Appellate Division, Fourth Department Motions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Motions Decided April 28, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL REIBEL	KA 17-02143	2023 NY Slip Op 66310(U)
PB-36 DOE V NIAGARA FALLS CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT, LASALLE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL AND ROBERT LEWIS	1015-22	2023 NY Slip Op 66309(U)
GREAT LAKES ANESTHESIOLOGY, P.C. V DORON FELDMAN AND JAMES FOSTER	13-23	2023 NY Slip Op 66308(U)
THE PEOPLE V FRANCIS FINSTER	KA 15-00472	2023 NY Slip Op 66307(U)
GLENN FEDERMAN V TOWN OF LORRAINE, HIGHWAY SUPERINTENDENT JOSEPH WASILEWSKI, DEPUTY HIGHWAY SUPERINTENDENT HAROLD	837-22	2023 NY Slip Op 66306(U)

**Motions Decided April 25, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF THOMAS J. SEGELIN V KELLEY M. WRIGHT	CAF 23-00595	2023 NY Slip Op 66304(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SA'RIAH C.-J., CORNELL C.-J. AND CATALAYA J.	CAF 23-00350	2023 NY Slip Op 66303(U)
IN THE MATTER OF LUIS R. MALDONADO V VIOLA QUEOR	CAF 23-00559	2023 NY Slip Op 66302(U)
IN THE MATTER OF LANDEN S. AND KAMERSON S.	CAF 23-00528	2023 NY Slip Op 66301(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALEXANDER KATES V LETITIA JAMES, ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR THE STATE OF NEW YORK, AND JOHN BRINGEWATT FOR	OP 23-00362	2023 NY Slip Op 66300(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DARNELL HAMILTON V LATANYA LAWS	CAF 23-00625	2023 NY Slip Op 66299(U)
IN THE MATTER OF G.H.	CAF 23-00195	2023 NY Slip Op 66298(U)

**Motions Decided April 24, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
MATTER OF DANIEL T. WARREN V PLANNING BOARD OF TOWN OF WEST SENECA, TOWN OF WEST SENECA, CANISIUS HIGH SCHOOL OF	CA 22-01929 and CA 23-00546	2023 NY Slip Op 66297(U)
U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, AS INDENTURE TRUSTEE, FOR LHOME MORTGAGE TRUST 2019-RTL2, MORTGAGE-BACKED NOTES, SERIES	CA 22-01351	2023 NY Slip Op 66296(U)
MARY ULES V COUNTY OF ONEIDA	CA 22-01401 and CA 23-00302	2023 NY Slip Op 66295(U)
THE PEOPLE V TERELL ROLFE	KA 23-00553	2023 NY Slip Op 66294(U)
IN THE MATTER OF NOAH C., ROMEO C., JADEN C., AND JACOB C.	CAF 22-01143	2023 NY Slip Op 66293(U)
THE PEOPLE V STEVE FULCOTT, ALSO KNOWN AS TOMMY G	KA 16-01444	2023 NY Slip Op 66292(U)

**Motions Decided April 21, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF ALIYAH M., D'ANDRE M., ELIJHA M., JR. MALAKAI M. AND MARQUEZ M.	CAF 23-00256	2023 NY Slip Op 66291(U)

**Motions Decided April 20, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF LILLYANA B., ALSO KNOWN AS LILLYANA M.	CAF 22-01291	2023 NY Slip Op 66290(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOHLYANNE F.	CAF 20-00654	2023 NY Slip Op 66289(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SIRBARINDER DHIR V RAIMOND WINSLOW	CAF 21-01414 and CAF 21-01415	2023 NY Slip Op 66288(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SHAQUAN L. BIBBS V JANAYA L. TYLER	CAF 22-01255	2023 NY Slip Op 66287(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ARIC D.B. AND MICHAEL H.B.	CAF 22-01104	2023 NY Slip Op 66286(U)

**Motions Decided April 19, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF JOSEPH A. SOLOMON V TINA WHITLEY AND STORM A. COLEY	CAF 22-01919	2023 NY Slip Op 65467(U)
PRIYANKA PARITI AND JAGANNADH PARITI V COUNTY OF MONROE, MONROE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND BRIGHTON	CA 22-01621	2023 NY Slip Op 65466(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JUSTICE H.M. AND LIBERTY D.M.-S.	CAF 23-00485	2023 NY Slip Op 65465(U)

**Motions Decided April 18, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF LEONARD P.	CAF 22-00563	2023 NY Slip Op 65468(U)
THE PEOPLE V FONTASIA TORAN	KA 23-00392	2023 NY Slip Op 65464(U)
THE PEOPLE V JEFFREY J. MATSON Indictment No: 8403-V	KA 22-00107	2023 NY Slip Op 65463(U)
IN THE MATTER OF LEONARD P.	CAF 23-00628	2023 NY Slip Op 65462(U)
THE PEOPLE V RYAN LAWS	KA 23-00277	2023 NY Slip Op 65461(U)
THE PEOPLE V FRANCIS FINSTER	KA 15-00472	2023 NY Slip Op 65460(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHEAHONNIE DAVIS (APPEAL NO. 1)	KA 19-00250	2023 NY Slip Op 65459(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALBERT S. AND STACEY S.	CAF 23-00309	2023 NY Slip Op 65458(U)

**Motions Decided April 17, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF STEVEN L. V STATE OF NEW YORK	CA 23-00462	2023 NY Slip Op 65457(U)
THE PEOPLE V JUSTIN M. SEWEL	KA 18-02217	2023 NY Slip Op 65456(U)
SANDRA JONAS V MICHAEL JONAS	CA 22-00451	2023 NY Slip Op 65455(U)
SARAH HAYES V HILLSIDE FAMILY OF AGENCIES	CA 22-01952 and CA 22-01953	2023 NY Slip Op 65454(U)
JANE DOE V ERIE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES BUFFALO CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT	CA 22-01757	2023 NY Slip Op 65453(U)
THE PEOPLE V CADARRELL O. CLARK Indictment No: 2017/0668A	KA 21-01244	2023 NY Slip Op 65452(U)
THE PEOPLE V BRANDON CLARK	KA 21-01152	2023 NY Slip Op 65451(U)
ELIZABETH CATLIN V DAVID MORABITO	CA 22-01323	2023 NY Slip Op 65450(U)
AMY BRIGNALL, FRAN-MARIE CHERESNOWSKY, PAUL DIPIERRO, JAMIE HAWLEY, GERARD KAELIN, MEREDITH PRATT, GWEN NANIA AND NYS	CA 22-00732	2023 NY Slip Op 65449(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHARDEA BRADLEY, ALSO KNOWN AS ALBERTO HENRIQUEZ	KA 17-00735	2023 NY Slip Op 65448(U)
SARAH E. AGGARWAL V VINAY R. AGGARWAL	CA 22-01312	2023 NY Slip Op 65447(U)

**Motions Decided April 13, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF STACEY PYNN V MATTHEW PYNN	CAF 22-01971	2023 NY Slip Op 65446(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MICHAEL JONAS V SANDRA JONAS, ALSO KNOWN AS SANDRA SURIANELLO	CAF 23-00521	2023 NY Slip Op 65445(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ASHLEY N. CHARLTON V NEWELL H. CHARLTON, JR.	CAF 22-00142	2023 NY Slip Op 65444(U)

**Motions Decided April 12, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF ADRIANNA WOOD V JAMES WOOD	CAF 22-01922	2023 NY Slip Op 65443(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MICHAEL C. SMITH V VALORIE J. SMITH IN THE MATTER OF MICHAEL C. SMITH V VALORIE J. SMITH IN THE MATTER	CAF 23-00515	2023 NY Slip Op 65442(U)
THE PEOPLE V MAHALIA GUEST	KA 22-00348	2023 NY Slip Op 65441(U)
IN THE MATTER OF FREDERICKA S. AND DELAWRENCE S.	CAF 22-00001	2023 NY Slip Op 65440(U)
THE PEOPLE V LUIS FERNANDEZ	KA 20-00259	2023 NY Slip Op 65439(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHEAHONNIE DAVIS (APPEAL NO. 1)	KA 19-00250	2023 NY Slip Op 65438(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHEAHONNIE DAVIS (APPEAL NO. 2.)	KA 22-01216	2023 NY Slip Op 65437(U)
IN THE MATTER OF COLUMBUS MONUMENT CORPORATION, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST TO THE COLUMBUS MONUMENT	CA 22-00380	2023 NY Slip Op 65436(U)
IN THE MATTER OF AUBREY M.T., CARMON M.T., HILLARY M.T., KINSLEY R.T., AND SHAWNNA L.T.	CAF 23-00504	2023 NY Slip Op 65435(U)

**Motions Decided April 11, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF THOMAS J. SEGELIN V KELLEY M. WRIGHT	CAF 23-00595	2023 NY Slip Op 66285(U)
THE PEOPLE V ISAIAH C. WOODS	KA 23-00446	2023 NY Slip Op 65434(U)
THE PEOPLE V IONA WHITE	KA 23-00510	2023 NY Slip Op 65433(U)
THE PEOPLE V IONA E. WHITE	KA 23-00270	2023 NY Slip Op 65432(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ONONDAGA COUNTY, COMMISSIONER OF SOCIAL SERVICES, ON BEHALF OF DESLA L. SULLIVAN V MARSHEEN B. TAYLOR	CAF 23-00518	2023 NY Slip Op 65431(U)
THE PEOPLE V EZIEKIEL SMITH (Appeal No. 1.) THE PEOPLE V EZIEKIEL SMITH (Appeal No. 2.)	KA 19-02175 and KA 20-01043	2023 NY Slip Op 65430(U)
THE PEOPLE V BRANDON R. REIDER	KA 21-01623	2023 NY Slip Op 65429(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KATTIE M. OSBORNE V CHRISTOPHER S. TULWITS	CAF 23-00156	2023 NY Slip Op 65428(U)
THE PEOPLE V RICHARD MEIER	KA 22-01855	2023 NY Slip Op 65427(U)
THE PEOPLE V WILLIE MCTYERE	KA 20-00180	2023 NY Slip Op 65426(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOHN S. LEE	KA 19-02147	2023 NY Slip Op 65425(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JENELLE KING, V ANDREW PELKEY, .	CAF 23-00048	2023 NY Slip Op 65424(U)
PEOPLE V LEONARD JACKSON	KA 20-01317	2023 NY Slip Op 65423(U)
THE PEOPLE V DIQUAN HALL (Appeal No. 1.) THE PEOPLE V DIQUAN HALL (Appeal No. 2.)	KA 21-01738 and KA 22-00843	2023 NY Slip Op 65422(U)
THE PEOPLE V DAVION GARBUTT (Appeal No. 1.) THE PEOPLE V DAVION GARBUTT (Appeal No. 2.)	KA 22-01386 and KA 22-01387	2023 NY Slip Op 65421(U)
JAMIE GAYLOR V TERRY M. GAYLOR, JR. Index No: 90548	CA 23-00283	2023 NY Slip Op 65420(U)
THE PEOPLE V STEVEN C. FORSHEY	KA 22-00975	2023 NY Slip Op 65419(U)
THE PEOPLE V ERICA DAVIS	KA 23-00373	2023 NY Slip Op 65418(U)
THE PEOPLE V JAMES A. CHASE, ALSO KNOWN AS JAMES ALBERT CHASE, ALSO KNOWN AS JAMES CHASE Indictment No: 6188	KA 19-02115	2023 NY Slip Op 65417(U)
THE PEOPLE V DARRYL R. BROWN Indictment No: 2007/05168	KA 22-00396	2023 NY Slip Op 65416(U)
THE PEOPLE V TRAVIS BILLUPS	KA 19-01454	2023 NY Slip Op 65415(U)

**Motions Decided April 10, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF JEFF WILLIAMS V COUNTY OF WAYNE, COUNTY ATTORNEY DANIEL C. CONNORS, DISTRICT ATTORNEY MICHAEL D.	OP 23-00232	2023 NY Slip Op 65414(U)
TARUNA VARMA V ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY AND WAYNE LEVAN	CA 23-00385	2023 NY Slip Op 65413(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF STATE OF NEW YORK V TYREE A.	CA 23-00408	2023 NY Slip Op 65412(U)
THE PEOPLE V ALFRED J THOMAS	KA 21-01381	2023 NY Slip Op 65411(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DENISE M. THURSTON V PAT J. BOMBARD	CAF 22-01111	2023 NY Slip Op 65410(U)
THE PEOPLE V WILLIAM C. SHRUBSALL, ALSO KNOWN AS ETHAN MACLEOD	KA 20-01124	2023 NY Slip Op 65409(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JEAN C. SEVILLA V ROCHELLE TORRES	CAF 22-00517	2023 NY Slip Op 65408(U)
THE PEOPLE V JONATHAN SANCHEZ	KA 23-00355	2023 NY Slip Op 65407(U)
THE PEOPLE V MARK SALATINO	KA 23-00391	2023 NY Slip Op 65406(U)
IN THE MATTER OF RICHARD RAWLEIGH, SR. V STACI GALLT	CAF 23-00432	2023 NY Slip Op 65405(U)
THE PEOPLE V CONNIE L. POWERS	KA 23-00358	2023 NY Slip Op 65404(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF OCTAVUS PAIGE #17B2842 - V KRISTYNA S. MILLS,JEFFERSON COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY;	CA 23-00404	2023 NY Slip Op 65403(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHRISTOPHER A. NICHOLSON	KA 23-00375	2023 NY Slip Op 65402(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANTHONY L. NESMITH	KA 23-00374	2023 NY Slip Op 65401(U)
IN THE MATTER OF STATE OF NEW YORK V NATHAN E.	CA 22-01166	2023 NY Slip Op 65400(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MEGHAN O. MURIEL, V JUAN L. MURIEL, .	CAF 23-00545	2023 NY Slip Op 65399(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MEGHAN O. MURIEL, V JUAN L. MURIEL, .	CAF 23-00545	2023 NY Slip Op 65398(U)
MICHAEL MIMASSI V ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS OF VILLAGE OF NEW YORK MILLS, RICHARD LENART, ERNIE TALERICO, JOHN CONSTAS	CA 22-01048	2023 NY Slip Op 65397(U)
ANNE MACKIEWICZ, AS EXECUTRIX OF THE ESTATE OF PAUL O. JESSEN, DECEASED V AUTUMN VIEW HEALTH CARE FACILITY, AUTUMN VIEW	CA 23-00306	2023 NY Slip Op 65396(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CARLTON MASSEY V ONONDAGA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES, AND WENDY SULLIVAN	CAF 23-00041	2023 NY Slip Op 65395(U)
THE PEOPLE V IRA LIDGE	KA 23-00228	2023 NY Slip Op 65394(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOSHUA J. KRICK	KA 15-00226	2023 NY Slip Op 65393(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOSHUA J. KRICK	KA 15-00227	2023 NY Slip Op 65392(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALEXANDER KATES V LETITIA JAMES, ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR THE STATE OF NEW YORK, AND JOHN BRINGEWATT FOR	OP 23-00362	2023 NY Slip Op 65391(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ROBERT HUGHES V CHRISTIE COPES	CAF 22-01963	2023 NY Slip Op 65390(U)
PATRICK HARDEN AND KATHLEEN HARDEN V DAVID N. WEINRAUB, BROWN AND WEINRAUB, PLLC, LINDSAY ROBINSON AND JODI LYNN MCKAY	CA 22-01644	2023 NY Slip Op 65389(U)
GLENN FEDERMAN V TOWN OF LORRAINE, HIGHWAY SUPERINTENDENT JOSEPH WASILEWSKI, DEPUTY HIGHWAY SUPERINTENDENT HAROLD	CA 22-00575	2023 NY Slip Op 65388(U)
IN THE MATTER OF GIANNA A.	CAF 22-02011	2023 NY Slip Op 65387(U)
ROBERT FALLON V FIVE STAR MANAGEMENT SERVICES, LLC NOW KNOWN AS JEMILEE, LLC; JCR MEDICINE CANAL STREET, PLLC; AND NY	CA 22-01765	2023 NY Slip Op 65386(U)
THE PEOPLE V GENELL DAVIS	KA 23-00121	2023 NY Slip Op 65385(U)
THE PEOPLE V KNOWLEDGE COUSER	KA 23-00376	2023 NY Slip Op 65384(U)
KEVIN CONLEY AND DENISE CONLEY V PINELLI LANDSCAPING, INC.	CA 22-01021	2023 NY Slip Op 65383(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CAMERON H., HAILEY H., AND CALEB T.	CAF 22-00475	2023 NY Slip Op 65382(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SUZETTE BONERB V WHITNEY BONERB	CAF 22-01517	2023 NY Slip Op 65381(U)
IN THE MATTER OF AVEN F.	CAF 23-00292	2023 NY Slip Op 65380(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ARIONA P.	CAF 22-00160	2023 NY Slip Op 65379(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ARIONA P.	CAF 22-00267	2023 NY Slip Op 65378(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ARIA S.	CAF 21-00954	2023 NY Slip Op 65377(U)
THE PEOPLE V DEVIN J. ALVARADO	KA 23-00175	2023 NY Slip Op 65376(U)
THE PEOPLE V HARVEY ALEXANDER, JR.	KA 23-00336	2023 NY Slip Op 65375(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALIYAH M., D'ANDRE M., ELIJHA M., JR. MALAKAI M. AND MARQUEZ M.	CAF 23-00256	2023 NY Slip Op 65374(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALEXANDER AND CHRISTIAN P.	CAF 21-01796	2023 NY Slip Op 65373(U)

**Motions Decided April 7, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF WILLIAM C.	CAF 23-00253	2023 NY Slip Op 65372(U)
IN THE MATTER OF WILLIAM C.	CAF 23-00253	2023 NY Slip Op 65371(U)

**Motions Decided April 6, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF WENDY STEWART, FORMERLY KNOWN AS WENDY BACHEYIE V GILFORD BACHEYIE	CAF 23-00551	2023 NY Slip Op 65370(U)
IN THE MATTER OF STEVEN M.	CAF 22-00599	2023 NY Slip Op 65369(U)
IN THE MATTER OF REBECCA MANCHESTER V AARON P. KNECHTEL AMBER DINOFF	CAF 22-01249	2023 NY Slip Op 65368(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JAMES M. LITWINSKI, JR. V JENNIFER M. ADINOLFE	CAF 22-01390	2023 NY Slip Op 65367(U)
MATTER OF KIM A.F. V ALEXIS M.B.-R.	CAF 23-00549	2023 NY Slip Op 65366(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KAMERON R.	CAF 22-00797	2023 NY Slip Op 65365(U)
IN THE MATTER OF AMBER DINOFF V AARON P. KNECHTEL AND REBECCA MANCHESTER	CAF 22-01247	2023 NY Slip Op 65364(U)

**Motions Decided April 5, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF ERIN S. KELLEY V ROBERT B. CRAMMOND	CAF 23-00016	2023 NY Slip Op 64600(U)

**Motions Decided April 4, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF KATTIE M. OSBORNE V CHRISTOPHER S. TULWITS	CAF 23-00156	2023 NY Slip Op 64599(U)
YANETTA S. MATHIS V RYAN L. ROBINSON	CA 23-00525	2023 NY Slip Op 64598(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ROBERT HUGHES V CHRISTIE COPES	CAF 22-01963	2023 NY Slip Op 64597(U)
THE PEOPLE V EDWARD HARRIS	KA 22-01456	2023 NY Slip Op 64596(U)
THE PEOPLE V ROBERT GRAYSON	KA 17-00367	2023 NY Slip Op 64595(U)
IN THE MATTER OF GRACE K. AND NATHAN K.	CAF 23-00501	2023 NY Slip Op 64594(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHAWN J. COFFEE	KA 14-01239	2023 NY Slip Op 64593(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DANIEL J. BOYDEN V REBECCA H. MILLER	CAF 23-00357	2023 NY Slip Op 64592(U)
THE PEOPLE V YUSSUF ARBOW	KA 18-01751	2023 NY Slip Op 64591(U)

**Motions Decided April 3, 2023**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
KELLY V. ZARCONE V HOWARD W. ZARCONE	CA 22-00374	2023 NY Slip Op 64590(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TRONDELL WALLACE V MADARIA EURE IN THE MATTER OF TRONDELL WALLACE V MADARIA EURE	CAF 21-01176	2023 NY Slip Op 64589(U)
IN THE MATTER OF STEVEN M.	CAF 22-00599	2023 NY Slip Op 64588(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JORDAN D. SHAW V JOHN C. GARCIA	CA 23-00216	2023 NY Slip Op 64587(U)
THE PEOPLE V ERIN E. RHYNES, ALSO KNOWN AS ERIN ROSHAD KENDRELL EDWARDS	KA 19-01373	2023 NY Slip Op 64586(U)
PRIYANKA PARITI AND JAGANNADH PARITI V COUNTY OF MONROE, MONROE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND BRIGHTON	CA 22-01621	2023 NY Slip Op 64585(U)
IN THE MATTER OF NOAH C., ROMEO C., JADEN C., AND JACOB C.	CAF 22-01600	2023 NY Slip Op 64584(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KAMERON R.	CAF 22-00797	2023 NY Slip Op 64583(U)
TOMMY R. JACKSON V WILLIAM J. FITZPATRICK, ONONDAGA COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY, IN HIS INDIVIDUAL CAPACITY, STEFANO	CA 23-00382 and CA 24-00815	2023 NY Slip Op 79726(U)