Appellate Division First Department

**Cases Decided May 28th**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
71st St.-Lexington Corp. v Frankel		Index No. 653548/23\|Appeal No. 6740-6741\|Case No. 2025-01840, 2025-03944\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03358
Berardi v 900 Third Ave., L.P.		Index No. 156323/21, 595059/22\|Appeal No. 6747\|Case No. 2025-04727\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03359
Matter of Christian v Department of Educ. of the City of N.Y.		Index No. 159994/20\|Appeal No. 5195\|Case No. 2024-03953\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03360
Francis v NYSARC Inc.		Index No. 810047/23\|Appeal No. 6748\|Case No. 2025-08090\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03361
James Thomas Realty, LLC v Cheliotes		Index No. 651836/16\|Appeal No. 6751\|Case No. 2025-06348\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03362
Lebron v Bronx Hgts. Beulah Assoc., LP		Index No. 304608/15\|Appeal No. 6742-6743\|Case No. 2025-02615\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03363
Matter of Moss	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2026-01059\|Case No. 2026-00072\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03364
Matter of Murray-Nolan	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-06562, 2026-00612\|Case No. 2025-07773\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03365
McNeill v Gewirtz		Index No. 20178/19\|Appeal No. 6736\|Case No. 2025-04920\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03366
Matter of New York Concrete Corp./JPL Indus. JV v Contract Dispute Resolution Bd. of the City of N.Y.		Index No. 155173/24\|Appeal No. 6738\|Case No. 2025-03150\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03367
People v Pedraza		Ind No. 58/00\|Appeal No. 6737\|Case No. 2022-03804\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03368
People v Ingram		Ind No. 3488/19\|Appeal No. 6744\|Case No. 2022-01162, 2025-02693\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03369
People v Brooks		Ind No. 2094/17\|Appeal No. 6750\|Case No. 2019-05425 2024-00770\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03370
People v Pena		Ind No. 707/19, 1738/19\|Appeal No. 6733\|Case No. 2022-01179\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03371
Faula v Auxiliary of Elmhurst Hosp. Ctr. of the N.Y. City Health & Hosps. Corp., Inc.		Index No. 816408/24\|Appeal No. 6739\|Case No. 2025-07473\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03372
Stillpoint Meadows PH-62, LLC v Residential Bd. of Mgrs. of the 62 Cooper Sq. Condominium		Index No. 650633/22\|Appeal No. 6745\|Case No. 2025-03940\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03373
Thilly v New York Presbyt. Hosp.		Index No. 150123/23\|Appeal No. 6614\|Case No. 2025-02755\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03374
Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v Whyte		Index No. 36127/20\|Appeal No. 6734\|Case No. 2025-04825\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03375

**Cases Decided May 26th**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Arizzo v Ethicon, Inc.	Shulman, J.	Index No. 159122/23\|Appeal No. 5776\|Case No. 2025-04031\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03262
Bermeo v Master Plumbing & Heating, Inc.		Index No. 154471/20\|Appeal No. 6717\|Case No. 2025-07061\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03263
Cattan v Rohner		Index No. 652468/20\|Appeal No. 6721-6722\|Case No. 2023-05695 2023-05719\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03264
City of New York v Crest Hous. Co., LLC		Index No. 452282/22\|Appeal No. 6715\|Case No. 2025-03518\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03265
Gantt v City of New York		Index No. 29299/17 21039/18 22560/18 22756/18 23552/18 23528/18 25474/18 25538/18 25770/18 28103/18 42212/19 30693/18\|Appeal No. 6729\|Case No. 2025-02973\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03266
Hubshman v 1010 Tenants Corp.		Index No. 157779/24\|Appeal No. 6724\|Case No. 2025-01399\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03267
Katiraeifar v New York-Presbyt.		Index No. 162653/15\|Appeal No. 6714\|Case No. 2025-05364\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03268
Matter of Lent v City of New York		Index No. 158624/24\|Appeal No. 6716\|Case No. 2025-02225\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03269
Lilly v State of New York		Index No. 155539/24\|Appeal No. 6720\|Case No. 2025-01852\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03270
Lotrean v 3M Co.		Index No. 153361/20\|Appeal No. 5138\|Case No. 2024-03189\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03271
Lotus Residences LLC v Northfield Ins. Co.		Index No. 653599/20\|Appeal No. 6732\|Case No. 2025-02553\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03272
Matter of Mpow Tech. Co., Ltd. v Amazon.com Servs., LLC		Index No. 652815/25\|Appeal No. 6723\|Case No. 2025-05067\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03273
Ochoa v C.I. Lobster Corp.		Index No. 815200/22\|Appeal No. 5717\|Case No. 2024-06937\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03274
People v Pleasant		Ind No. 425/21\|Appeal No. 6725-6726\|Case No. 2023-06132 2025-03445\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03275
People v Bosch		Ind No. 542/21\|Appeal No. 6731\|Case No. 2024-01122\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03276
People v Colon		Ind No. 498/17\|Appeal No. 6713\|Case No. 2019-2238\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03277
People v Santiful		Ind No. 542/21\|Appeal No. 6718\|Case No. 2023-04307\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03278
Rosario v C.C. Controlled Combustion Co., Inc.		Index No. 816166/21\|Appeal No. 6730\|Case No. 2025-02897\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03279
Soleil Chartered Bank v Breton Equity Co. Corp.		Index No. 653094/25\|Appeal No. 6727\|Case No. 2025-07627\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03280
Ziobro v Milan House Inc.		Index No. 154028/17\|Appeal No. 6728\|Case No. 2025-02611\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03281

**Cases Decided May 21st**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Adler v Troy		Index No. 805376/21\|Appeal No. 6692\|Case No. 2024-05957\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03220
Altieri v Hyl		Index No. 157681/21\|Appeal No. 6682\|Case No. 2025-02251\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03221
Andrade v 1203 E N.Y. Ave Owner, LLC		Index No. 154137/22\|Appeal No. 6698\|Case No. 2025-00725\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03222
Matter of V.B. (Richard B.--Marcia C.)		Docket No. NA-09766/24\|Appeal No. 6676\|Case No. 2025-04767\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03223
Blue Riv. Gems Inc. v Gross		Index No. 150883/20\|Appeal No. 6710\|Case No. 2025-02029\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03224
Blumenfeld v Smith		Index No. 651069/24\|Appeal No. 6703\|Case No. 2024-07564\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03225
Casella v Casella		Index No. 365119/20\|Appeal No. 6687\|Case No. 2024-06897\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03226
Chiappa v Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J.		Index No. 805328/22\|Appeal No. 6686\|Case No. 2025-05820\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03227
CSN Realty Corp. v Moussaieff		Index No. 652522/24\|Appeal No. 6699\|Case No. 2025-01502\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03228
De Souza v Hudson Yards Constr. II LLC		Index No. 157354/19 595340/25\|Appeal No. 6707\|Case No. 2026-00054\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03229
Freeland v Chemtob		Index No. 160094/21\|Appeal No. 6675\|Case No. 2025-03135\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03230
HSBC Bank USA v Keeling		Index No. 35472/15\|Appeal No. 6677\|Case No. 2024-07071\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03231
Matter of Kunz v C.Y.		Index No. 530187/25\|Appeal No. 6695\|Case No. 2025-04934\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03232
Leffler v Kotick		Index No. 155820/18\|Appeal No. 6683\|Case No. 2025-05709\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03233
Motcomb Estates, Ltd. v CMB Export Infrastructure Inv. Group 48, LP		Index No. 653343/24\|Appeal No. 6702\|Case No. 2025-01517\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03234
OCFBrook Holdings, LLC v TKS Brooklyn Ctr. Holding, LLC		Index No. 154460/24\|Appeal No. 6705\|Case No. 2025-06103\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03235
Pacheco v Tishman Constr. Corp. of N.Y.		Index No. 26440/18\|Appeal No. 6708\|Case No. 2025-07441\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03236
Paro Mgt. Co., Inc. v Allied World Natl. Assur. Co.		Index No. 655681/21\|Appeal No. 6706\|Case No. 2025-07259\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03237
People v Sanchez		Ind No. 73563/23\|Appeal No. 6694\|Case No. 2024-06763\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03238
People v Cassanova		Ind No. 1256/21\|Appeal No. 6679\|Case No. 2023-01463\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03239
People v Alvarez		Ind No. 962/18\|Appeal No. 6674\|Case No. 2019-1864\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03240
People v Christian G.		Ind No. 70381/24 70341/24\|Appeal No. 6700-6701\|Case No. 2025-01201 2025-00160\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03241
People v Harvard		Ind No. 1234/20\|Appeal No. 6685\|Case No. 2023-02003\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03242
People v Ramirez		Ind No. 619/21 1346/21 71076/23\|Appeal No. 6711\|Case No. 2024-05363\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03243
People v Antoine		Ind No. 72192/22\|Appeal No. 6697\|Case No. 2024-01271\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03244
People v Thomas		Ind No. 1428/18\|Appeal No. 6680\|Case No. 2020-01749\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03245
Perez v Kew Gardens Dev. Corp.		Index No. 453196/17\|Appeal No. 6704\|Case No. 2025-06701\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03246
S & M Bronx Inc. v Diversified Planning Brokerage LLC		Index No. 816715/21\|Appeal No. 6688\|Case No. 2025-07912\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03247
S.M. v City of New York	Renwick, P.J.	Index No. 27844/20\|Appeal No. 5927\|Case No. 2024-03494\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03248
Matter of Sajetta v Jung Park		Index No. 72641-2023\|Appeal No. 6712\|Case No. 2026-01206\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03249
Serhant LLC v Federico		Index No. 652441/22\|Appeal No. 5259\|Case No. 2025-02002\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03250
Staten v City of New York		Index No. 30997/18\|Appeal No. 6122\|Case No. 2025-00662\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03251
Velez v Central Parking Sys. of N.Y., Inc.		Index No. 26258/18\|Appeal No. 6689\|Case No. 2025-04278\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03252
Wilmington Sav. Fund Socy. v Okoronkwo		Index No. 804084/21\|Appeal No. 6696\|Case No. 2025-02982\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03253
Richardson v CE Solutions Group, LLC		Index No. 653369/21\|Appeal No. 6691\|Case No. 2025-03018\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03254

**Cases Decided May 19th**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Alshami v State of New York	Claim No. 142884\|Appeal No. 6657-6658\|Case No. 2025-04576, 2025-05525\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03111
Ayuso v State of New York	Claim No. 143421\|Appeal No. 6655-6656\|Case No. 2025-06774, 2025-06776\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03112
Matter of Edwin C.	Docket No. D-249/25\|Appeal No. 6653\|Case No. 2025-01024\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03113
Diaz v Boston Props., Inc.	Index No. 151421/22\|Appeal No. 6666\|Case No. 2026-00275\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03114
Diaz v Rotavele El., Inc.	Index No. 157664/20\|Appeal No. 6652\|Case No. 2025-03132\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03115
Falcao v Metropolitan Transp. Auth.	Index No. 154962/18\|Appeal No. 6164\|Case No. 2024-06308\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03116
Matter of Gaddy v Litman	Appeal No. 6673, M-00546\|Case No. 2026-00499\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03117
Gusel v King	Index No. 159824/24\|Appeal No. 6668\|Case No. 2025-04298\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03118
Maza v 120 E. 144 LLC	Index No. 819431/23\|Appeal No. 6654\|Case No. 2025-08029\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03119
People v Nicholas	Ind. No. 73555/24\|Appeal No. 6662\|Case No. 2025-02648\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03120
People v Smith	SCI. No. 70862/22, 70865/22\|Appeal No. 6669\|Case No. 2024-04560\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03121
People v Calderon	SCI. No. 00705/16\|Appeal No. 6659\|Case No. 2023-05052\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03122
People v Williams	Ind. No. 74898/23\|Appeal No. 6664\|Case No. 2025-01312\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03123
People v Anderson	Ind. No. 71407/23\|Appeal No. 6651\|Case No. 2024-05029\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03124
People v Lee	Ind. No. 753/21\|Appeal No. 6026\|Case No. 2024-03688\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03125
Perez v Tanya Towers, Inc.	Index No. 28519/20\|Appeal No. 6663\|Case No. 2025-04802\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03126
Tapinekis v Pace Univ.	Index No. 652902/22\|Appeal No. 6670\|Case No. 2025-00027\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03127
Taylor v City of New York	Index No. 816934/21\|Appeal No. 6667\|Case No. 2024-06438\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03128
U.S. Bank N.A. v Chait	Index No. 850196/22\|Appeal No. 6661\|Case No. 2025-02980\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03129
Ward v Northeast Truck Rental & Leasing LLC	Index No. 809980/22\|Appeal No. 6671-6672\|Case No. 2025-02981, 2025-03680\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03130
Prosight Specialty Mgt. Co., Inc. v Altruis Group, LLC	Index No. 653775/23\|Appeal No. 6660\|Case No. 2025-00967\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03131

**Cases Decided May 14th**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Adames v Galaxy Gen. Contr. Corp.		Index No. 802231/23\|Appeal No. 6612\|Case No. 2025-00235\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03054
Amirov v Turtle Bay Tavern Corp.		Index No. 23467/19\|Appeal No. 6642\|Case No. 2025-04813\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03055
Anderson v AKAM Assoc., Inc.		Index No. 159765/21\|Appeal No. 6645-6646\|Case No. 2025-05702, 2025-07068\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03056
Apple Bank for Sav. v Prime Rok Real Estate LLC		Index No. 653140/23\|Appeal No. 6640\|Case No. 2025-01642\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03057
Aroch v 391 Broadway LLC		Index No. 158856/17\|Appeal No. 6649\|Case No. 2025-05359\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03058
Howira v New York City Health & Hosp. Corp.		Index No. 850285/14\|Appeal No. 6648\|Case No. 2025-00209\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03059
Banasik v Mount Sinai Health Sys.		Index No. 153072/23\|Appeal No. 6628\|Case No. 2025-03354\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03060
Bapaz NYC W. St Group LLC v Assa Props. Inc.		Index No. 652456/18\|Appeal No. 6624\|Case No. 2025-07218\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03061
Matter of C.C. (M.C.)		Docket No. B-6404/19 B-7600/19\|Appeal No. 6607\|Case No. 2025-01221 2025-01222\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03062
Cha v Ryder Truck Rental, Inc.		Index No. 804102/24\|Appeal No. 6608\|Case No. 2025-06399\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03063
De Souza v El Sol Contr. & Constr. Corp.		Index No. 151863/21\|Appeal No. 6618\|Case No. 2025-04667\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03064
Famula v Kiewit-Weeks-Massman AJV		Index No. 31087/18\|Appeal No. 6620\|Case No. 2025-02482\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03065
Fifth Ave. Surgery Ctr. LLC v JJS Group Inc.		Index No. 650796/25\|Appeal No. 6631-6632\|Case No. 2025-04179, 2025-05016\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03066
Frantz v XL Diamonds LLC		Index No. 151672/22\|Appeal No. 6619\|Case No. 2025-06178\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03067
Gur Assoc. LLC v Kassim		Index No. 654168/23\|Appeal No. 6621\|Case No. 2025-06773\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03068
J.R. v City of New York		Index No. 21119/19\|Appeal No. 6644\|Case No. 2025-02662\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03069
Kingdom Assoc., Inc. v WBC Servs. Inc.		Index No. 158068/24\|Appeal No. 6622\|Case No. 2025-02291\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03070
Kociaj v DeRose		Index No. 803599/22\|Appeal No. 6643\|Case No. 2024-07913\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03071
Matter of Mackey v Mennin		Motion No. M-1948\|Appeal No. 6650\|Case No. 2026-01529\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03072
Matter of V.M. (D.M.)		Docket No. NN-31338-23\|Appeal No. 6629\|Case No. 2025-03554\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03073
Matter of Lewis	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2026-01135\|Case No. 2026-00170\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03074
MEC Prop. Holdings, LLC v Gelfand		Index No. 653955/24\|Appeal No. 6609\|Case No. 2025-06624\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03075
Mittel v Beth Din of the United States of Am., Inc.		Index No. 655814/21\|Appeal No. 6637\|Case No. 2025-00364\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03076
Parker v Simmons		Index No. 152852/20\|Appeal No. 6606\|Case No. 2025-02612\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03077
People v Jordan		Ind No. 3767/08\|Appeal No. 6636\|Case No. 2024-00381\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03078
People v Simmons		Ind No. 74375/22\|Appeal No. 6616\|Case No. 2023-00942\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03079
People v Ndiaye		Ind No. 72722/23\|Appeal No. 6641\|Case No. 2024-06234\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03080
People v Santana		Ind No. 70894/21 1266/21\|Appeal No. 6623\|Case No. 2022-03516 2022-03333\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03081
People v Grant		Ind No. 73722/23\|Appeal No. 6633\|Case No. 2024-06778\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03082
People v Velez		Ind No. 3130/13\|Appeal No. 6647\|Case No. 2020-03761\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03083
People v Alvarez		Ind No. 679/20\|Appeal No. 6605\|Case No. 2024-06006\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03084
People v D.D.		Ind No. 70352/21, 70736/22\|Appeal No. 5337-5337A\|Case No. 2022-03393\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03085
People v Andino		Ind No. 75505/23\|Appeal No. 6627\|Case No. 2024-04469\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03086
People v Guithy		Ind No. 74010/23\|Appeal No. 6613\|Case No. 2025-02652\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03087
People v Fofana		Ind No. 70269/22\|Appeal No. 6610\|Case No. 2024-05570\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03088
Reid v Veloz-Espinal		Index No. 809910/21\|Appeal No. 6635\|Case No. 2025-03405\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03089
Rojas v 444-451 Orange Bldgs. Hous. Dev. Fund Corp.		Index No. 158841/19\|Appeal No. 6611\|Case No. 2025-02829\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03090
Terron-Alcantara v Charlie's Real Estate LLC		Index No. 813407/22\|Appeal No. 6634\|Case No. 2025-08346\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03091
Tribeca Lending Corp. v Bartlett		Index No. 105275/07\|Appeal No. 6639\|Case No. 2025-07134\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03092
Urban v Roman Catholic Archdiocese of N.Y.		Index No. 950359/21, 950019/21, 950536/20 950148/19 950149/19, 950476/21, 70072/20, 70226/21, 400025/19, 70004/21, 950035/19, 950042/19, 950056/19, 950149/20, 950694/20\|Appeal No. 6615\|Case No. 2025-06396\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03093
Wiener Realty Mgt., LLC v One Penn Plaza LLC		Index No. 162194/23\|Appeal No. 6617\|Case No. 2026-00475\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03094
Matter of Kaufman		File No. 2018-711/A+/C 2018-711/E\|Appeal No. 6625-6626\|Case No. 2025-00381 2025-01365\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03095

**Cases Decided May 13th**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Kane v Campbell		Index No. 451700/26\|Appeal No. 6835-6836, M-2687&M2688\|Case No. 2026-02722, 2026-02724\|	2026 NY Slip Op 03027

**Cases Decided May 12th**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Feliciano v Board of Elections in the City of New York		Index No. 1639/26\|Appeal No. 6814\|Case No. 2026-02504\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02952
Matter of Kane v Lander		Index No. 451585/26\|Appeal No. 6815-6816\|Case No. 2026-02537, 2026-02422\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02953
Matter of Sairitupac v Sanchez		Index No. 154729/26\|Appeal No. 6817\|Case No. 2026-02635\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02954
Blount v Verizon		Index No. 158977/23\|Appeal No. 6581\|Case No. 2025-03708\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02918
Choi v Linc LIC L.L.C.		Index No. 154436/24\|Appeal No. 6602\|Case No. 2025-05055\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02919
Farmer v Mizuho Sec. USA LLC		Index No. 151348/24\|Appeal No. 6568\|Case No. 2025-06032\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02920
Fuhr v Smith		Index No. 153767/25\|Appeal No. 6591\|Case No. 2025-05994\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02921
Greenpoint Mtge. Funding, Inc. v Ehrenthal		Index No. 115170/08\|Appeal No. 6570\|Case No. 2024-06191\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02922
Heitman Credit Acquisition XXIII, LLC v Meadow Partners LLC		Index No. 659052/24\|Appeal No. 6571\|Case No. 2025-07120\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02923
Hubbard v JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.		Index No. 30571/18\|Appeal No. 6575\|Case No. 2025-01164\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02924
Migadde v Permanent Mission of Uganda to the United Nations		Index No. 100820/19\|Appeal No. 6589\|Case No. 2025-03473\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02925
Nicolai v Daisak		Index No. 150218/22\|Appeal No. 6592\|Case No. 2025-05950\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02926
Matter of New York State Div. of Human Rights v Engolos LLC		Index No. 4510501/20\|Appeal No. 6596\|Case No. 2024-05286\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02927
Matter of E.O. v O.O.		Docket No. O-10573/24\|Appeal No. 6590\|Case No. 2024-07854\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02928
P.S. Marcato El. Co., Inc. v Scottsdale Ins. Co.		Index No. 655259/19, 595038/20\|Appeal No. 6604\|Case No. 2024-04585\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02929
Pearson v Jakubcin		Index No. 809382/22\|Appeal No. 6601\|Case No. 2025-03751\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02930
People v Musah		Ind. No. 3986/18\|Appeal No. 6577\|Case No. 2022-02525\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02931
People v Fogler		SCI No. 72034/24, Ind. No. 75342/23\|Appeal No. 6572-6573\|Case No. 2025-03282, 2024-05574\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02932
People v Scott		Ind. No. 71513/23\|Appeal No. 6597\|Case No. 2024-04039\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02933
People v Fuhrtz		Ind. No. 70281/22, 135/21\|Appeal No. 6593-6594\|Case No. 2023-01663, 2023-01664, 2025-03063\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02934
People v Martinez		Ind. No. 70049/22\|Appeal No. 6576\|Case No. 2024-05017\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02935
People v Taylor		SCI No. 5259/14\|Appeal No. 6567\|Case No. 2016-1082\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02936
People v Delrio		Ind. No. 73757/22\|Appeal No. 6584\|Case No. 2024-06557\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02937
People v Odom		Ind. No. 361/17\|Appeal No. 6588\|Case No. 2019-03752\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02938
People v Jennings		Ind. No. 72831/22\|Appeal No. 6603\|Case No. 2023-06689\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02939
People v Cuevas		Ind. No. 1163/10\|Appeal No. 6600-6600A\|Case No. 2019-4501, 2024-05535\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02940
People v Hernandez		Ind. No. 1108/19\|Appeal No. 3913\|Case No. 2024-05971\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02941
Pescales v Pax Ventures LLC		Index No. 653319/19\|Appeal No. 6091-6092\|Case No. 2024-06733, 2025-02577\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02942
Matter of Philippe NYC 1 LLC v Office of Admin. Trials & Hearings		Index No. 152622/24\|Appeal No. 6599\|Case No. 2024-06524\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02943
Quintanar v New York State Off. of the Attorney Gen.		Index No. 160721/22\|Appeal No. 6582\|Case No. 2025-01351\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02944
Matter of A.E.R. v A.B.		Docket No. O-08893/23\|Appeal No. 6569\|Case No. 2025-04199\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02945
Rios v City of New York		Index No. 153910/18\|Appeal No. 6587\|Case No. 2025-05497\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02946
Sen v GR Realty Holdings LLC		Index No. 157812/20\|Appeal No. 6598\|Case No. 2025-03723\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02947
Sznycer v Con Edison Co. of N.Y., Inc.		Index No. 158138/17\|Appeal No. 6585-6586\|Case No. 2023-03757, 2024-06633\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02948
Watson v Roanoke Is. Historical Assn.	Webber, J.P.	Index No. 952266/23\|Appeal No. 5690\|Case No. 2025-01773\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02949
Weir v Weir		Index No. 313319/11\|Appeal No. 6755\|Case No. 2025-01762\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02950
WPC Billboard Lender LLC v Bartkowski		Index No. 653700/23\|Appeal No. 6578-6579-6580\|Case No. 2025-00499, 2025-03682, 2025-04376\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02951

**Cases Decided May 7th**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
AIG Prop. Cas. Co. v High Line Constr. Group LLC		Index No. 158444/18 595626/19 595475/21\|Appeal No. 6555\|Case No. 2025-01839\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02872
Buchman v 117 E. 72nd St. Corp.		Index No. 650576/25\|Appeal No. 6561\|Case No. 2025-07559\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02873
Calle v JRR Contr. Inc.		Index No. 21943/20\|Appeal No. 6557\|Case No. 2025-01863\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02874
Dorilton Capital Mgt. LLC v Stilus LLC		Index No. 652428/23 \|Appeal No. 6558\|Case No. 2025-06684\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02875
Flores v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.		Index No. 27869/18\|Appeal No. 5726\|Case No. 2024-04338\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02876
Gonzalez v Navillus Tile, Inc.		Index No. 34386/20\|Appeal No. 6551\|Case No. 2025-03833\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02877
Matter of La.M.		\|Docket No. V-00620/23 V-00621/23\|Appeal No. 6550\|Case No. 2024-02546\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02878
Lexington Ave. Hotel, L.P. v 525 Lexington Owner, LLC		Index No. 651969/24\|Appeal No. 6306\|Case No. 2025-05828\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02879
Marinac v Marinac		Index No. 365207/22\|Appeal No. 6562\|Case No. 2025-02661\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02880
Matter of Miami Entertainment Law Group v Sokoloff		Appeal No. 6566\|Case No. 2026-00136\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02881
Park v Butkow		Index No. 306738/19\|Appeal No. 6552\|Case No. 2025-05504\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02882
People v Young	Webber, J.P.	Index No. 74702/23\|Appeal No. 5490\|Case No. 2024-05936\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02883
People v Urgitano		Ind No. 1561/16\|Appeal No. 6554-6554A-M-1467\|Case No. 2019-986 2024-06269\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02884
People v Jones		Ind No. 2488/17\|Appeal No. 6559\|Case No. 2023-01150\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02885
People v Sanchez		Ind No. 1359/21\|Appeal No. 6564\|Case No. 2023-01434\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02886
People v Simms		Ind No. 75413/23\|Appeal No. 6553\|Case No. 2025-00759\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02887
People v Diallo		Ind No. 71086/23\|Appeal No. 6560\|Case No. 2024-06375\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02888
People v Cuello-Guerrido		Ind No. 1471/21\|Appeal No. 6563\|Case No. 2023-05230\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02889
People v Jenkins		Ind No. 00828/21\|Appeal No. 6549\|Case No. 2023-00182\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02890
Smartmatic USA Corp. v Fox Corp.		Index No. 151136/21\|Appeal No. 6565\|Case No. 2025-08190\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02891

**Cases Decided May 5th**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Allen v Thompson		Index No. 160342/20\|Appeal No. 6531\|Case No. 2025-07729\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02771
Matter of Bifulco v City of New York	Higgitt, J.	Index No. 161841/23\|Appeal No. 6253\|Case No. 2024-05513\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02772
Breiding v High Hopes Films, LLC		Index No. 152385/23\|Appeal No. 6515\|Case No. 2025-05001\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02773
Matter of Clemente v City of New York		Index No. 819542/24\|Appeal No. 6516\|Case No. 2025-04344\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02774
Cortlandt St. Recovery Corp. v TPG Capital Mgt., L.P.		Index No. 651176/17\|Appeal No. 6512\|Case No. 2022-05473\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02775
Dodaj v Total Concrete Flatwork, LLC		Index No. 803790/24\|Appeal No. 6521\|Case No. 2025-02986\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02776
Edwards v New Jersey Tr. Bus Operations, Inc.		Index No. 153876/16\|Appeal No. 4970\|Case No. 2023-00122\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02777
Evans v Punter		Index No. 154101/20\|Appeal No. 6536\|Case No. 2025-04208\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02778
Forrester v 640 Park Ave. Corp.		Index No. 150070/25\|Appeal No. 6546\|Case No. 2025-05886\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02779
Garcia v 267 Dev. LLC		Index No. 160076/16\|Appeal No. 6524\|Case No. 2025-01235\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02780
Garrido v 200 Lenox Ave., LLC		Index No. 160673/20\|Appeal No. 6511\|Case No. 2024-06784\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02781
Henriquez v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 21718/18\|Appeal No. 6527\|Case No. 2025-00167\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02782
Matter of Lebda v Touro Coll. Sch. of Educ.		Index No. 101271/24\|Appeal No. 6509\|Case No. 2025-02994\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02783
Matter of Lurie v New York City Dept. of Educ.		Index No. 162176/23\|Appeal No. 6529\|Case No. 2025-03133\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02784
MIC Gen. Ins. Corp. v Eckart		Index No. 651028/22\|Appeal No. 6541-6542\|Case No. 2024-05767 2025-02802\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02785
Mills v Santos		Index No. 35466/20\|Appeal No. 6532\|Case No. 2025-00326\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02786
Mulacek v ExxonMobil Corp.		Index No. 659043/24\|Appeal No. 6523\|Case No. 2025-04710\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02787
Matter of Monet O. v Leroy L.B.		\|Docket No. V-15901/21 V-15716/21\|Appeal No. 6510\|Case No. 2025-01661\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02788
Omansky v 300-302 E. 119 St. HDFC		Index No. 650217/23 \|Appeal No. 6543\|Case No. 2025-05951\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02789
People v Ruiz		Ind No. 3418/16\|Appeal No. 6534\|Case No. 2017-03090\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02790
People v Parrott		Ind No. 659/17\|Appeal No. 6528\|Case No. 2019-03753\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02791
People v Puntiel-Ruck		Ind No. 1449/19\|Appeal No. 6508\|Case No. 2022-00516\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02792
People v Ford		Ind No. 70852/22\|Appeal No. 6544\|Case No. 2023-03335\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02793
People v Talavera		Ind No. 2989/18\|Appeal No. 6533\|Case No. 2020-02110\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02794
People v Sullivan		Ind No. 72000/24 72357/24 73346/24\|Appeal No. 6518 6519 6520\|Case No. 2025-04444 2025-04445 2025-04446\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02795
People v Cabrera		Ind No. 1131/21\|Appeal No. 6526\|Case No. 2023-00469\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02796
People v Bowers		Ind No. 74425/22\|Appeal No. 6547\|Case No. 2023-04172\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02797
People v Johnson		Ind No. 1480/21\|Appeal No. 6514\|Case No. 2023-04599\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02798
People v Gagum		Ind No. 70726/22\|Appeal No. 6539\|Case No. 2023-03461\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02799
People v Nicholas		Ind No. 71672/22\|Appeal No. 6513\|Case No. 2023-00169\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02800
Preacely v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 153446/24\|Appeal No. 6537M-1758\|Case No. 2024-07354\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02801
Rosenblum v City of New York		Index No. 20717/19\|Appeal No. 6535\|Case No. 2025-00883\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02802
Rubin v EFP Rotenberg, LLP		Index No. 651825/15\|Appeal No. 6540\|Case No. 2025-02000\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02803
Matter of M.S. (Aissatou T.)		Docket No. NA-31221/23\|Appeal No. 6530\|Case No. 2025-02764\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02804
Stafford v Nacson		Index No. 159911/22\|Appeal No. 5387\|Case No. 2025-01077\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02805
Stuckey v City of New York		Index No. 309691/11\|Appeal No. 6548\|Case No. 2025-03490\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02806
M.P.V. v A.V.		Index No. 300003/17\|Appeal No. 6525M-1539\|Case No. 2025-00571\|	2026 NY Slip Op 02807

Appellate Division, First Department Decisions