Appellate Division, Second Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided January 31, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Seeham Ayach v Olga Ghazal		2005-03450	2006 NY Slip Op 00616
David Bregman v Douglas Finn		2004-09085	2006 NY Slip Op 00617
Henrietta Broadie v St. Francis Hospital		2004-06705	2006 NY Slip Op 00618
Jane Browdame v Lewis J. Candura		2004-08834	2006 NY Slip Op 00619
Diane Corrado v Marilyn C. Rubine		2004-09508	2006 NY Slip Op 00620
Hubert Dessain v Jean Franklin		2005-01936	2006 NY Slip Op 00621
Nicola DeVito v Oi Ying Ho		2004-04490	2006 NY Slip Op 00622
Juan Fernandez v Ahmed E. Elemam		2005-00312	2006 NY Slip Op 00623
Nicola Ferrara v N.Y. & Atlantic Railway Co.		2004-07272	2006 NY Slip Op 00624
Edward Fitzpatrick v State of New York		2004-06704	2006 NY Slip Op 00625
Desiree Gagliardotto v Huntington Hospital		2004-05599	2006 NY Slip Op 00626
Tony T. Gjokaj v Jean Fox		2004-09353	2006 NY Slip Op 00627
Daniel Hageman v Home Depot U.S.A., Inc.		2004-06058	2006 NY Slip Op 00628
Jennifer S. Hes v New York City Transit Authority		2005-03333	2006 NY Slip Op 00629
Paul Iorizzo v Alfred Mattikow		2005-01469	2006 NY Slip Op 00630
John Joseph v Insureco, Inc.		2004-08308	2006 NY Slip Op 00631
Melvyn Kaufman v Elizabeth Kehler		2005-00030	2006 NY Slip Op 00632
Victor Klein v Robert's American Gourmet Food, Inc.	F I S H E R	2003-00553	2006 NY Slip Op 00633
L&S Motors, Inc. v Broadview Networks, Inc.		2005-03284	2006 NY Slip Op 00634
Diane F. Leibel v Flynn Hill Elevator Company		2004-09524	2006 NY Slip Op 00635
Sean Lester v Francis Braue		2003-11189	2006 NY Slip Op 00636
Ilya Makaron v Luna Park Housing Corporation		2005-01945	2006 NY Slip Op 00637
9394, Llc v Dean Kehler		2004-08005	2006 NY Slip Op 00638
Beatriz Perez v City of New York		2005-03250	2006 NY Slip Op 00639
Merida Pina v Flik International Corp.		2005-01804	2006 NY Slip Op 00640
Carlos R. Ramos v Castega-20 Vesey Street, LLC		2004-09276	2006 NY Slip Op 00641
Yarimith Sanchez v City of New York		2004-07814	2006 NY Slip Op 00642
Albert Simmons v Rafael M. Pantoja		2005-01325	2006 NY Slip Op 00643
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company v Deirdre Sparacio		2004-08669	2006 NY Slip Op 00644
Gregory Tarone v Madeleine Tarone		2004-00806	2006 NY Slip Op 00645
Katherine Tarone v Gregory J. Tarone		2004-09894	2006 NY Slip Op 00646
Denise Terio v Lance Roger Spodek		2004-01601	2006 NY Slip Op 00647
Carol Ann Thomas v Leonard Smith		2004-10643	2006 NY Slip Op 00648
TPZ Corporation v Lucille Dabbs		2003-03516	2006 NY Slip Op 00649
Glen S. Udell v Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States		2004-05837	2006 NY Slip Op 00650
Paula Wilkins v Alexander Burgess		2005-03681	2006 NY Slip Op 00651
Xand Corporation v Reliable Systems Alternatives Corporation		2005-05027	2006 NY Slip Op 00652
Matter of Mina Bronstein-Becher v Yehudah Becher		2004-11005	2006 NY Slip Op 00653
Matter of George J. Cotz	Per Curiam	2005-05629	2006 NY Slip Op 00654
Matter of Patricia Griffin v Daniel B. Griffin		2004-02133	2006 NY Slip Op 00655
Matter of Alfredo H.		2004-10031	2006 NY Slip Op 00656
Matter of Julie A. Hughes v State of New York		2005-01358	2006 NY Slip Op 00657
Matter of Aleksander Keylikhes v Elena Kiejliches		2004-03399	2006 NY Slip Op 00658
Matter of John Park v John A. Kapica		2003-10212	2006 NY Slip Op 00659
Matter of John Park v John A. Kapica		2004-06783	2006 NY Slip Op 00660
Matter of Craig E. Parles	Per Curiam	2005-07645	2006 NY Slip Op 00661
Matter of T'Challaarkiesha Janette Jouslin R.-D. v Shavonne R.		2004-05367	2006 NY Slip Op 00662
Matter of Joseph S.		2004-00154	2006 NY Slip Op 00663
Matter of Joshua T. v John T.		2005-00688	2006 NY Slip Op 00664
People v Bernard Diggs		2003-10095	2006 NY Slip Op 00665
People v Errol Garvey		2003-06954	2006 NY Slip Op 00666
People v Jermaine Jackson		2003-06111	2006 NY Slip Op 00667
People v Vaughn Jones		2003-04652	2006 NY Slip Op 00668
People v Charles Kimbrough		2002-09952	2006 NY Slip Op 00669
People v Joseph Linyear		2004-04515	2006 NY Slip Op 00670
People v Brian Ortiz		2004-01007	2006 NY Slip Op 00671
People v Ruben Pagan		2003-05017	2006 NY Slip Op 00672
People v Benjamin Sherman		2003-05982	2006 NY Slip Op 00673
People v Sergio Ulysse		2003-03313	2006 NY Slip Op 00674

**Cases Decided January 26, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Beatriz Fuentes v George Aluskewicz		2005-01429	2006 NY Slip Op 00542
Nitza Keane v rank M. Keane		2004-00109	2006 NY Slip Op 00543
David W. v State of New York	Ritter, J.	2004-08544	2006 NY Slip Op 00544
Noel Wright v N.Y.C. Health and Hospitals Corp.		2004-07530	2006 NY Slip Op 00545
Matter of Brian H. v Jose V.		2004-08188	2006 NY Slip Op 00546
Matter of Brian H. v Jose V.		2005-00880	2006 NY Slip Op 00547
Matter of State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company v Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corp.		2004-10447	2006 NY Slip Op 00548
People v Miles Hasty		2003-08385	2006 NY Slip Op 00549

**Cases Decided January 24, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Aimco Chelsea Land, LLC v Joan R. Bassey		2004-08469	2006 NY Slip Op 00462
Marc Beck v Northside Medical		2004-07515	2006 NY Slip Op 00463
Christian P. Benefield v Halmar Corporation		2004-01287	2006 NY Slip Op 00464
Stephen Beyel v Eduardo Console		2004-08115	2006 NY Slip Op 00465
Board of Education of Mamaroneck Union Free School District v Attorney-General of State of New York		2005-05730	2006 NY Slip Op 00466
Murray R. Braun v Gloria May Rosenblum		2005-00565	2006 NY Slip Op 00467
Peter Byrne v Paul K. Leblond		2005-00477	2006 NY Slip Op 00468
Coinmach Corp. v Alley Pond Owners Corp.		2005-10059	2006 NY Slip Op 00469
Crum and Foster Insurance Co. v State of New York		2004-09856	2006 NY Slip Op 00470
Helen Deitz v Anne M. Huibregtse		2003-05446	2006 NY Slip Op 00471
Michael DeNicola v Assured Sprinkler and Mechanical, Inc.		2004-06716	2006 NY Slip Op 00472
Timothy Farmer v City of New York		2004-01973	2006 NY Slip Op 00473
Timothy Farmer v City of New York		2004-04816	2006 NY Slip Op 00474
Mary Gainey v Hubert Anorzej		2004-10177	2006 NY Slip Op 00475
Rachel Gluck v Fantastic, Inc.		2004-07904	2006 NY Slip Op 00476
Nancy Gonzalez v Jamaica Hospital		2004-06482	2006 NY Slip Op 00477
Milan Handlovic v Bedford Park Development, Inc.		2004-09586	2006 NY Slip Op 00478
Lori J. Hudson v Allstate Insurance Company		2004-09841	2006 NY Slip Op 00479
Mohamed Jaffer v Daniel J. Goldstein		2004-10870	2006 NY Slip Op 00480
John Kingston v Michael Breslin		2004-07277	2006 NY Slip Op 00481
John Kingston v Michael Breslin		2004-10262	2006 NY Slip Op 00482
Liberty Mutual Insurance Company v Hartford Insurance Company of the Midwest		2004-07291	2006 NY Slip Op 00483
Michael Locicero v Princeton Restoration, Inc.		2004-03444	2006 NY Slip Op 00484
Theresa Lolly v Brookdale University Hospital and Medical Center		2005-06791	2006 NY Slip Op 00485
Long Island Sound, LLC v O'Brien & Gere Engineers, Inc.		2004-07025	2006 NY Slip Op 00486
Philip Mahler v Milta Torres		2005-03596	2006 NY Slip Op 00487
Solomon Mesholam v Isabelle Helene Mesholam		2004-00800	2006 NY Slip Op 00488
Linda Moore v Challar A. Edison		2005-04656	2006 NY Slip Op 00489
Mount Sinai Hospital v Allstate Insurance Company		2005-05298	2006 NY Slip Op 00490
Peter Muller v Waring Abbott		2004-11264	2006 NY Slip Op 00491
NPR, LLC v K.A.B.B., Inc.		2004-09313	2006 NY Slip Op 00492
People v Jeannette Hegazy		2004-06366	2006 NY Slip Op 00493
People v Herbert H. White		2005-01882	2006 NY Slip Op 00494
Richard Pickering v Lehrer, McGovern, Bovis, Incorporated		2004-08939	2006 NY Slip Op 00495
Edgar Hernandez Ramirez v Juan Romualdo		2005-03835	2006 NY Slip Op 00496
Re-Max Classic Realty, Inc. v Howard Berger		2004-04499	2006 NY Slip Op 00497
Pasquale Romeo v Ronald McDonald House		2004-07615	2006 NY Slip Op 00498
Reina Romero v Metropolitan Suburban Bus Authority		2004-09532	2006 NY Slip Op 00499
Susan Sommers v Harold Sommers		2003-09683	2006 NY Slip Op 00500
Michael Swift v New York Medical College		2005-02972	2006 NY Slip Op 00501
Unclaimed Property Recovery Service, Inc. v Chase Manhattan Bank		2004-10231	2006 NY Slip Op 00502
Scott Unger v Theodore Leviton		2003-09547	2006 NY Slip Op 00503
Joann Vasta v Home Depot		2005-00264	2006 NY Slip Op 00504
Joseph Vitarelli v Excel Automotive Tech. Center, Inc.		2005-04880	2006 NY Slip Op 00505
Pamela Zito v Gary Zabarsky	Luciano	2004-01148	2006 NY Slip Op 00506
Matter of Sonya Moody Barksdale	Per Curiam	2001-03751	2006 NY Slip Op 00507
Matter of Misa Brim v Sean Combs		2004-08406	2006 NY Slip Op 00508
Matter of Cathedral Fourth Development Corp. v Board of Assessors and Assessment Review Commission of County of Nassau		2004-00967	2006 NY Slip Op 00509
Matter of James E. Davis	Goldstein	2005-02657	2006 NY Slip Op 00510
Matter of Eveready Insurance Company v Joseph Modeste		2005-06472	2006 NY Slip Op 00511
Matter of Carl F.		2004-06623	2006 NY Slip Op 00512
Matter of Donald Feola v Patrick J. Carroll		2004-09356	2006 NY Slip Op 00513
Matter of Lucille Figuereo v Joshua Lipsman		2004-00707	2006 NY Slip Op 00514
Matter of Judith Finell v Steven Finell		2004-09887	2006 NY Slip Op 00515
Matter of Marie H. v Julie M.		2004-05970	2006 NY Slip Op 00516
Matter of George E. Kearsey	Per Curiam	2004-03783	2006 NY Slip Op 00517
Matter of Michael Matthews v New York State Department of Environmental Conservation		2005-01475	2006 NY Slip Op 00518
Matter of Andre Moore v Michael Gary		2005-11139,	2006 NY Slip Op 00519
Matter of Clarence Norman	Per Curiam	2005-09739	2006 NY Slip Op 00520
Matter of Jamal S.		2004-10987	2006 NY Slip Op 00521
Matter of State-Wide Insurance Company v Tamey Womble		2005-06781	2006 NY Slip Op 00522
Matter of Donna G. Steward v Clifford A. Steward		2004-10093	2006 NY Slip Op 00523
Matter of Tyrelle T.		2004-08961	2006 NY Slip Op 00524
Matter of 3202 Owners Corp. v Billy Contractors, Inc.		2005-02504	2006 NY Slip Op 00525
Matter of Cathleen Tokarz v Michael Loughlin		2005-03672	2006 NY Slip Op 00526
Matter of Paula M.Venezia		2004-09874	2006 NY Slip Op 00527
Matter of Brian Zazulka v New York State Department of Environmental Conservation		2005-02521	2006 NY Slip Op 00528
People v Terrance Breazil		2002-07522	2006 NY Slip Op 00529
People v Jason Bullock		2004-05789	2006 NY Slip Op 00530
People v Thomas Burke		2004-00592	2006 NY Slip Op 00531
People v Timothy Burks		2004-11001	2006 NY Slip Op 00532
People v Kevin Gambichler		2004-05441	2006 NY Slip Op 00533
People v Jemel Goode		2005-00731	2006 NY Slip Op 00534
People v Travis Hill		2004-08532	2006 NY Slip Op 00535
People v Bethel Jones		2003-08030	2006 NY Slip Op 00536
People v Derek Josey		2001-08655	2006 NY Slip Op 00537
People v Victor M. Santos		2004-08110	2006 NY Slip Op 00538
People v Erin Thurmond		2004-07002	2006 NY Slip Op 00539
People v Joshua Ward		2004-09341	2006 NY Slip Op 00540
People v Mario Zhenin		2005-01743	2006 NY Slip Op 00541

**Cases Decided January 17, 2006**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Alberta Albright v City of New York	2004-06936	2006 NY Slip Op 00327
Larry R. Alexander v Kevin J. Womble	2005-01506	2006 NY Slip Op 00328
Linda Cendales v City of New York	2004-07706	2006 NY Slip Op 00329
Pawel Czernicki v Marek Lawniczak	2005-02281	2006 NY Slip Op 00330
Lorraine Evans v John Craig	2004-08205	2006 NY Slip Op 00331
Sinclair Haberman v City of Long Beach	2004-05668	2006 NY Slip Op 00332
Sinclair Haberman v City of Long Beach	2005-02529	2006 NY Slip Op 00333
Cathy Hall v Barist Elevator Company	2004-09921	2006 NY Slip Op 00334
Binna Han v Chungwon Bark	2005-01330	2006 NY Slip Op 00335
Yvonne Hayes v Nachelle Wilson	2004-09558	2006 NY Slip Op 00336
Samei Jamal v Pravina V. Gohel	2004-03850	2006 NY Slip Op 00337
Victor La Maina v Nathan's Famous, Inc.	2004-05326	2006 NY Slip Op 00338
Concetta Lucchese v Evan S. Silverman	2004-02835	2006 NY Slip Op 00339
Gary Mankiewicz v Jacqueline Excellent	2004-09406	2006 NY Slip Op 00340
Gabrielle D. Nachman v Jenelo Corp.	2005-02224	2006 NY Slip Op 00341
Elbio Paradis v F. L. Smithe Machine Co., Inc.	2005-04400	2006 NY Slip Op 00342
Robert M. Richter v Davidson & Cohen, P.C.	2004-05729	2006 NY Slip Op 00343
Alan Rosenfeld v Community School District #28	2004-06452	2006 NY Slip Op 00344
Carol T. Seaman v Wyckoff Heights Medical Center, Inc.	2005-02044	2006 NY Slip Op 00345
Carol T. Seaman v Wyckoff Heights Medical Center, Inc.	2005-03542	2006 NY Slip Op 00346
Regina Smith v Leslie G. Nameth	2005-02084	2006 NY Slip Op 00347
Ingrid Tortola v NHT Owners, LLC	2005-06669	2006 NY Slip Op 00348
Tri-Global Management Corp. v Charles Richardson	2005-03069	2006 NY Slip Op 00349
Jill Winters v James Winters	2005-04775	2006 NY Slip Op 00350
Charles O. Wright v Cetek Technologies, Inc.	2005-02508	2006 NY Slip Op 00351
Francis M. Zilinski v Michael Graziano	2005-00992	2006 NY Slip Op 00352
Matter of Diana Aitola v New York City Employees' Retirement System	2004-09726	2006 NY Slip Op 00353
Matter of Elizabeth Brilliant v David Gamache	2005-11816	2006 NY Slip Op 00354
Matter of Seasia D. v Mr. and Mrs.	2005-03488	2006 NY Slip Op 00355
Matter of Mark I. Eromosele v Robert A. Ross	2005-10667	2006 NY Slip Op 00356
Matter of Carlton F.	2004-01291	2006 NY Slip Op 00357
Matter of Catherine Greene v Zoning Board of Appeals of Town of Islip	2004-07309	2006 NY Slip Op 00358
Matter of Qwasan M.	2004-07145	2006 NY Slip Op 00359
Matter of Kristin Nilsen v Robert Slowey	2004-08898	2006 NY Slip Op 00360
Matter of Antoine P.	2005-04404	2006 NY Slip Op 00361
Matter of Rockland County Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, Inc. v Patricia Prendergast	2004-06127	2006 NY Slip Op 00362
Matter of Utica Mutual Insurance Co. v Jose Colon	2004-07728	2006 NY Slip Op 00363
People v Maynard Archer	2004-01321	2006 NY Slip Op 00364
People v Tony Curtis	2004-01805	2006 NY Slip Op 00365
People v Joseph Garcia	2003-08084	2006 NY Slip Op 00366
People v Johannes Gonzalez	2003-05788	2006 NY Slip Op 00367
People v Larry Holmes	2002-10992	2006 NY Slip Op 00368
People v Garrol Jones	2002-10992	2006 NY Slip Op 00369
People v Richard Kearney	2003-08545	2006 NY Slip Op 00370
People v Kevin Langston	2003-06949	2006 NY Slip Op 00371
People v Jaquan Levly	2004-04799	2006 NY Slip Op 00372
People v Gardel Morales	2002-05823	2006 NY Slip Op 00373
People v Sagin Persaud	2003-07066	2006 NY Slip Op 00374
People v Tyrone Rolle	1999-03368	2006 NY Slip Op 00375
People v Vernon Roper	2004-01687	2006 NY Slip Op 00376
People v Robert Shervington	2003-04041	2006 NY Slip Op 00377
People v Marvin Stewartson	2000-03599	2006 NY Slip Op 00378

**Cases Decided January 10, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
ATIFA v Mohammed Akbar Shairzad		2004-07661	2006 NY Slip Op 00135
Victor Alesi v Underforming and Foundation Construction, Inc.		2005-02000	2006 NY Slip Op 00136
Anthony Campagna v Julie Arleo		2003-04086	2006 NY Slip Op 00137
Smithy E. Dunbar v Lorraine E. Dunbar		2004-03048	2006 NY Slip Op 00138
Frost Line Refrigeration, Inc. v Gastwirth, Mirsky & Stein, LLP		2005-03137	2006 NY Slip Op 00139
Carol Glick v Russell Glick		2004-06728	2006 NY Slip Op 00140
Hospital for Joint Diseases v Dollar Rent A Car		2005-01011	2006 NY Slip Op 00141
Izko Sportswear Co., Inc. v Neil R. Flaum		2004-00279, 2004-01167, 2004-05260	2006 NY Slip Op 00142
Deborah Miller v Allan B. Miller		2004-06434	2006 NY Slip Op 00143
Beatrice Putter v North Shore University Hospital		2003-10891	2006 NY Slip Op 00144
Patricia Ramirez v Robert A. Jacobs		2004-06700	2006 NY Slip Op 00145
Theresa Schmidt v Thomas DiPerno		2005-01622	2006 NY Slip Op 00146
Sandra Soto v New York City Transit Authority		2005-00748	2006 NY Slip Op 00147
Lori Stadok v Ishay Stadok		2004-07042	2006 NY Slip Op 00148
Ronald M. Terlizzese v Robinson's Custom Service, Inc.		2005-02118	2006 NY Slip Op 00149
Rachel Torres v Safety Cab Corp.		2005-00134	2006 NY Slip Op 00150
Shari Vail v KMart Corporation		2001-05997	2006 NY Slip Op 00151
Matter of Joseph Correia v Incorporated Village of Northport		2004-06070	2006 NY Slip Op 00152
Matter of Andrew F. Fisher v Christine DeFlora		2004-09936	2006 NY Slip Op 00153
Matter of Derek G.		2005-01120	2006 NY Slip Op 00154
Matter of Louis Gelsomino v City of New Rochelle		2004-07209	2006 NY Slip Op 00155
Matter of Gerald Goll	Per Curiam	2003-10710	2006 NY Slip Op 00156
Matter of John R. Haberman	Per Curiam	2004-04345	2006 NY Slip Op 00157
Matter of Matrice L.		2005-02014	2006 NY Slip Op 00158
Matter of Leslie L. McIver-Heyward v Richard Heyward		2005-01083	2006 NY Slip Op 00159
Matter of Rohan McM.		2005-03402	2006 NY Slip Op 00160
Matter of Joseph J. Milano	Per Curiam	2005-09482	2006 NY Slip Op 00161
Matter of Keven Plummer v Dana Plummer		2005-01871	2006 NY Slip Op 00162
Matter of Star Jada Rivera v Department of Education, City of New York		2005-01380	2006 NY Slip Op 00163
Matter of Michael J. Rosenblatt	Per Curiam	2004-09734	2006 NY Slip Op 00164
Matter of Brittany W. v Eileen Horn		2004-11168	2006 NY Slip Op 00165
People v Manuel Alvarenga		2002-04229	2006 NY Slip Op 00166
People v Frank Baylor		2003-10596	2006 NY Slip Op 00167
People v Alex Campbell		2004-03432	2006 NY Slip Op 00168
People v Jose Corea		2002-04806	2006 NY Slip Op 00169
People v Edwin Cruz		2004-01649	2006 NY Slip Op 00170
People v Dion Greene		1998-04028	2006 NY Slip Op 00171
People v Lorgio Hernandez		2002-10894	2006 NY Slip Op 00172
People v Everett Holloway		2004-11248	2006 NY Slip Op 00173
People v Jearmy Kennedy		2002-03772	2006 NY Slip Op 00174
People v Mohammed Kliti		2003-00634	2006 NY Slip Op 00175
People v Edwin Larios		2002-05248	2006 NY Slip Op 00176
People v Erick Martinez-Ramos		2004-06695	2006 NY Slip Op 00177
People v Mark McCurdy		2004-04905	2006 NY Slip Op 00178
People v Josiah McTier		2002-04912	2006 NY Slip Op 00179
People v Tremaine Patterson		2003-04295	2006 NY Slip Op 00180
People v Allah Pilgrim		2003-05372	2006 NY Slip Op 00181
People v Steven Scheufler		2004-10069	2006 NY Slip Op 00182
People v Thomas Smith		2004-00123	2006 NY Slip Op 00183
People v Mark A. White		2004-02372	2006 NY Slip Op 00184
People v Maurice Wynn		2004-03687	2006 NY Slip Op 00185