Cases Decided December 22, 2005
| Title |
Judge |
Docket No. |
Slip Opinion No. |
|---|
| E. Philip Saunders v Farm
Fans |
|
1117 CA 04-02865 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09813 |
| Cynthia Colello v Richard A.
Maussner |
|
1157 CA 05-00416 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09814 |
| Marcia M. Halpin v Town of
Lancaster |
|
1185 CA 05-01231 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09815 |
| Merchants Mutual Insurance Group v
Travelers Insurance Company |
|
1193 CA 05-01116 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09816 |
| Matter of Matthew B. v Kimberly
B. |
|
1196 CAF 04-00825 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09817 |
| People v Shane Andrews |
|
1204.1 KA 05-01511 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09818 |
| People v Audley Fagan |
|
1209 KA 03-00434 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09819 |
| Keith Worden v Solvay Paperboard,
Llc |
|
1222 CA 05-00866 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09820 |
| Sharon J. Benty v First Methodist Church of
Oakfield |
|
1263 CA 05-00144 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09821 |
| Stacy L. Rak v Ken R.
Kossakowski |
|
1265 CA 05-01160 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09822 |
| Thomas Barton v Edward
Youmans |
|
1266 CA 05-01028 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09823 |
| Brendan B. Keavey v New York State
Dormitory Authority |
|
1273 CA 05-01032 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09824 |
| Feher Rubbish Removal, Inc. v New York
State Department of Labor, Bureau of Public Works |
Pine |
1286 CA 05-01118 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09825 |
| Syracuse Haulers Waste Removal, Inc. v
New York State Department of Labor, Bureau of Public Works |
Pine |
1294 CA 05-01119 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09826 |
| People v Brandon J. Bolling |
|
1305 KA 03-00146 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09827 |
| Dan Trevett v City of Little Falls |
|
1324 CA 05-00604 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09828 |
| Thomas Kish v Victor N. Farley |
|
1326 CA 05-00973 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09829 |
| Matter of Sean R.P. |
|
1333 CAF 04-03000 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09830 |
| Steven Searley v Wegmans Food Markets,
Inc. |
|
1364 CA 05-00919 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09831 |
| Matter of John Holehan |
|
1365 CA 05-00970 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09832 |
| Fulton Tool Co., Inc. v United States Life
Insurance Company |
|
1367 CA 05-00711 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09833 |
| Fulton Tool Co., Inc. v United States Life
Insurance Company |
|
1368 CA 05-00712 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09834 |
| Randall D. Foster v James R.
Kanous |
|
1370.1 CA 05-01928 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09835 |
| Randall D. Foster v James R.
Kanous |
|
1370 CA 05-00341 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09836 |
| Maria Cameron v Joyce A. Steel |
|
1372 CA 05-01212 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09837 |
| People v Steven Farnsworth |
|
1374 KA 04-02645 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09838 |
| People v Brenda K. Skardinski |
|
1381 KA 05-00009 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09839 |
| Stanley J. Ciura v Richard Muto |
|
1403 CA 05-00718 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09840 |
| Stanley J. Ciura v Richard Muto |
|
1404 CA 05-00719 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09841 |
| Stanley J. Ciura v Richard Muto |
|
1405 CA 05-00720 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09842 |
| Peter L. Petrosino v Robert P.
Petrosino |
|
1408 CA 04-01725 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09843 |
| James Bounds v State of New
York |
|
1412 CA 05-00601 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09844 |
| Matter of Michele Malecki v Thomas
Fernandez |
|
1414 CAF 05-00150 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09845 |
| People v Jack Vigliotti |
|
1422 KA 02-01913 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09846 |
| Judith K. Capruso v Reinardo
Castoire |
|
1429 CA 05-01356 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09847 |
| Jack Vigliotti v State of New York |
|
1431 CA 05-00385 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09848 |
| Matter of Cherie Dunsmoor |
|
1433 CA 05-01495 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09849 |
| David E. Neff v Mark Brassie |
|
1436 CA 05-01582 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09850 |
| Matter of Robert Baird v Billie Lynn
Holt |
|
1437 CAF 03-02459 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09851 |
| People v Timothy Waz |
|
1438 KA 04-00775 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09852 |
| People v Christopher D. White |
|
1439 KA 04-00228 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09853 |
| People v Des D. Hollis |
|
1440 KA 04-00375 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09854 |
| People v Robert H. Jeffery |
|
1441 KA 04-00043 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09855 |
| People v Darwin J. Fifield |
|
1443 KA 04-01024 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09856 |
| People v Orlando Melendez |
|
1445 KA 04-00211 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09857 |
| People v Karen A. Petrianni |
|
1446 KA 03-02576 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09858 |
| People v Michael Clark |
|
1447 KA 04-00287 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09859 |
| People v Caleaf Rashard Harrison |
|
1448 KA 03-00058 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09860 |
| Amherst Paving, Inc. v Paul J. Gallo
Contracting, Inc. |
|
1449 CA 05-01571 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09861 |
| David R. D'Alessandro v Eastman Kodak
Company |
|
1450 CA 05-00462 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09862 |
| Edgewater Construction Co., Inc. v 81 & 3
of Watertown, Inc. |
|
1451 CA 05-01598 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09863 |
| Edgewater Construction Co., Inc. v 81 & 3
of Watertown, Inc. |
|
1452 CA 05-02226 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09864 |
| Matter of Kevin Degnan v Merritt
Rahn |
|
1453 CA 05-01092 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09865 |
| Joye Maracle v Joseph Curcio |
|
1454.1CA 05-02491 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09866 |
| Joye Maracle v Joseph Curcio |
|
1454 CA 05-00060 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09867 |
| Data-Track Account Services, Inc. v Curtis
W. Lee |
|
1455 CA 05-00268 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09868 |
| James A. Losurdo v Skyline Associates,
L.P. |
|
1456 CA 05-01328 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09869 |
| Loida M. Booth v Ronald Booth |
|
1457 CA 05-01102 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09870 |
| Michelle Ellsworth v James F.
Foley |
|
1458 CA 05-00961 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09871 |
| Matter of Gregory S. Victor v Rhonda
Carney |
|
1459 CAF 04-00759 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09872 |
| Matter of Kimberly Morris v J. Bradford
Morris |
|
1460 CAF 05-01602 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09873 |
| Matter of Nathaniel W. v Tina W. |
|
1461 CAF 05-00650 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09874 |
| Matter of Nathaniel W. v Matthew
W. |
|
1462 CAF 04-01569 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09875 |
| Matter of Humberto R. |
|
1463 CAF 05-01437 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09876 |
| People v Michael Wightman |
|
1464 KA 03-01426 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09877 |
| People v Craig Mc Knight |
|
1465 KA 04-02817 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09878 |
| People v Michael Thomas |
|
1466 KA 04-00054 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09879 |
| People v Kenneth Spearman |
|
1467 KA 04-02097 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09880 |
| People v Carlton Massey |
|
1468 KA 04-02748 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09881 |
| People v Martin Santiago |
|
1469 KA 03-02614 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09882 |
| People v Larry Little |
|
1470 KA 03-01918 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09883 |
| People v Robert Lee |
|
1471 KA 03-00065 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09884 |
| People v Wendell L. Fuqua |
|
1472 KA 03-01020 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09885 |
| People v Larry S. Yoho |
|
1473 KA 04-02684 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09886 |
| People v Sean Gordon |
|
1474 KA 03-02369 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09887 |
| People v Darren Loveland |
|
1475 KA 03-02027 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09888 |
| People v Joseph Auld |
|
1476 KA 04-00484 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09889 |
| People v Ferguson Igbinosun |
|
1477 KA 04-01292 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09890 |
| People v Steven A. Mullen |
|
1478 KA 04-02540 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09891 |
| People v Danny W. Pardee |
|
1479 KA 04-01201 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09892 |
| People v Matthew Smith |
|
1480 KA 03-00165 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09893 |
| Matter of John Mc Auley v Faith
Martin |
|
1481 CAF 04-01670 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09894 |
| James F. Volpe v James J. Volpe |
|
1485 CA 05-01094 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09895 |
| Mark Parker v Daniel W. Leonard |
|
1486 CA 05-01364 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09896 |
| La Fever Excavating, Inc. v Hartford Casualty
Insurance Company |
|
1487 CA 05-01380 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09897 |
| Lois E. Streiff v Clifford Fuel Company,
Inc. |
|
1490 CA 05-01473 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09898 |
| Matter of Patrick Burke v Glenn S.
Goord |
|
1491 TP 05-01554 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09899 |
| People v Samuel Beu |
|
1492 KA 03-02237 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09900 |
| People v Habib F. Johnson |
|
1493 KA 03-02274 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09901 |
| People v Damian Johnson |
|
1494 KA 03-02290 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09902 |
| People v Lucas L. Gates |
|
1495 KA 04-01272 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09903 |
| People v David Vega |
|
1496 KA 04-00365 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09904 |
| People v Norbert P. Kostyj |
|
1497 KA 05-01539 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09905 |
| People v Sidney L. Barker |
|
1498 KA 05-01594 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09906 |
| People v Ronnie A. Diggs |
|
1499 KA 03-01080 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09907 |
| People v William Robinson |
|
1500 KA 03-02490 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09908 |
| Matter of Carlos D. v Enedina E. |
|
1501 CAF 04-02111 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09909 |
| Matter of Duane C. Baker v Donna L.
Baker-Kelly |
|
1502 CAF 05-01508 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09910 |
| Matter of AES Somerset, LLC v Town of
Somerset |
|
1503 CA 05-01336 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09911 |
| Markan Corporation v Plane's Cayuga
Vineyard, Inc. |
|
1505 CA 05-01027 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09912 |
| Raymond Guarnieri v Essex Homes of
WNY |
|
1506 CA 05-01564 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09913 |
| Matter of Jerome Laine v Rochester Housing
Authority |
|
1507 CA 05-01501 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09914 |
| New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance
Company v Warlinda Hill |
|
1508 CA 05-00817 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09915 |
| People v Richard A. Castrechino |
|
1511.1 KA 03-00694 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09916 |
| Matter of Jose Colon v Glenn S.
Goord |
|
1512 TP 05-01552 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09917 |
| Matter of Darrell Shaw v Timothy J.
Murray |
|
1513 TP 05-01023 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09918 |
| People v Neal Taylor |
|
1515 KA 02-01973 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09919 |
| People v Thomas L. Mc Kinney |
|
1516 KA 04-02121 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09920 |
| People v Germaine V. Brown |
|
1517 KA 05-01331 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09921 |
| People v Christina Stevenson |
|
1518 KA 05-00239 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09922 |
| People v Kyle Mc Clain |
|
1519 KA 04-00844 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09923 |
| People v Augustine R. Rizzo |
|
1520 KA 04-01695 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09924 |
| People v Robert A. Prescott |
|
1521 KA 03-01981 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09925 |
| Matter of Kathleen M.K. v Brian
S.R. |
|
1522 CAF 04-02912 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09926 |
| Matter of Briana J. |
|
1523 CAF 05-01344 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09927 |
| Matter of Carl G. v Oneida County
Department of Social Services |
|
1524 CAF 04-02657 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09928 |
| Erik Trell v American Association of
Advancement of Science |
|
1525 CA 04-02334 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09929 |
| Julie K. Ciccarelli v Cotira, Inc. |
|
1526 CA 05-01274 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09930 |
| Diane Schaaf v Pork Chop, Inc. |
|
1527 CA 05-01390 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09931 |
| Lenz Hardware, Inc. v Board of Education,
Van Hornesville-Owen D. Young Central School District |
|
1537 CA 05-01584 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09932 |
| Matter of Destyni B. |
|
1544 CAF 04-02586 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09933 |
| Matter of Dustin B. v William J.B. |
|
1545 CAF 04-03040 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09934 |
| People v Maurice Mc Knight |
|
1546 KA 02-01433 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09935 |
| People v Serina J.C. |
|
1547 KA 04-00286 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09936 |
| People v Charles Simms |
|
1548 KA 04-02474 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09937 |
| People v Mazi Ware |
|
1549 KA 04-01542 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09938 |
| People v Jeffrey L. Haberer |
|
1551 KA 03-02449 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09939 |
| People v James Branch |
|
1553 KA 04-00939 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09940 |
| Matter of Paul Mitchell v Glenn S.
Goord |
|
1554 TP 04-03034 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09941 |
| People v James Colvin |
|
1555 KA 04-00170 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09942 |
| People v Victor D. Smith |
|
1556 KA 04-01035 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09943 |
| People v Rahsaan M. Samuels |
|
1557 KA 05-01690 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09944 |
| People v Hoyt Newton |
|
1558 KA 03-00818 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09945 |
| People v Gus Oldham |
|
1559 KA 04-00885 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09946 |
| Matter of Deborah P. v Kimberly
B. |
|
1563 CAF 05-01343 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09947 |
| Carl J. Dirschedl v Asher B. Blum |
|
1565 CA 05-01333 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09948 |
| Todd E. Shatkin, D.D.S. v Dawn M.
Drescher |
|
1569 CA 05-00323 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09949 |
| Todd E. Shatkin, D.D.S. v Dawn M.
Drescher |
|
1570 CA 05-00325 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09950 |
| Todd E. Shatkin, D.D.S. v Dawn M.
Drescher |
|
1571 CA 05-00326 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09951 |
| Timothy J. Filkins v Village of
Elbridge |
|
1574 CA 05-01127 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09952 |
| Anthony Romano v Rochester Downtown
Hotel, Inc. |
|
1578 CA 05-00775 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09953 |
| Frank Tornatola v Greece Central School
District |
|
1579 CA 05-01399 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09954 |
| Matter of Dean Wright v Glenn S.
Goord |
|
1580 CA 05-00320 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09955 |
| Jeff Hebblethwaite v Town of
Amherst |
|
1581 CA 05-01507 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09956 |
| Gloria Allen v General Electric Co. |
|
1582 CA 05-01503 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09957 |
| Kathleen Shumway v William V. Craig, M.D.,
P.C. |
|
1583 CA 05-00663 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09958 |
| Kristie M. Petroski v Jeffrey J.
Petroski |
|
1584 CA 05-01499 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09959 |
| Asenath Atwal v Amarjit Atwal |
|
1586 CA 05-01453 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09960 |
| Matter of Michael P. v Anita S. |
|
1592 CAF 04-01877 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09961 |
| Matter of Brittany S. |
|
1593 CAF 04-02249 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09962 |
| People v Woodrow I. Abrams |
|
1594 KA 04-02781 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09963 |
| People v Khali Ali |
|
1597 KA 04-00685 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09964 |
| People v Joseph Woody |
|
1599 KA 04-01534 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09965 |
| People v Gary Smith |
|
1600 KA 04-02057 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09966 |
| Kenneth Thagard v Can Am Rapid Courier,
Inc. |
|
1602.1 CA 04-02891 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09967 |
| Matter of Walter Ball v Glenn S.
Goord |
|
1603 TP 05-01550 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09968 |
| Matter of Philip Congilaro v Glenn S.
Goord |
|
1604 TP 05-01551 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09969 |
| Matter of Danielle Trusso v Board of
Education of Jamestown City School District |
|
1605 CA 05-01451 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09970 |
| Charles H. Miller v Patsy Cappara |
|
1606 CA 05-01456 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09971 |
| Matter of Jessica Lindstrom v Board of
Education of Jamestown City School District |
|
1610 CA 05-01452 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09972 |
| Matter of Justin S. |
|
1612 CAF 05-01614 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09973 |
| Matter of Kevin K.O. v Tracy O. |
|
1613 CAF 04-01957 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09974 |
| People v Michael Sayles |
|
1615 KA 04-01080 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09975 |
| People v James High |
|
1616 KA 03-00911 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09976 |
| People v Joseph Oliver |
|
1619 KA 03-02575 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09977 |
| People v Michael Matthews |
|
1620 KA 04-01651 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09978 |
| People v Dwight J. Primm |
|
1621 KA 04-00049 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09979 |
| People v Jose Ayuso |
|
1625 KA 04-02416 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09980 |
| People v Erwin Lee |
|
1626 KA 03-01917 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09981 |
| People v Gregory White |
|
1627 KA 04-02294 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09982 |
| People v Elijah Jenkins |
|
1628 KA 04-00458 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09983 |
| People v Dana Sanders |
|
1631 KA 03-02240 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09984 |
| Matter of Veronica S.-O. v Desiree
S. |
|
1632 CAF 05-00477 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09985 |
| Matter of Tatiana O.-S. v Desiree
S. |
|
1633 CAF 05-00478 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09986 |
| Matter of Susan K. Hustleby v Byron-Bergen
Central School District |
|
1641 CA 05-01505 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09987 |
| Matter of Susan K. Hustleby v Byron-Bergen
Central School District |
|
1642 CA 05-01717 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09988 |
| Tufty Ceramics v Village of
Andover |
|
1643 CA 05-01465 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09989 |
| Matter of Alfred C. Blanche v Glenn S.
Goord |
|
1645 TP 05-01553 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09990 |
| Matter of Leo A. Marino v Thomas M.
Poole |
|
1646 TP 04-02177 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09991 |
| Matter of Pyramid Company of Watertown v
Planning Board of Town of Watertown |
|
1647 CA 05-01653 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09992 |
| Pamela J. Campbell v International Truck and
Engine Corporation |
|
1648 CA 05-01581 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09993 |
| Robert C. Andrews v Chad
Edwards |
|
1649 CA 05-01466 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09994 |
| William J. De Line v CitiCapital Commercial
Corporation |
|
1650 CA 05-01388 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09995 |
| Janet Gallinger v Pasquale Scutari,
D.D.S. |
|
1651 CA 05-01272 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09996 |
| Matter of Pyramid Company of Watertown v
Planning Board of Town of Watertown |
|
1652 CA 05-01389 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09997 |
| Thomas H. Aton v Syracuse
University |
|
1653 CA 05-01586 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09998 |
| Stuart Vogelmann v JLT Services
Corporation |
|
1654 CA 05-00574 |
2005 NY Slip Op 09999 |
| People v Davon M. Griffin |
|
1655 KA 03-02629 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10000 |
| People v Robbie Owens |
|
1656 KA 04-01348 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10001 |
| People v Jeffrey M. Herber |
|
1657 KA 05-01485 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10002 |
| People v Herbert Thomas |
|
1658 KA 03-01063 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10003 |
| People v Vance Dunlap |
|
1659 KA 04-01271 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10004 |
| People v Bruce F. Murry |
|
1660 KA 03-02167 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10005 |
| People v Rafrica R. Clarke |
|
1661 KA 03-01837 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10006 |
| People v Lucas Rodriquez |
|
1663 KA 03-01672 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10007 |
| People v Robert Saffold |
|
1664 KA 03-02020 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10008 |
| James W. Betro v Enessa M.
Carbone |
|
1666 CA 05-01538 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10009 |
| Matter of Garry King |
|
1666 CA 05-01538 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10010 |
| Matter of Jeffrey A. Lazroe |
Per Curiam |
1666 CA 05-01538 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10011 |
| Matter of Rene F. Hensel |
|
1666 CA 05-01538 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10012 |
| Matter of Thomas J. Casey |
|
1666 CA 05-01538 |
2005 NY Slip Op 10013 |