Index No. 152869/17\|Appeal No. 4782\|Case No. 2024-05224\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05746
Lewis v Ganesh	Index No. 24992/18\|Appeal No. 4965\|Case No. 2024-02453\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05745
Dorilton Capital Mgt. LLC v Stilus LLC	Index No. 652428/23\|Appeal No. 4980\|Case No. 2025-01239\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05744
Board of Mgrs. of the 610 Park Ave. Condominium v 16EF Apt. LLC	Index No. 151261/23\|Appeal No. 4985\|Case No. 2024-04110\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05743
Matter of 670 Riv. Realty Corp. v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal	Index No. 151041/24\|Appeal No. 4971\|Case No. 2024-05438\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05742

**Cases Decided October 14, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Sanchez v 562 Thieriot Ave, LLC	Index No. 808455/21\|Appeal No. 4845\|Case No. 2024-07203\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05654
Matter of Wadsworth Assoc. LLC v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal	Index No. 160054/23\|Appeal No. 4942M-4529\|Case No. 2024-02494\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05659
Uno A Brokerage Inc. v Inshur, Inc.	Index No. 652251/23\|Appeal No. 4946\|Case No. 2024-02444\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05658
Matter of Stikeman Elliott LLP v OL Private Counsel LLC	Index No. 153406/24\|Appeal No. 4809\|Case No. 2025-01514\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05657
Matter of State of New York v T.N.	Index No. 260518/19\|Appeal No. 4929\|Case No. 2024-05054\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05656
Simon v 4 World Trade Ctr. LLC	Index No. 152437/18\|Appeal No. 4258-4259-4260\|Case No. 2024-03831, 2024-03513, 2024-03619\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05655
600 Assoc. LLC v Illinois Union Ins. Co.	Index No. 814015/22\|Appeal No. 4939-4940\|Case No. 2023-04993, 2024-06544\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05622
People v Brown	Ind. No. 74064/23\|Appeal No. 4952\|Case No. 2024-03125\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05653
People v Santos	SCI No. 67/21\|Appeal No. 4955\|Case No. 2023-01682\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05652
People v Rosario	Ind. No. 854/21\|Appeal No. 4956\|Case No. 2023-00571\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05651
People v Shilman	Ind. No. 72654/22\|Appeal No. 4954\|Case No. 2022-04342\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05650
People v Wade	Ind. No. 71531/23\|Appeal No. 4932\|Case No. 2024-03780\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05649
People v Correa	Ind. No. 2562/18\|Appeal No. 4919\|Case No. 2019-04847\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05648
People v Fields	SCI No. 3143/18\|Appeal No. 4944\|Case No. 2019-03817\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05647
People v Sastre	Ind. No. 4712/09\|Appeal No. 4923\|Case No. 2020-01659\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05646
People v Thompson	Ind. No. 1593/21\|Appeal No. 4934\|Case No. 2022-04809\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05645
People v Ferguson	Ind. No. 2740/15\|Appeal No. 4926\|Case No. 2017-1547\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05644
People v Braxton	Ind. No. 1384/20, 1162/20, 75474/22\|Appeal No. 4927\|Case No. 2024-00469\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05643
People v Santiago	Ind. No. 71159/21\|Appeal No. 4930\|Case No. 2023-01876\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05642
People v Newell	Ind. No. 1778/18\|Appeal No. 4947\|Case No. 2020-00300\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05641
People v Guzman	Ind. No. 70447/20\|Appeal No. 4922\|Case No. 2021-02475\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05640
People v Guitierez	SCI No. 1865/19\|Appeal No. 4938\|Case No. 2020-00997\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05639
People v Seda	Ind. No. 464/20\|Appeal No. 4933\|Case No. 2023-05751\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05638
Nunez v Turo, Inc.	Index No. 810444/21\|Appeal No. 4931\|Case No. 2024-04306\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05637
Molner v Molner	Index No. 301261/12\|Appeal No. 4957\|Case No. 2025-00799\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05636
Metropolitan Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co. v Pentair Residential Filtration, LLC	Index No. 153189/18\|Appeal No. 4935\|Case No. 2024-04359\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05635
Matter of Darryl M. v Shaniqua D.	Docket No. V-26546/23, V-10105/24\|Appeal No. 4921\|Case No. 2025-01414\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05634
Lopez v Rodriguez	Index No. 158166/23\|Appeal No. 4928\|Case No. 2024-04927\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05633
J.N. v Strong	Index No. 805083/15\|Appeal No. 4925\|Case No. 2023-06557\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05632
Feifei Gu v Hong Ji	Index No. 101013/22\|Appeal No. 4949-4950\|Case No. 2024-03068, 2024-04918\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05631
Gonzalez v Metropolitan Transp. Auth.	Index No. 20050/18\|Appeal No. 4948\|Case No. 2024-03875\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05630
Gomez v Thomas	Index No. 29048/19\|Appeal No. 4924\|Case No. 2024-06871\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05629
Doe v Archdiocese of N.Y.	Index No. 950208/19\|Appeal No. 4943\|Case No. 2025-03876\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05628
Matter of L.D. (Sonja A.)	Docket No. NN-35862/23\|Appeal No. 4941\|Case No. 2024-06686\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05627
Cohn v RTW Retail Winds Acquisition LLC	Index No. 653518/24\|Appeal No. 4958-4959-4960-4961-4962-4963\|Case No. 2024-07867, 2025-00032, 2025-00033, 2025-00034, 2025-00035, 2025-00057\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05626
Charlton v 92 Pinehurst Ave. LLC	Index No. 151342/21\|Appeal No. 4936\|Case No. 2024-05245\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05625
Best Work Holdings (N.Y.) LLC v Jia Ivy Ma.	Index No. 654826/22\|Appeal No. 4953\|Case No. 2024-01759\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05624
ARK292 Doe v Archdiocese of N.Y.	Index No. 950344/20, 950063/19, 950167/20, 950175/20, 951194/21, 950238/19, 950203/20, 950305/20\|Appeal No. 4937\|Case No. 2025-00024\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05623

**Cases Decided October 9, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 413 E. 187 Holdings LLC v New York City Dept. of Hous. Preserv. & Dev.		Index No. 812423/23\|Appeal No. 4909\|Case No. 2023-06788\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05566
Tahari v 860 Fifth Ave. Corp.	Scarpulla, J.	Index No. 654702/18\|Appeal No. 3859\|Case No. 2024-03150\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05584
People v McGrier		Ind No. 1493/21, 71310/22, 71955/22\|Appeal No. 4911-4911A\|Case No. 2023-01032- 2023-00048\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05583
People v Zorrilla		Ind No. 600/18\|Appeal No. 4912\|Case No. 2023-02676\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05582
People v Harris		SCI No. 2099/19\|Appeal No. 4902\|Case No. 2020-01196\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05581
People v Chance		Ind No. 72384/23\|Appeal No. 4893\|Case No. 2024-01981\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05580
People v Morris		Ind No. 70721/21, 2392/19\|Appeal No. 4898-4899\|Case No. 2023-02655 2023-02690\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05579
People v Brown		Ind No. 1396/84\|Appeal No. 4907\|Case No. 2022-05204\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05578
Pallero v Romero		Index No. 305093/15\|Appeal No. 4897\|Case No. 2024-04715\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05577
Ovalle v Church St. Constr. Corp.		Index No. 30590/19\|Appeal No. 4896\|Case No. 2024-05202\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05576
Ntiru v WV Preserv. Partners, LLC		Index No. 158358/21\|Appeal No. 4894\|Case No. 2025-01288\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05575
Murillo v Downtown NYC Owner, LLC		Index No. 152211/17\|Appeal No. 4901\|Case No. 2024-03218\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05574
Matter of Peter M. v Fezeka G.G.		Docket No. V-14941/22\|Appeal No. 4895\|Case No. 2024-05408\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05573
Grace v Sabal		Index No. 952265/23\|Appeal No. 4914-4915-4916\|Case No. 2025-00378 2025-00382 2025-01821\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05572
Gedula 26, LLC v Lightstone Acquisitions III LLC		Index No. 653977/14\|Appeal No. 4904-4905\|Case No. 2024-04317 2025-00314\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05571
Brevet Direct Lending Short Duration Fund, L.P. v Aprio LLP		Index No. 656441/18\|Appeal No. 4906\|Case No. 2024-07555\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05570
Bey v City of New York		Index No. 153420/24\|Appeal No. 4917-4917AM-4853\|Case No. 2024-06859 2024-06996\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05569
ARC NYWWPJV001, LLC v WWP JV LLC		Index No. 654977/22\|Appeal No. 4900\|Case No. 2025-00798\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05568
Matter of Emmanuel A. v Evelyn R.M.G.		Index No. V-15416/21 V-24698/22\|Appeal No. 4903\|Case No. 2025-00007 2024-06582\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05567

**Cases Decided October 7, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
437 W. 36th St. LLC v ZDJ W 37 LLC		Index No. 156904/24\|Appeal No. 4871-4872\|Case No. 2025-01604, 2025-01605\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05448
Dluzen v Equinox Group		Index No. 158205/21\|Appeal No. 4886\|Case No. 2024-04577\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05486
Wayman v CPE Hous. Dev. Fund Co., Inc.		Index No. 25691/20 Case No. 2024-07915 Appeal No. 4865	2025 NY Slip Op 05485
Matter of D.W. v D.W.		Docket No. O-01750/21, O-01745/21\|Appeal No. 4869\|Case No. 2025-01203, 2025-01204\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05484
Matter of T.G.V. v K.P.K.		Docket No. G-1406/22\|Appeal No. 4854\|Case No. 2024-05680\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05483
Spring Scaffolding LLC v Krall		Index No. 159748/23\|Appeal No. 4868\|Case No. 2024-05969\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05482
Rosenblum v Treitler		Index No. 654177/15\|Appeal No. 4873-4874\|Case No. 2024-04525, 2024-06869\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05481
People v McEnaney		Ind. No. 70297/22\|Appeal No. 4882\|Case No. 2024-01428\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05480
People v Carrion		Ind. No. 74593/23\|Appeal No. 4851\|Case No. 2024-05490\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05479
People v Andino		Ind. No. 1029/17\|Appeal No. 4842\|Case No. 2018-04169\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05478
People v Normil		Ind. No. 72564/22\|Appeal No. 4888\|Case No. 2024-01718\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05477
People v Jose S.		Ind. No. 1274/12\|Appeal No. 4853, 4853A\|Case No. 2023-06021\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05476
People v Luis		Ind. No. 0032/20\|Appeal No. 4857\|Case No. 2022-05224\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05475
People v Joel R.		Ind. No. 71378/22\|Appeal No. 4889\|Case No. 2024-04821\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05474
People v Martinez		Ind. No. 74113/22\|Appeal No. 4847\|Case No. 2024-06181\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05473
People v Martinez		Ind. No. 75230/22\|Appeal No. 4848\|Case No. 2024-06135\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05472
People v Orellana		Ind. No. 71503/23\|Appeal No. 4863\|Case No. 2025-00874\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05471
People v Compres-Moreno		Ind. No. 68/19\|Appeal No. 4887\|Case No. 2019-04665\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05470
People v Hooks		Ind. No. 2631/17\|Appeal No. 4858\|Case No. 2022-05592\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05469
People v B.D.		Ind. No. 2589/16\|Appeal No. 4867\|Case No. 2019-05343\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05468
People v Balaguer		Ind. No. 73167/23, 2129/19\|Appeal No. 4875, 4876\|Case No. 2023-06436, 2023-06439\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05467
Owens v Metropolitan Transp. Auth.		Index No. 160308/21\|Appeal No. 4892\|Case No. 2025-03052\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05466
New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal v Zara Realty Holding Corp.		Index No. 450245/19\|Appeal No. 4866\|Case No. 2023-05732\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05465
McGrane-Mungo v Dag Hammarskjold Tower		Index No. 159019/20, 595219/22\|Appeal No. 4885\|Case No. 2024-06476\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05464
Matter of Dratch	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-04258\|Case No. 2025-04797\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05463
Matter of D.K. v D.L.		Docket No. O-23059/22\|Appeal No. 4881\|Case No. 2023-05792\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05462
Julien Farel, LLC v Stove Props. USA, Inc.		Index No. 653122/19\|Appeal No. 4846\|Case No. 2024-05008\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05461
Homelink Intl. Inc. v Law Offs. of Sanjay Chaubey		Index No. 653822/24\|Appeal No. 4852\|Case No. 2024-07161\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05460
Green Tree Servicing LLC v Rivera		Index No. 380778/13\|Appeal No. 4850\|Case No. 2025-02604\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05459
Fine Creative Media, Inc. v Barnes & Noble, Inc.		Index No. 651141/23\|Appeal No. 4849\|Case No. 2024-05778\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05458
Emissions Reduction Corp. v mCloud Tech. (USA) Inc.		Index No. 655897/23\|Appeal No. 4884\|Case No. 2024-04653\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05457
Matter of Emeagwali v Department of Educ. of the City of N.Y.		Index No. 161422/19\|Appeal No. 4855\|Case No. 2024-03072\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05456
Eisner v Posillico Civ., Inc.		Index No. 21449/20\|Appeal No. 4880\|Case No. 2024-05122\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05455
Matter of Cuomo v JAMS, Inc.		Index No. 652945/23\|Appeal No. 4877-4878\|Case No. 2024-02157, 2024-02517\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05454
Commonwealth Land Tit. Ins. Co. v Sky Abstract, LLC		Index No. 159204/15\|Appeal No. 4890\|Case No. 2024-05468\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05453
Matter of Christine B. v Antonio G.		Docket No. V-27712/23\|Appeal No. 4844\|Case No. 2024-07379\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05452
Ali Baba Hotel Corp. v Prose		Index No. 150993/22\|Appeal No. 4860-4861, 4862\|Case No. 2024-04756, 2024-04778, 2024-06059\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05451
Ahsanuddin v Addo		Index No. 30571/17\|Appeal No. 4870\|Case No. 2024-06088\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05450
Matter of Acevedo v Citibank N.A.		Ind. No. 802892/21\|Appeal No. 4864\|Case No. 2024-02920\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05449

**Cases Decided October 2, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
21st Mtge. Corp. v Jin Hua Lin		Index No. 850085/18\|Appeal No. 4799\|Case No. 2024-07333\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05288
Zain v Ernest L. Isaacson, DPM, P.C.		Index No. 805136/21\|Appeal No. 4807\|Case No. 2025-00404\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05332
Hyun S. Yang v Griffin		Index No. 152620/24\|Appeal No. 4801\|Case No. 2024-04733\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05331
WarnerMedia Direct, LLC v Paramount Global		Index No. 651001/23\|Appeal No. 4820\|Case No. 2025-00747\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05330
Voorham v Hicks-Voorham		Index No. 365492/22\|Appeal No. 4813\|Case No. 2025-01616\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05329
Matter of Vazquez v New York State Off. of Children & Family Servs.		Docket No. 157860/20\|Appeal No. 4828\|Case No. 2024-03308\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05328
Samsung Elec.s Co., Ltd. v MPEG LA, L.L.C.		Index No. 656312/22\|Appeal No. 4810\|Case No. 2024-05978\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05327
Rodriguez v FGI Corp.		Index No. 157850/21\|Appeal No. 4822\|Case No. 2025-00127\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05326
Ramos v Ford Found.		Index No. 159885/17\|Appeal No. 4821\|Case No. 2024-06470\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05325
Raistone Purch. LLC-Series XLI v London Luxury LLC		Index No. 651488/23\|Appeal No. 4721\|Case No. 2024-02786\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05324
Matter of Serenity R. (Miguel R.)		Docket No. B9598/20\|Appeal No. 4819\|Case No. 2024-04069\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05323
Matter of Polesny v Capitti		Index No. 306954/18\|Appeal No. 4841\|Case No. 2025-04013\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05322
People v Rivera		Ind No. 2745/17\|Appeal No. 4701\|Case No. 2019-5145\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05321
People v Glasgow		Ind No. 74204/23, 03579/19\|Appeal No. 4797\|Case No. 2024-04364\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05320
People v Flores		Ind No. 73421/23\|Appeal No. 4798\|Case No. 2023-05557\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05319
People v Carrasquillo		Ind No. 72787/22\|Appeal No. 4836\|Case No. 2024-03393\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05318
People v Hardison		Ind No. 2988/01\|Appeal No. 4825\|Case No. 2024-00483\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05317
People v Alvarado		Ind No. 255/04\|Appeal No. 4811\|Case No. 2023-02650\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05316
People v Leak		Ind No. 72427/22\|Appeal No. 4803\|Case No. 2024-03082\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05315
People v Rivera		Ind No. 634/20\|Appeal No. 4830\|Case No. 2023-01916\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05314
People v JeanBaptiste		Ind No. 75363/22\|Appeal No. 4817\|Case No. 2023-03868\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05313
People v Maldonado		Ind No. 73259/22\|Appeal No. 4833\|Case No. 2023-02035\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05312
People v Jachero		Ind No. 3736/15\|Appeal No. 4794\|Case No. 2017-02377\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05311
People v Gordon		Ind No. 73839/22\|Appeal No. 4823\|Case No. 2022-05518\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05310
People v Scott		Ind No. 1138/21\|Appeal No. 4802\|Case No. 2022-03304\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05309
People v Balbi		Ind No. 998/20\|Appeal No. 4832\|Case No. 2024-02499\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05308
People v McCrae		Ind No. 306/17\|Appeal No. 4812\|Case No. 2018-03103\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05307
Matter of New York Life Ins. Co. v John Hancock Life Ins. Co. (U.S.A.)		Index No. 655745/23\|Appeal No. 4840\|Case No. 2025-01856\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05306
NewRez LLC v Morton		Index No. 850098/17\|Appeal No. 4815-4815A-4815B\|Case No. 2024-05483 2024-06166 2024-06167\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05305
Moore v Maley	Michael, J.	Index No. 22507/18\|Appeal No. 4240\|Case No. 2024-02148\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05304
KD-1 Doe v MC-Doe		Index No. 952138/23\|Appeal No. 4795\|Case No. 2024-03260\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05303
Johnson v Northeast Agencies Inc.		Index No. 809872/23\|Appeal No. 4808\|Case No. 2024-03868\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05302
Halgene Watch Ltd. v Alex Capital Fund, LLC		Index No. 654217/24\|Appeal No. 4826-4827\|Case No. 2025-00912 2025-00913\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05301
Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. v March		Index No. 381347/12\|Appeal No. 4708-4709\|Case No. 2024-07719 2025-02226\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05300
Matter of Shainiska D. v Gage D.		V-13977/22 V-13978/22 V-22811/22 V-22812/22\|Docket No. V-13977/22, V-13978/22, V-22811/22, V-22812/22\|Appeal No. 4796\|Case No. 2024-04579\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05299
Costanzo v American Academy of Dramatic Arts		Index No. 160453/17\|Appeal No. 4824\|Case No. 2024-03861\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05298
Matter of Carrasquillo v Lewis		Index No. 01132/16\|Appeal No. 4816\|Case No. 2025-03442\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05297
Matter of Cani v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.		Index No. 806790/24\|Appeal No. 4839\|Case No. 2024-05447\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05296
Matter of Damien W.C. v Melissa S.		Docket No. V-19906/18 V-19907/18\|Appeal No. 4805\|Case No. 2024-06288\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05295
Brewster v Hunter		Index No. 28027/18\|Appeal No. 4800\|Case No. 2024-03992\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05294
Matter of Bodenchak v 5178 Holdings LLC		Index No. 152916/24\|Appeal No. 4838\|Case No. 2025-03424\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05293
Beals v Roman Catholic Archdiocese of N.Y.		Index No. 950159/19\|Appeal No. 4837\|Case No. 2025-00834\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05292
Matter of Barger v Malkin		Index No. 653772/23\|Appeal No. 4814\|Case No. 2024-04931\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05291
Apex Funding Source, LLC v Blue Earth Resources, Inc.		Index No. 654552/23\|Appeal No. 4804\|Case No. 2024-07637\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05290
2814 Morris LLC v Ortega		Index No. 804221/21\|Appeal No. 4818\|Case No. 2025-01830\|	2025 NY Slip Op 05289