Appellate Division, Fourth Department Motions

**Motions Decided May 27th, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
IN THE MATTER OF BRADLEY B.	CAF 25-01174 Docket No: NN-03895-23	2026 NY Slip Op 70119(U)
IN THE MATTER OF PRINCE-NOBEL B.	CAF 25-00190 Docket No: B-09494-18 CAF 25-00192 Docket No: B-09495-18 CAF 25-00193 Docket No: B-09497-18 CAF 25-00194 Docket No: B-15028-19	2026 NY Slip Op 70120(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOHN A. PORTER, III V SHAIQUIDA B. HAYES	CAF 25-01062 Docket No: F-04002-12/25J	2026 NY Slip Op 70121(U)
IN THE MATTER OF PHILLIP PRESTON, V SHQUANEBIN LONE	CAF 25-00586 Docket Nos: V-00573-24/24A V-00574-24/24A	2026 NY Slip Op 70122(U)
IN THE MATTER OF PHILLIP PRESTON, V SHQUANEBIN LONE	CAF 25-00586 Docket Nos: V-00573-24/24A V-00574-24/24A	2026 NY Slip Op 70123(U)

**Motions Decided May 26th, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
THE PEOPLE V JAMIE AVERY	KA 23-00938 Indictment No: 70089-22/001	2026 NY Slip Op 69001(U)
THE PEOPLE V ROBERT COFFIN	KA 18-01553 Indictment No: I17-335	2026 NY Slip Op 69002(U)
THE PEOPLE V LEE A. COOPER	KA 24-01225 Indictment No: 70399-23/001	2026 NY Slip Op 69003(U)
JENA COPELIN, - V TOWN OF LEWISTON AND AMY WITRYOL	CA 25-00725	2026 NY Slip Op 69004(U)
THE PEOPLE V FUQUAN K. HAMEED	KA 25-00290 Indictment No: 2023-0454-1	2026 NY Slip Op 69005(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANGELO J. HURLBURT, SR.	KA 25-01055 Indictment No: 70314-23/001	2026 NY Slip Op 69006(U)
US INCOME PARTNERS, LLC, V CYPRESS POINTE FL HOLDINGS, LLC, PHILLIPS LYTLE, LLP, ANTHONY M. CARELLO AND RYAN A. LOWN, .	CA 25-01490	2026 NY Slip Op 69007(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL L. SCHROCK	KA 26-00423 Indictment No: 06-115	2026 NY Slip Op 69008(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL L. SCHROCK	KA 26-00424 Indictment No: 06-115	2026 NY Slip Op 69009(U)
THE PEOPLE V MARLON SCOTT	KA 22-01821 Indictment No: 2021-0688	2026 NY Slip Op 69010(U)
THE PEOPLE, V MARLOW TABRON	KA 21-01805 Indictment No: I20-200	2026 NY Slip Op 69011(U)

**Motions Decided May 22nd, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
IN THE MATTER OF BRITTANY TRAPPLER V ERIC FREELAND IN THE MATTER OF BRITTANY TRAPPLER V ERIC FREELAND	CAF 26-00913 Docket No: O-00208-25 CAF 26-00914 Docket Nos: V-00034-25, V-00035-25, V-0034-25/25A,B, V-00035-25/25A,B, V-00132-25, V-00133-25, V-00132-25/25A, V-00133-25/25A, V-02043-2044-24	2026 NY Slip Op 69000(U)

**Motions Decided May 18th, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
BANK OF AMERICA, N.A. V CHRISTOPHER ALEXANDER SALCICCIOLI,	CA 26-00280	2026 NY Slip Op 68966(U)
THE PEOPLE V KIRK BIELANIN	KA 24-01953 Indictment No: 00975-2022	2026 NY Slip Op 68967(U)
THE PEOPLE V RAYMOND BIGELOW	KA 26-00385 SCI No: I-2019-0307-1 Index No: 19-3404	2026 NY Slip Op 68968(U)
THE PEOPLE V SADIQ BONNER-JUDGE THE PEOPLE V SADIQ K. BONNER-JUDGE	KA 26-00143 and KA 26-00166 Indictment No: 70392-21/001 Indictment No: 70108-21/002	2026 NY Slip Op 68969(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOHN P. BROWN V ONTARIO COUNTY SUPREME COURT	OP 26-00532	2026 NY Slip Op 68970(U)
THE PEOPLE V DOUGLAS A. BUSCH	KA 23-00463 Indictment No: 70518-21/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68971(U)
THE PEOPLE V HAROLD J. CALKINS THE PEOPLE V HAROLD CALKINS	KA 26-00573 and KA 26-00574 Indictment No: 70315-25/001 Indictment No: 70222-25/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68972(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOENATHAN CASH	KA 23-01224 Indictment No: 2021-0133B	2026 NY Slip Op 68973(U)
IN THE MATTER OF WELLS COLLEGE	CA 26-00730	2026 NY Slip Op 68974(U)
THE PEOPLE V MEGAN COSTELLO	KA 26-00860 Indictment No: 2022-0785-2	2026 NY Slip Op 68975(U)
US INCOME PARTNERS, LLC, V CYPRESS POINTE FL HOLDINGS, LLC, PHILLIPS LYTLE, LLP, ANTHONY M. CARELLO AND RYAN A. LOWN, .	CA 25-01490	2026 NY Slip Op 68976(U)
US INCOME PARTNERS, LLC, V CYPRESS POINTE FL HOLDINGS, LLC, PHILLIPS LYTLE, LLP, ANTHONY M. CARELLO AND RYAN A. LOWN, .	CA 25-01490	2026 NY Slip Op 68977(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOHN W. FERGUSON	KA 19-01777 Indictment No: I18-233	2026 NY Slip Op 68978(U)
GLENN FEDERMAN, CLAIMANT- V STATE OF NEW YORK	CA 25-01171	2026 NY Slip Op 68979(U)
IN THE MATTER OF STATE OF NEW YORK V FREDERICK B.	CA 25-01686	2026 NY Slip Op 68980(U)
THE PEOPLE V TERRANCE B. HINES	KA 25-01457 Indictment No: 70257-24/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68981(U)
THE PEOPLE V DAVID M. HUNT	KA 25-00018 SCI No: 70131-22/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68982(U)
THE PEOPLE V KARON JAMES	KA 23-00289 Indictment No: 2021-0601B	2026 NY Slip Op 68983(U)
MERIMA KAJTEZOVIC V HUSEIN KAJTEZOVIC	CA 24-01553	2026 NY Slip Op 68984(U)
RIMA MIAN KHAN V MEHDI ALI KHAN	CA 25-01009	2026 NY Slip Op 68985(U)
THE PEOPLE V ELWELL MCPHAIL	KA 26-00832 Indictment No: 2017-1161	2026 NY Slip Op 68986(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHARLES MONTAGUE THE PEOPLE V CHARLES MONTAGUE	KA 23-01646 and KA 23-01647 Indictment No: CR-2330-20 Indictment No: CR-04234-21	2026 NY Slip Op 68987(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHAWN O. MOORE, JR.	KA 19-00838 Indictment No: 17-417-17	2026 NY Slip Op 68988(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOHN P. BROWN V ONTARIO COUNTY SUPREME COURT	OP 26-00532	2026 NY Slip Op 68989(U)
THE PEOPLE V DARYL W. PIERSON	KA 25-00756 Indictment No: 70662-23/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68990(U)
THE PEOPLE V RAFAEL R. PRESTOL	KA 24-00270 Indictment No: 70018-22/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68991(U)
ASTON B. WILSON, SHARIF J. BOSLEY, AND YOUNG WORLD BIG BIZ LLC V PUFFALO DREAMS INC., FLOWER CITY SHOP LLC, PHETNAKHONG	CA 26-00040	2026 NY Slip Op 68992(U)
THE PEOPLE V JESSE J. ROBERTS, JR.	KA 26-00524 Indictment No: 60028-24	2026 NY Slip Op 68993(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOHN L. SMITH	KA 24-01735 Indictment No: 70888-23/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68994(U)
RICHARD L. SPOSATO V VILLAGE OF SOLVAY, DENNIS AGUAYO, MARK LEPETICH, AND MICHAEL ROOT	CA 26-00815	2026 NY Slip Op 68995(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOSEPH R. STEELE	KA 24-00633 Indictment No: 70606-23/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68996(U)
THE PEOPLE V PAUL TOLBERT	KA 22-00876 Indictment No: 02007-2020	2026 NY Slip Op 68997(U)
IN THE MATTER OF BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF VILLAGE OF PENN YAN V TOWN COUNCIL OF TOWN OF MILO	OP 25-00325	2026 NY Slip Op 68998(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JON Z. AND VICTOR Z. FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF A GUARDIAN OF THE PROPERTY AND/OR PERSON OF MARGARET Z.	CA 18-01987, CA 18-01988, and CA 18-01989	2026 NY Slip Op 68999(U)

**Motions Decided May 14th, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
IN THE MATTER OF SHELBY J. HILL V JEFFERY S. DEFAZIO IN THE MATTER OF JEFFERY S. DEFAZIO V SHELBY J. HILL	CAF 25-00463 Docket No: V-00158-23/23D CAF 25-00464 Docket No: V-00158-23/24F	2026 NY Slip Op 68965(U)

**Motions Decided May 12th, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
THE PEOPLE V DARRELL BOYD 2013/005596	KA 26-00704 Indictment Nos: 0396-2013 70006-2013	2026 NY Slip Op 68936(U)
JING CHEN V DAVID P. WILLIAMS	CA 25-01978	2026 NY Slip Op 68937(U)
JING CHEN V DAVID P. WILLIAMS	CA 25-01978, CA 25-02005, CA 26-00130, CA 26-00361, CA 26-00362, AND CA 26-00483	2026 NY Slip Op 68938(U)
JING CHEN V DAVID P. WILLIAMS	CA 25-01978, CA 25-02005, CA 26-00130, CA 26-00361, CA 26-00362, AND CA 26-00483	2026 NY Slip Op 68939(U)
JING CHEN V DAVID P. WILLIAMS Index No.: 003167/2025	CA 26-00130, CA 26-00361, CA 26-00362, AND CA 26-00483	2026 NY Slip Op 68940(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOHN C. COLE	KA 25-01992 Indictment No: 70044-11 Previously: 2011-0420A	2026 NY Slip Op 68941(U)
PATRICK J. DHONDT V HON. GEORGE PANEBIANCO, HON. JOHN I. LAMANCUSO, THE PEOPLE	CA 26-00700	2026 NY Slip Op 68942(U)
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORATION, AS TRUSTEE FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE FREDDIE MAC SEASONED LOANS STRUCTURED	CA 26-00363	2026 NY Slip Op 68943(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOSEPH M. FUSCO III V HON. JOHN B. GALLAGHER, JR., IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME	OP 26-00065	2026 NY Slip Op 68944(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHRISTIAN GARRAMONE	KA 26-00634 Indictment No: I-2009-394	2026 NY Slip Op 68945(U)
FRANK GARCIA, CLAIMANT- V STATE OF NEW YORK Claim No.: 143707	CA 26-00058	2026 NY Slip Op 68946(U)
THE PEOPLE V DARRYL GLOVER	KA 26-00696 Indictment No: 70450-23/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68947(U)
THE PEOPLE V PERRY GRIGGS	KA 26-00707 Indictment No: 01397-2010	2026 NY Slip Op 68948(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF KEVIN HARVEY V SUPREME COURT, MONROE COUNTY (HON. JUSTICE STEPEHN T. MILLER)	OP 26-00631	2026 NY Slip Op 68949(U)
TODD E. MORRIS V IRINI KARIPIDIS Index No.: E2023012550	CA 26-00650	2026 NY Slip Op 68950(U)
THE PEOPLE V PAUL M. KHOUZAM	KA 21-01750 Indictment No: 18-66	2026 NY Slip Op 68951(U)
THE PEOPLE V DAVID LOFTON	KA 24-00092 Indictment No: 2021-0678	2026 NY Slip Op 68952(U)
THE PEOPLE V JAKAI LOFTON	KA 26-00768 Indictment No: 01532-2023	2026 NY Slip Op 68953(U)
THE PEOPLE V JAKAI LOFTON	KA 26-00769 Indictment No: 00479-2023	2026 NY Slip Op 68954(U)
THE PEOPLE V LEE O. MORGAN	KA 26-00627 SCI No: 70103-23/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68955(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL R. MULLEN, JR.	KA 25-01093 SCI No: 70110-22/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68956(U)
IN THE MATTER OF NY BOSTON II, LLC V ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS OF THE TOWN OF BOSTON AND CITIZENS OF FEDDICK ROAD, BY ITS	CA 25-01985	2026 NY Slip Op 68957(U)
THE PEOPLE V MALEEK A. ODUSANYA	KA 23-00992 Indictment No: 70094-21/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68958(U)
THE PEOPLE V JESSE D. OUTLEY	KA 24-01263 Indictment No: 2023-0117-1	2026 NY Slip Op 68959(U)
STACEY PYNN V HON. FRANK A. SEDITA III, AS SUPREME COURT JUSTICE, NEW YORK STATE UNIFIED COURT SYSTEM, NEW YORK STATE	OP 25-01936	2026 NY Slip Op 68960(U)
THE PEOPLE V JERAMY G. RIVERA	KA 26-00626 Indictment No: 21-01-022	2026 NY Slip Op 68961(U)
PAUL RYAN V SUSAN CUNNINGHAM, ALAN LINCOLN, NANCY KERRIGAN, CHARLIE BERNET, KRISTA TASKEY, DIANA MARLEY, DAVID SMART	CA 26-00129	2026 NY Slip Op 68962(U)
NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF CANNABIS MANAGEMENT V GEORGE F. WEST, INDIVIDUALLY AND D/B/A "JAYDEGA 7.0"	CA 25-02064	2026 NY Slip Op 68963(U)
MARLENA WRZOS V JASON HASKELL, - .	CA 25-00375	2026 NY Slip Op 68964(U)

**Motions Decided May 11th, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
IN THE MATTER OF KRISTIN S. BUCHHOLZ V ROBERT TROMBLEY, JR.	CAF 25-00372 Docket Nos: V-00649-11/24U V-00270-12/24U V-270-12/23T	2026 NY Slip Op 68922(U)
THE PEOPLE V JAMES W. BURGESS THE PEOPLE V JAMES W. BURGESS	KA 24-01469 and KA 24-01470 Indictment No: 70189-21/001 Indictment No: 70190-21/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68923(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MICHAEL CARROLL V MARA CARROLL	CAF 25-00232 Docket No: V-14292-23/23A	2026 NY Slip Op 68924(U)
JULIE E. PASEK, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS A POWER OF ATTORNEY FOR JAMES G. PASEK V CATHOLIC HEALTH SYSTEM, INC. , TERUMO	CA 25-01307	2026 NY Slip Op 68925(U)
JEFFREY B. DICKINSON V KRISTEN B. WHELAN	CA 25-00274	2026 NY Slip Op 68926(U)
KIRK HAUSER V DAVID MURPHY	CA 25-01625	2026 NY Slip Op 68927(U)
KATHLEEN HUGHES, AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF MATILDA MCLEOD V ALPHA HARRIS , PREMIUM MORTGAGE CORPORATION AND	CA 24-01744	2026 NY Slip Op 68928(U)
THE PEOPLE EX REL., DANIEL JONES V DANIELLE TOPE, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, SECURE TREATMENT AND REHABILITATION CENTER	KAH 25-01882	2026 NY Slip Op 68929(U)
CHRISTINA KANE AND WAYNE G. MARTIN, JR. V STEVEN HOPKINS	CA 25-02103	2026 NY Slip Op 68930(U)
THE PEOPLE V ELWELL MCPHAIL	KA 18-01514 Indictment No: 2017-1161	2026 NY Slip Op 68931(U)
THE PEOPLE V WAYNE ROBBINS	KA 24-01633 Indictment No: 00889-2021	2026 NY Slip Op 68932(U)
THE PEOPLE V DIAMONTE SCOTT	KA 23-01023 Indictment No: 70632-21/003	2026 NY Slip Op 68933(U)
THE PEOPLE V DAVID J. STEINMETZ	KA 25-00873 Indictment No: 70118-24/001	2026 NY Slip Op 68934(U)
THE PEOPLE V FONTASIA TORAN	KA 26-00444 Indictment No: 2020-0246-2	2026 NY Slip Op 68935(U)

**Motions Decided May 6th, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
IN THE MATTER OF ANDRE S. NESMITH V FATHIA ABDOCH	CAF 25-01328 Docket Nos: V-05192-22/24D, V-05192-22/24E	2026 NY Slip Op 68921(U)

**Motions Decided May 5th, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
IN THE MATTER OF SUSAN G. CANDE V CHRISTINA CELLINI AND MICHAEL A. ORGANEK	CAF 26-00098 Docket Nos: V-07128-25 V-07129-25	2026 NY Slip Op 68919(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CHARLENE LASHA CHANDLER V STACY EMANUEL JACKSON IN THE MATTER OF TATINA LEWIS V STACY EMANUEL JACKSON	CAF 25-01995 Docket No: F-10971-07 CAF 25-02006 Docket No: P-14767-03	2026 NY Slip Op 68920(U)

**Motions Decided May 4th, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
TAMMY DEES AND DAKOTA BOLAND, ON BEHALF OF THEMSELVES AND OTHERS SIMILARLY SITUATED V T.L. CANNON CORP., APPLEBEES	CA 25-01356	2026 NY Slip Op 67697(U)
STEVEN P. DINIERI V MICHAEL D. DINIERI	CA 25-01729	2026 NY Slip Op 67698(U)
DAVID M. SZCZESNY, AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF MARY R. SZCZESNY, DECEASED V ROBERT S. ARMSTRONG, M.D. RURIK	CA 25-01229	2026 NY Slip Op 67699(U)
THE PEOPLE EX REL., STEPHEN FRANCIS KUBER, III V CHRISTOPHER YEHL, SUPERINTENDENT, WENDE CORRECTIONAL FACILITY	KAH 25-01137	2026 NY Slip Op 67700(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHRISTOPHER J. MICHIK	KA 24-01037 Indictment No: 70807-23/001	2026 NY Slip Op 67701(U)
THE PEOPLE, V NATHANIEL C. MYERS	KA 24-00431 Indictment No: 00286-2021	2026 NY Slip Op 67702(U)
THE PEOPLE V RAMEHER PULLEY	KA 24-02005 and KA 24-02006 Indictment No: 2023-0615-3 Indictment No: 2023-0649-1	2026 NY Slip Op 67703(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF JOSE RIVERA V DANIEL F. MARTUSCELLO III COMMISSIONER OF NYSDOCCS	CA 26-00811 Index No: 2025-0884	2026 NY Slip Op 67704(U)
THE PEOPLE V EARL ROBERTS	KA 22-01557 Indictment No: I20-073	2026 NY Slip Op 67705(U)
WILMINGTON TRUST NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, AS TRUSTEE FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE REGISTERED HOLDERS OF JPMBB COMMERCIAL	CA 25-01133	2026 NY Slip Op 67706(U)

**Motions Decided May 1st, 2026**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
IN THE MATTER OF JUNIPER T.	CAF 25-00650 Docket No: NA-00453-24	2026 NY Slip Op 67696(U)