Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided October 29, 2020**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Xavier Blade Lee Billy Joe S. (Josefina S.)	Docket No. B7087/14 Appeal No. 11929&M-3154 Case No. 2019-1648	2020 NY Slip Op 06196
King Penguin Opportunity Fund III, LLC v Spectrum Group Mgt. LLC	Index No. 154084/18 Appeal No. 12244 Case No. 2019-5732	2020 NY Slip Op 06230
Matter of Amar v New York City Empls.' Retirement Sys.	Index No. 101751/18 Appeal No. 12254 Case No. 2019-4618	2020 NY Slip Op 06229
Matter of Lewis v New York City Hous. Auth.	Index No. 160578/18 Appeal No. 12253 Case No. 2019-4762	2020 NY Slip Op 06228
Zemsky v Prokofieva	Index No. 805282/16 Appeal No. 12252 Case No. 2019-5091	2020 NY Slip Op 06227
People v White	Ind No. 3710/11 Appeal No. 12251 Case No. 2012-02015	2020 NY Slip Op 06226
Matter of Tate v O'Neill	Index No. 151123/19 Appeal No. 12250 Case No. 2020-02273	2020 NY Slip Op 06225
Hidalgo v Vasquez	Index No. 303148/16 Appeal No. 12249 Case No. 2019-04958	2020 NY Slip Op 06224
Madison Ave. I LLC v Marecheau	Index No. 157359/18 Appeal No. 12248 Case No. 2019-04187	2020 NY Slip Op 06223
People v Bowser	Ind No. 2978/14 Appeal No. 12247 Case No. 2018-4481	2020 NY Slip Op 06222
Board of Mgrs. of Be@William Condominium v 90 William St. Dev. Group LLC	Index No. 105137/11 Appeal No. 12246-12246A Case No. 2019-3298, 2019-3367	2020 NY Slip Op 06221
People v Albergottie	Ind No. 281/15 Appeal No. 12245 Case No. 2018-03027	2020 NY Slip Op 06220
People v McCray	Ind No. 3920/08 3920/08 Appeal No. 12241-12241A Case No. 2016-2146	2020 NY Slip Op 06219
Samoya W. v 3940 Carpenter Ave., LLC	Index No. 350433/12 Appeal No. 12240 Case No. 2019-03477	2020 NY Slip Op 06218
Matter of Jadiel M. (Naqwaun B.)	Docket No. N4748/2017 Appeal No. 12238 Case No. 2019-05029	2020 NY Slip Op 06217
Capstone Business Funding, LLC v Sanitas Partners V.I., LLC	Index No. 652784/18 Appeal No. 12237 Case No. 2019-4305	2020 NY Slip Op 06216
People v El-Amin	Ind No. 2295/15 2295/15 Appeal No. 12236&[M-3064] Case No. 2019-626	2020 NY Slip Op 06215
Olsen v Smith	Index No. 100164/18 Appeal No. 12235 Case No. 2019-2637	2020 NY Slip Op 06214
Shyer v Shyer	Index No. 651109/18 595921/18 Appeal No. 12234 Case No. 2020-01334	2020 NY Slip Op 06213
Matter of Halcomb v New York City Dept. of Hous. Preserv. & Dev.	Index No. 153890/19 Appeal No. 12233 Case No. 2019-04151	2020 NY Slip Op 06212
People v Koenigsberg	Ind No. 232/16 Appeal No. 12232 Case No. 2018-4597	2020 NY Slip Op 06211
Raphael v Vintage Grape & Grog, Ltd.	Index No. 159028/18 Appeal No. 12231 Case No. 2019-03297	2020 NY Slip Op 06210
Kemper Independence Ins. Co. v AB Med. Supply, Inc.	Index No. 153707/18 Appeal No. 12229 Case No. 2020-02270	2020 NY Slip Op 06209
Kuzmich v 50 Murray St. Acquisition LLC	Index No. 155266/16 Appeal No. 12228 Case No. 2019-05132	2020 NY Slip Op 06208
Weir v Weir	Index No. 313319/11 Appeal No. 12227 Case No. 2019-04128	2020 NY Slip Op 06207
People v Cummings	Ind No. 4117/17 Appeal No. 12226 Case No. 2019-3442	2020 NY Slip Op 06206
Pedoto v City of New York	Index No. 307183/11 Appeal No. 12225 Case No. 2019-05409	2020 NY Slip Op 06205
Board of Mgrs. of the Towers on the Park Condominium v Cruz	Index No. 157132/17 Appeal No. 12224 Case No. 2019-4666	2020 NY Slip Op 06204
Matter of Alico Servs. Corp. v Westchester Bldg. Co. LLC	Index No. 656456/18 Appeal No. 12223 Case No. 2020-01989	2020 NY Slip Op 06203
People v Credle	Ind No. 649/17 Appeal No. 12222 Case No. 2019-1158	2020 NY Slip Op 06202
Eurotech Constr. Corp. v Illinois Natl. Ins. Co.	Index No. 650510/14 Appeal No. 12221 Case No. 2019-04314	2020 NY Slip Op 06201
Chowaniec v AACC Inc.	Index No. 157375/16 Appeal No. 12220 Case No. 2020-01265	2020 NY Slip Op 06200
Matter of Hyland P. v Ericka B.	Docket No. V29041/17 Appeal No. 12219 Case No. 2019-2714	2020 NY Slip Op 06199
Mitchell v 423 W. 55th St.	Index No. 154366/12 Appeal No. 12218 Case No. 2020-02380	2020 NY Slip Op 06198
People v Williamson	Ind No. 2595/16 2595/16 Appeal No. 12217-12217A Case No. 2018-1496	2020 NY Slip Op 06197

**Cases Decided October 27, 2020**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
U.S. Bank Natl. Assn. v Hao T. Hoang	Index No. 850176/15 Appeal No. 12216N Case No. 2019-04946	2020 NY Slip Op 06077
Matter of Amberlina V. (Alexis R.)	Dkt. No. NN-26053/17 Appeal No. 12199-12199A Case No. 2019-04252	2020 NY Slip Op 06078
3P-733, LLC v Davis	Index No. 650800/18 Appeal No. 12186 Case No. 2019-4109	2020 NY Slip Op 06043
U.S. Bank Trust, N.A. v Board of Mgrs. of the Devon Condominium	Index No. 850076/17 Appeal No. 12192-12192A Case No. 2019-3768	2020 NY Slip Op 06076
Tusu v Leone	Index No. 301290/16 Appeal No. 12182 Case No. 2019-04969	2020 NY Slip Op 06075
Theroux v Resnicow	Index No. 154642/17 Appeal No. 12201 Case No. 2019-5576	2020 NY Slip Op 06074
Romano v One City Block LLC	Index No. 303911/15 Appeal No. 12185 Case No. 2020-00068	2020 NY Slip Op 06073
Poivan-Traub v Chaglassian	Index No. 805394/13 Appeal No. 12203 Case No. 2020-02342	2020 NY Slip Op 06072
Philip v G.O.L.A., Inc.	Index No. 650905/16 Appeal No. 12190 Case No. 2019-4902	2020 NY Slip Op 06071
People v Walton	Ind No. 3188/15 Appeal No. 12194 Case No. 2017-2549	2020 NY Slip Op 06070
People v DePalo	Ind No. 1450/15 Appeal No. 12191 Case No. 2018-4432	2020 NY Slip Op 06069
People v Colon	Ind No. 5073/10 826/11 2527/11 Appeal No. 12178 Case No. 2016/887	2020 NY Slip Op 06068
People v Encarnacion	Ind No. 1115/14 Appeal No. 12183 Case No. 2017-255	2020 NY Slip Op 06067
People v Ramos	Sci. No. 3654/17 Appeal No. 12206 Case No. 2019-3025	2020 NY Slip Op 06066
People v Cordon	Ind No. 936/15 Appeal No. 12197 Case No. 2018-2025	2020 NY Slip Op 06065
People v Dalton	Ind No. 2747/17 Appeal No. 12202 Case No. 2018-4932	2020 NY Slip Op 06064
People v Akino	Ind No. 3043/06 Appeal No. 12209 Case No. 2008-2322	2020 NY Slip Op 06063
People v Parks	Ind No. 4000/08 Appeal No. 12212 Case No. 2018-1410	2020 NY Slip Op 06062
People v Joseph	Ind No. 1347/17 Appeal No. 12187 Case No. 2018-6074	2020 NY Slip Op 06061
People v Banyan	Ind No. 2052/16 2052/16 Appeal No. 11928 Case No. 2017-2327	2020 NY Slip Op 06060
Olivare v Tomlin	Index No. 303336/16 Appeal No. 12179 Case No. 2019-03656	2020 NY Slip Op 06059
Morel v City of New York	Index No. 21087/12 Appeal No. 12211-12211A Case No. 2019-4576	2020 NY Slip Op 06058
Matter of Lenahan v Chandler	Index No. 154955/18 Appeal No. 12193 Case No. 2019-04225	2020 NY Slip Op 06057
Katz v Siano	Index No. 152809/19 Appeal No. 12215 Case No. 2020-2751	2020 NY Slip Op 06056
Katsky Korins, LLP v International Dev. Inst., Inc.	Index No. 657285/17 Appeal No. 12198 Case No. 2020-01390	2020 NY Slip Op 06055
IG Second Generation Partners, L.P. v 166 Enters. Corp.	Index No. 652962/13 Appeal No. 12214 Case No. 2019-4751	2020 NY Slip Op 06054
Gorman v Gorman	Index No. 312525/10 Appeal No. 12204 Case No. 2019-3095(1)	2020 NY Slip Op 06053
Gonzalez v Miles	Index No. 30966/17 Appeal No. 12196N Case No. 2020-01949	2020 NY Slip Op 06052
Five Star Elec. Corp. v A.J. Pegno Constr. Co., Inc./Tully Constr. Co., Inc.	Index No. 400897/11 Appeal No. 12207 Case No. 2020-02955	2020 NY Slip Op 06051
Cohen v Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C.	Index No. 154650/13 Appeal No. 12189 Case No. 2019-3827	2020 NY Slip Op 06050
Matter of Bradeanu v Davis	Index No. 100276/19 Appeal No. 12195 Case No. 2019-05457	2020 NY Slip Op 06049
Board of Mgrs. of the Apthorp Condominium v Apthorp Garage LLC	Index No. 850021/18 Appeal No. 12210-12210A Case No. 2019-4484	2020 NY Slip Op 06048
Benefatti v Centerlight Healthcare, Inc.	Index No. 21614/14E Appeal No. 12200 Case No. 2019-4909	2020 NY Slip Op 06047
Matter of Melinda B. v Jonathan L.P.	Docket No. O-14051-17 Appeal No. 12180 Case No. 2019-05108	2020 NY Slip Op 06046
Button v Metropolitan Club, Inc.	Index No. 650008/16 656625/17 Appeal No. 12188-12188A Case No. 2019-1701	2020 NY Slip Op 06045
American Infertility of N.Y., P.C. v Kushnir	Index No. 655306/18 Appeal No. 12208 Case No. 2020-02917	2020 NY Slip Op 06044

**Cases Decided October 22, 2020**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Anonymous		Ind No. 5046/15 5046/15 Appeal No. 12174 Case No. 2018-1621	2020 NY Slip Op 06006
Vlachos v Thomas		Index No. 152087/17 Appeal No. 12177N Case No. 2019-03367N	2020 NY Slip Op 06041
U.S. Bank Trust N.A. v Rivera		Index No. 382784/09 Appeal No. 12154N Case No. 2019-04247	2020 NY Slip Op 06040
Matter of TCR Sports Broadcasting Holding, LLP v WN Partner, LLC		Index No. Index No. 652044/14 Appeal No. 12147-12147A-12147B Case No. 2019-05390 2019-05458 2019-05459	2020 NY Slip Op 06039
Matter of Stephens v New York State Div. of Human Rights		Index No. 100699/18 Appeal No. 12163 Case No. 2019-5430	2020 NY Slip Op 06038
Sinera v Bedford-Webster LLC		Index No. 23902/15E Appeal No. 12171 Case No. 2019-04678	2020 NY Slip Op 06037
Matter of Government Empls. Ins. Co. v Pellot		Index No. 20445/14E 24691/14E Appeal No. 12167 Case No. 2020-01958	2020 NY Slip Op 06036
Olivia R. v Morris		Index No. 805116/14 Appeal No. 12173-12173A Case No. 2019-2400	2020 NY Slip Op 06035
Rodriguez v Extell W. 57th St. LLC		Index No. 300786/14 Appeal No. 12156N Case No. 2020-01945	2020 NY Slip Op 06034
Roberts v Liberty Lines Tr., Inc.		Index No. 20424/13E Appeal No. 12175N Case No. 2019-4790N	2020 NY Slip Op 06033
Matter of Pullins v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 452826/15 Appeal No. 12150 Case No. 2019-5741	2020 NY Slip Op 06032
Plotch v 435 E. 85th St. Tenants Corp.		Index No. 157881/17 Appeal No. 12139-12139A Case No. 2018-5126	2020 NY Slip Op 06031
People v Owens		Ind No. 1283/17 1272/18 Appeal No. 12169 Case No. 2019-2470	2020 NY Slip Op 06030
People v Smith		FalseAppeal No. 12142 Case No. 2018-748	2020 NY Slip Op 06029
People v Jones		Ind No. 1490/16 1490/16 Appeal No. 12164 Case No. 2018-360	2020 NY Slip Op 06028
People v Manafort		Ind No. 774/19 Appeal No. 12170 Case No. 2020-1097	2020 NY Slip Op 06027
People v Powell		Ind No. 576/16 576/16 Appeal No. 12148 Case No. 2017-03443	2020 NY Slip Op 06026
People v Baez		Ind No. 2454/16 2454/16 Appeal No. 12166 Case No. 2019-3139	2020 NY Slip Op 06025
People v McLaurin		Ind No. 1160/13 1160/13 Appeal No. 12138 Case No. 2015-2717	2020 NY Slip Op 06024
People v Rositas		Ind No. 1408/13 1408/13 Appeal No. 12152 Case No. 2018-1409	2020 NY Slip Op 06023
People v Rogers		Ind No. 3975/14 3975/14 Appeal No. 12151 Case No. 2017-2875	2020 NY Slip Op 06022
People v Bernstein		FalseAppeal No. 12143 Case No. 2019-3533	2020 NY Slip Op 06021
People v Graham		Ind No. 5310/15 3641/16 571N/17 914/17 Appeal No. 12158-12158A Case No. 2018-2670 2019-1801	2020 NY Slip Op 06020
Mishkin v Mascolo		Index No. 152788/15 Appeal No. 12172 Case No. 2019-21723	2020 NY Slip Op 06019
Matter of Meltzer	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2020-2703 Case No. 2020-3443	2020 NY Slip Op 06018
Hudak v Good Samaritan Hosp. of Suffern, N.Y.		Index No. 101448/10 Appeal No. 12144 Case No. 2019-4461	2020 NY Slip Op 06017
Matter of Kamal v CureMD.com, Inc.		Index No. 656306/18 Appeal No. 12176-12176A Case No. 2020-00607	2020 NY Slip Op 06016
Giron v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 22599/16 Appeal No. 12149 Case No. 2019-3699	2020 NY Slip Op 06015
Funkelstein v City of New York		Index No. 154324/16 Appeal No. 12162 Case No. 2019-4819	2020 NY Slip Op 06014
ECD NY Inc. v 616 First Ave. Dev. LLC		Index No. 650725/18 Appeal No. 12145-12146 Case No. 2020-00092 2020-00095	2020 NY Slip Op 06013
Deschaine v Tricon Constr., LLC		Index No. 161654/14 595123/15 595166/15 595184/15 Appeal No. 12141 Case No. 2019-03750	2020 NY Slip Op 06012
Matter of Crawford v Brezenhoff		Index No. 452177/18 Appeal No. 12140 Case No. 2019-5735	2020 NY Slip Op 06011
China Privatization Fund (Del.), L.P. v Galaxy Entertainment Group Ltd.		Index No. 650587/11 Appeal No. 12165 Case No. 2019-1727	2020 NY Slip Op 06010
Matter of Brioso v Motor Veh. Acc. Indem. Corp.		Index No. 33073/18E Appeal No. 12159 Case No. 2020-01912	2020 NY Slip Op 06009
Borges v Rose		Index No. 42084/15E Appeal No. 12161-12161A Case No. 2019-2174(1)	2020 NY Slip Op 06008
Arouh v Rosenfeld		Index No. 652326/15 Appeal No. 12168 Case No. 2019-4774	2020 NY Slip Op 06007

**Cases Decided October 20, 2020**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Francis	Ind No. 8031C/05 642/05 8031C/05 642/05 Appeal No. 12115 Case No. 2017-2885	2020 NY Slip Op 05867
Holmberg v Bevcon Group Inc.	Index No. 156130/15 Appeal No. 12110 Case No. 2020-01592	2020 NY Slip Op 05876
Yaffe v Shkreli	Index No. 651784/18 Appeal No. 12116N Case No. 2019-04898	2020 NY Slip Op 05875
Townsend v New York City Hous. Auth.	Index No. 302927/16 Appeal No. 12121 Case No. 2019-03285	2020 NY Slip Op 05874
Sultana v St. Elizabeth Med. Ctr.	Index No. 805233/19 Appeal No. 12134N Case No. 2020-00698	2020 NY Slip Op 05873
People v Disla	Ind No. 4006N/12 4006N/12 Appeal No. 7361 Case No. 2014-01596	2020 NY Slip Op 05872
People v Rich	Ind No. 932/15 932/15 Appeal No. 12112 Case No. 2018-1108	2020 NY Slip Op 05871
People v Gonzalez	Ind No. 1975/06 1975/06 Appeal No. 12105 Case No. 2018-2297	2020 NY Slip Op 05870
People v Adolph	FalseAppeal No. 12108 Case No. 2016-2039	2020 NY Slip Op 05869
People v Bloch	Ind No. 2443/15 Appeal No. 12099 Case No. 2018-03175	2020 NY Slip Op 05868
Idelfonso v City of New York	Index No. 302462/15 Appeal No. 12114 Case No. 2019-04164	2020 NY Slip Op 05854
People v Tall	Docket No. 060766/14N Appeal No. 12127 Case No. 2017-2023	2020 NY Slip Op 05866
People v Pena	Ind No. 5269N/14 Appeal No. 12106 Case No. 2018-1715	2020 NY Slip Op 05865
People v Garcia	Ind No. 3248/14 3248/14 Appeal No. 12123 Case No. 2018-4100	2020 NY Slip Op 05864
People v Hernandez	Ind No. 2968/15 Appeal No. 12126 Case No. 2018-3883	2020 NY Slip Op 05863
People v Garcia	SCI No. 4147/18 Appeal No. 12131 Case No. 2019-827	2020 NY Slip Op 05862
Ovalle v Buckwalter	Index No. 20677/15E Appeal No. 12113 Case No. 2018-5934	2020 NY Slip Op 05861
Matter of Bryan v Castro	Index No. 500107/07 Appeal No. 12119-12119A Case No. 2019-04720(1)	2020 NY Slip Op 05860
La Scoula D'Italia Guglielmo Marconi v Gates Capital Corp.	Index No. 650419/18 Appeal No. 12104 Case No. 2019-5938	2020 NY Slip Op 05859
Matter of Stephanie M. v Edgar C.	Docket No. O-3523/18 Appeal No. 12101 Case No. 2018-3637	2020 NY Slip Op 05858
Lvovsky v Lvovsky	Index No. 300055/14 Appeal No. 12103 Case No. 2019-2685	2020 NY Slip Op 05857
Kingston v International Business Machs. Corp.	Index No. 156289/18 Appeal No. 12107 Case No. 2019-04188	2020 NY Slip Op 05856
JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. v Executor of the Estate of Lerner	Index No. 850171/13 Appeal No. 11395-,11395A Case No. 2019-4179	2020 NY Slip Op 05855
Brummer v Wey	Index No. 153583/15 Appeal No. 12135-12136N-12136NA Case No. 2020-1794, 2020-00882	2020 NY Slip Op 05846
Hewitt v NY 70th St. LLC	Index No. 20953/17E Appeal No. 11636 Case No. 2019-03930	2020 NY Slip Op 05853
Goldfeder v CenPark Realty LLC	Index No. 155687/16 Appeal No. 12128 Case No. 2019-3763	2020 NY Slip Op 05852
Global Liberty Ins. Co. v Laruenceau	Index No. 300062/15 Appeal No. 12111 Case No. 2019-04968	2020 NY Slip Op 05851
Gaylord v Gentile	Index No. 805351/16 Appeal No. 12124 Case No. Case No. 2019-5522	2020 NY Slip Op 05850
Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. v Kirschenbaum	Index No. 850141/14 Appeal No. 12100 Case No. 2020-00944	2020 NY Slip Op 05849
Matter of Dale J.D. v Randi N.H.	Docket No. O-13776/18/18A Appeal No. 12120 Case No. 2020-00003	2020 NY Slip Op 05848
Citimortgage, Inc. v Dalal	Index No. 32339/16E Appeal No. 12102 Case No. 2019-5432	2020 NY Slip Op 05847
6 E. 39th St. Holdings, LLC v Raul Perez LMT LLC	Index No. 654906/16 Appeal No. 12137 Case No. 2019-5609	2020 NY Slip Op 05842
Matter of New York City Asbestos Litig.	Index No. 190016/17 Appeal No. 12125 Case No. 2019-2105, 2018-5160	2020 NY Slip Op 05845
Archer v New York City Tr. Auth.	Index No. 302582/14 Appeal No. 12109 Case No. 2019-03654	2020 NY Slip Op 05844
83 Willow, LLC v Apollo	Index No. 151266/15 Appeal No. 12130 Case No. 2019-4314	2020 NY Slip Op 05843

**Cases Decided October 15, 2020**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
80 Broad Retail Assoc., LLC v BSD 80 Broad LLC	Index No. 159994/19 Appeal No. 12096N Case No. 2020-00844	2020 NY Slip Op 05805
White v MP 40 Realty Mgt. LLC	Index No. 27143/16 Appeal No. 12094 Case No. 2020-01896	2020 NY Slip Op 05838
Uberto, Ltd. v Supcoff	Index No. 655155/16 Appeal No. 12087 Case No. 2019-4851	2020 NY Slip Op 05837
Saeteros v Seven Up Realty, LLC	Index No. 23759/14E Appeal No. 12073 Case No. 2020-00791	2020 NY Slip Op 05836
Ruiz v Selzer	Index No. 24949/14E Appeal No. 12082 Case No. 2019-4708	2020 NY Slip Op 05835
Rosenberg Feldman Smith, LLP v Ninety-Five Madison Co., L.P.	Index No. 653953/18 Appeal No. 12075N Case No. 2019-04423	2020 NY Slip Op 05834
Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. v Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J.	Index No. 157144/19 Appeal No. 12090 Case No. 2020-00669	2020 NY Slip Op 05833
Matter of Dream F. (Phillystina R.)	Docket No. NN-12124-7/18 Appeal No. 12060-12061 Case No. 2019-5906, 2019-5702	2020 NY Slip Op 05832
Powell v City of New York	Index No. 304079/14 Appeal No. 12062 Case No. 2019-5507	2020 NY Slip Op 05831
Petrisko v Animal Med. Ctr.	Index No. 151573/18 Appeal No. 12095 Case No. 2019-5044	2020 NY Slip Op 05830
People v Smith	Ind No. 1566/12 Appeal No. 12065 Case No. 2017-1428	2020 NY Slip Op 05829
People v Flores	Ind No. 5540/07 Appeal No. 12069 Case No. 2019-5040	2020 NY Slip Op 05828
People v Silvestre	Ind No. 2777/10 Appeal No. 12092 Case No. 2016-940	2020 NY Slip Op 05827
People v Garcia	Ind No. 2650/16 Appeal No. 12083 Case No. 2017-01574	2020 NY Slip Op 05826
People v Ramirez	Ind No. 2609/18, 2609/18 Appeal No. 12085-12086 Case No. 2019-3538, 2019-3222	2020 NY Slip Op 05825
People v Ford	Ind No. 1053/10 Appeal No. 12089 Case No. 2018-3365	2020 NY Slip Op 05824
People v Harley	Ind No. 1608/12 Appeal No. 12078 Case No. 2016-1985	2020 NY Slip Op 05823
People v Castillo	Ind No. 4256/15 Appeal No. 12058 Case No. 2018-3523	2020 NY Slip Op 05822
People v Ndiongue	Ind No. 2091/16 Appeal No. 12066 Case No. 2019-4133	2020 NY Slip Op 05821
Paulino v Xing Wu Chen	Index No. 31895/17 Appeal No. 12079 Case No. 2019-4792	2020 NY Slip Op 05820
Moiseenko v AGA Mgt. Corp.	Index No. 653454/15 Appeal No. 12067 Case No. 2019-04291	2020 NY Slip Op 05819
Mikenshina v Tishman Constr. Corp.	Index No. 155373/12 Appeal No. 12064 Case No. 2019-3824	2020 NY Slip Op 05818
Little Rest Twelve, Inc. v Zajic	Index No. 650209/10 Appeal No. 12068 Case No. 2018-20962	2020 NY Slip Op 05817
Lembo v Rosania	Index No. 655076/16 Appeal No. 12084 Case No. 2019-03359	2020 NY Slip Op 05816
Leffler v Kotick	Index No. 155820/18 Appeal No. 12088 Case No. 2020-01773	2020 NY Slip Op 05815
Jenkins v Riverbay Corp.	Index No. 21753/18 Appeal No. 12255N Case No. 2020-02669	2020 NY Slip Op 05814
Hoffman v Babad	Index No. 150176/16 Appeal No. 12072 Case No. 2019-4747	2020 NY Slip Op 05813
Matter of Samiyah H. (Sammie H.)	Docket No. NN17209/19, NN-17210/19 Appeal No. 12080-12081 Case No. 2020-00162, 2020-00093	2020 NY Slip Op 05812
Greene v State of New York	Claim No. 115571 Appeal No. 12097N Case No. 2019-05251	2020 NY Slip Op 05811
Genn v Ratnathicam	Index No. 22006/15E Appeal No. 12076N Case No. 2020-00942	2020 NY Slip Op 05810
Foran v Computershare, Inc.	Index No. 150159/16 Appeal No. 12074 Case No. 2019-3790	2020 NY Slip Op 05809
Commissioners of the State Ins. Fund v Sanitation Salvage Corp.	Index No. 452400/17 Appeal No. 12059-12059A Case No. 2019-05489	2020 NY Slip Op 05808
Brown v New York City Dept. of Transp.	Index No. 24598/13 Appeal No. 12093 Case No. 2019-04234	2020 NY Slip Op 05807
Berkshire Bank v Fawer	Index No. 850250/17 Appeal No. 12070 Case No. 2019-03270	2020 NY Slip Op 05806

**Cases Decided October 13, 2020**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Weisenfeld v Iskander	Index No. 651436/16 Appeal No. 12047 Case No. 2019-4304	2020 NY Slip Op 05710
Vitra, Inc. v Ninety-Five Madison Co., L.P.	Index No. 652342/17 Appeal No. 12037N Case No. 2019-03344	2020 NY Slip Op 05709
Verges v Concourse Residential Hotel, Inc.	Index No. 305974/08 Appeal No. 12053 Case No. 2019-5021	2020 NY Slip Op 05708
Vector Media, LLC v Go New York Tours Inc.	Index No. 653808/2019 Appeal No. 12036N Case No. 2019-05103	2020 NY Slip Op 05707
Streit v Bombart	Index No. 20465/18E Appeal No. 12055 Case No. 2019-5030	2020 NY Slip Op 05706
Rossman v Windermere Owners LLC	Index No. 108350/2011 Appeal No. 12031 Case No. 2019-2688	2020 NY Slip Op 05705
Matter of Radio Drama Network, Inc.	File No. 2010-2056/A Appeal No. 12025 Case No. 2019-03428	2020 NY Slip Op 05704
Matter of Portelos v New York City Dept. of Educ.	Index No. 156610/17 Appeal No. 12022 Case No. 2019-4187	2020 NY Slip Op 05703
People v Sylvester	Ind No. 933N/17 Appeal No. 12038 Case No. 2018-2755	2020 NY Slip Op 05702
People v Herbin	Ind No. 2754/16 Appeal No. 12023 Case No. 2018-2515	2020 NY Slip Op 05701
People v Hall	SCI. No. 3496/16 Appeal No. 12045 Case No. 2019-1591	2020 NY Slip Op 05700
People v Zuniga	Ind No. 1183/17 Appeal No. 12030 Case No. 2019-885	2020 NY Slip Op 05699
People v Perez	Ind No. 2416/16 Appeal No. 12024 Case No. 2017-2143	2020 NY Slip Op 05698
People v Webb	SCI. No. 1955/16, 2316/16 Appeal No. 12033 Case No. 2017-1825	2020 NY Slip Op 05697
People v Smith	Ind No. 2032/13 Appeal No. 12034 Case No. 2019-4488	2020 NY Slip Op 05696
People v Christopher S.	Ind No. 1704/15, 2876/16 Appeal No. 12029 Case No. 2018-3754	2020 NY Slip Op 05695
People v Gamble	Ind No. 2697/14, 1140/14 Appeal No. 12052 Case No. 2018-5327	2020 NY Slip Op 05694
People v Tripathy	Ind No. 2720/16 Appeal No. 12050 Case No. 2018-02997	2020 NY Slip Op 05693
People v Morris	Ind No. 2817/16 Appeal No. 12049 Case No. 2018-2328	2020 NY Slip Op 05692
People v Mirabel	Ind No. 2746/15 Appeal No. 12042 Case No. 2019-3589	2020 NY Slip Op 05691
People v Ellis	Ind No. 3629/16 Appeal No. 12018 Case No. 2018-2601	2020 NY Slip Op 05690
People v Anonymous	Ind No. 3433/14 Appeal No. 12054 Case No. 2017-2259	2020 NY Slip Op 05689
Negron v Marco Realty Assoc., L.P.	Index No. 300919/2016 Appeal No. 12035 Case No. 2020-00030	2020 NY Slip Op 05688
Napoli v Bern	Index No. 161423/15, 161529/18 Appeal No. 12056N-12057N [M-2734 & M-2735] Case No. 2019-1756, 2019-3384	2020 NY Slip Op 05687
Matter of Aniya M. (Onaisa M.)	Docket No. NN-2223-4/17 Appeal No. 12020 Case No. 2019-4436	2020 NY Slip Op 05686
Matter of Angelica M. (Joe M.)	Docket No. NN-24043/2018 Appeal No. 12040 Case No. 2019-04332	2020 NY Slip Op 05685
Lancer & Loader Group, LLC v American Tack & Hardward Co., Inc.	Index No. 651594/2017 Appeal No. 12043-12044 Case No. 2019-3345(2)	2020 NY Slip Op 05684
Matter of Frances M.L. v Luis F.O.C.	Docket No. V-8710/18, V-08715/18, V-09224/18, V-09225/18 Appeal No. 12048 Case No. 2019-004879	2020 NY Slip Op 05683
Kovkov v Law Firm of Dayrel Sewell, PLLC	Index No. 300163/18 Appeal No. 12027 Case No. 2019-2577	2020 NY Slip Op 05682
Kosovsky v Kosovsky	Index No. 154893/2019 Appeal No. 12051 Case No. 2020-01956	2020 NY Slip Op 05681
Kivo v Louis F. Burke, P.C.	Index No. 100135/14 Appeal No. 12039 Case No. 2019-2624	2020 NY Slip Op 05680
KH 48 LLC v Muniak	Index No. 151606/16 Appeal No. 11965 Case No. 2020-00869	2020 NY Slip Op 05679
Jiraud v Barnes & Noble, Inc.	Index No. 161738/2015 Appeal No. 12032 Case No. 2019-5549	2020 NY Slip Op 05678
Matter of Monique J. v Keith S.	Docket No. V2675-17/18D Appeal No. 12028 Case No. 2019-03498	2020 NY Slip Op 05677
Cohn v Nationstar Mtge. LLC	Index No. 160840/17 Appeal No. 12021 Case No. 2020-00722, 2020-00724	2020 NY Slip Op 05676
Barahona v Perez	Index No. 21767/15E Appeal No. 12019 Case No. 2019-5434	2020 NY Slip Op 05675
90th St. Corp. v 203 W. 90th St. Retail, LLC	Index No. 654532/16 Appeal No. 12041 Case No. 2019-04761	2020 NY Slip Op 05674

**Cases Decided October 8, 2020**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Paucay v D.P. Group Gen. Contrs./Devs., Inc.	Index No. 156347/13 Appeal No. 12011 Case No. 2019-4975	2020 NY Slip Op 05611
Vergara v Mission Capital Advisors, LLC	Index No. 656441/19 Appeal No. 12017N Case No. 2020-02083	2020 NY Slip Op 05610
Subway Real Estate Corp. v Saleem	Index No. 652759/17 Appeal No. 11989 Case No. 2019-3724	2020 NY Slip Op 05609
Spielmann v 170 Broadway NYC LP	Index No. 152835/15 Appeal No. 11984 Case No. 2020-00862	2020 NY Slip Op 05608
Matter of Soames v 2LS Consulting Eng'g, D.P.C.	Index No. 154272/17 Appeal No. 12006-12006A-12006B-12006C Case No. 2019-404	2020 NY Slip Op 05607
Matter of Jaylin S. (Jasmine E.T.)	Docket No. NN49512/16 Appeal No. 11960-11960A Case No. 2019-03207	2020 NY Slip Op 05606
Quik Park 808 Garage, LLC v 808 Columbus Commercial Owner LLC	Index No. 159396/19 Appeal No. 12129 Case No. 2019-05451	2020 NY Slip Op 05605
Pieternelle v Smiley & Smiley, LLP	Index No. 160295/15 Appeal No. 11975N Case No. 2019-2398	2020 NY Slip Op 05604
Perez-Vargas v Aarron	Index No. 304887/14 Appeal No. 11994 Case No. 2019-03637	2020 NY Slip Op 05603
People v Watson	Ind No. 1225/16 Appeal No. 12015 Case No. 2018-3075	2020 NY Slip Op 05602
People v Huggins	Ind No. 2883/16 Appeal No. 12013 Case No. 2019-363	2020 NY Slip Op 05601
People v Flanders	Ind No. 2213/16 Appeal No. 11993 Case No. 2018-4000	2020 NY Slip Op 05600
People v Laramore	Ind No. 3196/09 Appeal No. 11978 Case No. 2019-4227	2020 NY Slip Op 05599
People v Sierra	Ind No. 841/17, 1803/17 Appeal No. 11995 Case No. 2018-2684	2020 NY Slip Op 05598
People v Aleman	Ind No. 2331/16 Appeal No. 12007 Case No. 2018-4904	2020 NY Slip Op 05597
People v Hamby	Ind No. 2398/15 Appeal No. 11990 Case No. 2019-5172	2020 NY Slip Op 05596
People v Pagan	Ind No. 2393/13 Appeal No. 11982 Case No. 2014-2713	2020 NY Slip Op 05595
People v Quinones	Ind No. 4796/16 Appeal No. 12002 Case No. 2019-681	2020 NY Slip Op 05594
People v Samuel	Ind No. 2281/16 Appeal No. 11983 Case No. 2018-03337	2020 NY Slip Op 05593
People v Madera	Ind No. 139/18 Appeal No. 12010 Case No. 2019-4046	2020 NY Slip Op 05592
People v Anthony P.	Ind No. 5059/84 Appeal No. 11998 Case No. 2018-03518	2020 NY Slip Op 05591
People v Della-Tacoma	Ind No. 783/17 Appeal No. 11987 Case No. 2019-5275	2020 NY Slip Op 05590
People v Reyes	Ind No. 2177/18 Appeal No. 12003 Case No. 2019-3121	2020 NY Slip Op 05589
Matter of Brandy P. v Pauline W.	Docket No. V-32166-15/18E, V32167-15/18E, V32168-15/18E Appeal No. 11980 Case No. 2019-5193	2020 NY Slip Op 05588
Orea v NH Hotels USA	Index No. 152367/13 Appeal No. 12009 Case No. 2019-4344	2020 NY Slip Op 05587
Matter of Noralez v New York City Dept. of Educ.	Index No. 101062/16 Appeal No. 12004 Case No. 2019-2652	2020 NY Slip Op 05586
Matter of Abeba N. v Joseph N.	Docket No. O-25761/17 Appeal No. 12000 Case No. 2019-5710	2020 NY Slip Op 05585
Monitronics Intl., Inc. v NorthStar Alarm Servs., LLC	Index No. 654792/17 Appeal No. 12016N Case No. 2019-2888N	2020 NY Slip Op 05584
McGookin v Berishai	Index No. 21904/17E, 21737/19E Appeal No. 11996N Case No. 2019-1567N	2020 NY Slip Op 05583
Linn v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.	Index No. 800017/11 Appeal No. 12012 Case No. 2019-2711	2020 NY Slip Op 05582
Matter of Katz v Carranza	Index No. 158539/18 Appeal No. 11999 Case No. 2019-5526	2020 NY Slip Op 05581
Hoppenstein v Shore	File No. 2918/15F Appeal No. 11997N Case No. 2020-00969	2020 NY Slip Op 05580
Matter of New York City Asbestos Litig.	Index No. 190150/18 Appeal No. 11986 Case No. 2019-05469	2020 NY Slip Op 05579
Garza v Nunz Realty, LLC	Index No. 160593/18 Appeal No. 12001 Case No. 2019-04238	2020 NY Slip Op 05578
Matter of Annalisa G. (Tamara A. H.)	Docket No. B-35158-9/18 Appeal No. 12008 Case No. 2019-04309	2020 NY Slip Op 05577
Matter of Derek G. v Alice M.	Docket No. V-24985/16 Appeal No. 11988 Case No. 2019-03263	2020 NY Slip Op 05576
Friedfeld v Citibank, N.A.	Index No. 161344/15 Appeal No. 11992 Case No. 2019-3772	2020 NY Slip Op 05575
Matter of Dmitriyev v City of New York	Index No. 653078/18 Appeal No. 11979 Case No. 2019-2797	2020 NY Slip Op 05574
Citizens Ins. Co. of Am. v American Ins. Co.	Index No. 652925/18 Appeal No. 12005 Case No. 2019-05004	2020 NY Slip Op 05573
Camara v Appiah	Index No. 307247/12 Appeal No. 11991 Case No. 2019-3202	2020 NY Slip Op 05572
Avila v Saint David's Sch.	Index No. 302405/16 Appeal No. 12014 Case No. 2019-05410	2020 NY Slip Op 05571
Matter of A.M.A. (Anggeluz A.)	Docket No. NA-10423-5/17 Appeal No. 11985 Case No. 2019-2611	2020 NY Slip Op 05570

**Cases Decided October 6, 2020**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Ahsanuddin v Carde	Index No. 25100/2016E Appeal No. 11943 Case No. 2019-5439	2020 NY Slip Op 05442
White v City of New York	Index No. 158095/16 Appeal No. 11976-11977N-11977NA Case No. 2020-01489 2020-02158 2020-02159	2020 NY Slip Op 05477
Matter of United Probation Officers Assn. v City of New York	Index No. 158342/2018 Appeal No. 11938 Case No. 2019-2885	2020 NY Slip Op 05476
Thomas v New York City Dept. of Educ.	Index No. 100824/18 Appeal No. 11959 Case No. 2019-04301	2020 NY Slip Op 05475
Matter of Silvers v City of New York	Index No. 652696/15 Appeal No. 11961 Case No. 2019-4346	2020 NY Slip Op 05474
Santini v Gillian Abrams Design LLC	Index No. 154151/2016 Appeal No. 11940-11940A Case No. 2019/4508	2020 NY Slip Op 05473
Richards v Security Resources	Index No. 101659/2018 Appeal No. 11950 Case No. 2019-5457	2020 NY Slip Op 05472
PPR Media LLC v Leo Cable LP	Index No. 651443/18 Appeal No. 11945 Case No. 2019-2783	2020 NY Slip Op 05471
People v Zosya	Ind No. 3621/2016 Appeal No. 11942 Case No. 2018-04330	2020 NY Slip Op 05470
People v Tatis	Ind No. 1233/15 Appeal No. 11972 Case No. 2015/02579	2020 NY Slip Op 05469
People v Moreno	Ind No. 3867/17 Appeal No. 11937 Case No. 2019-5267	2020 NY Slip Op 05468
People v Pugmire	Ind No. 766/17 Appeal No. 11941 Case No. 2019-1832	2020 NY Slip Op 05467
People v Hyde	Ind No. 1863/16 Appeal No. 11958 Case No. 2017-2539	2020 NY Slip Op 05466
People v Rolon	Ind No. 523/18 Appeal No. 11974 Case No. 2019-3949	2020 NY Slip Op 05465
People v Sepulveda	Ind No. 5365/10 Appeal No. 11963 Case No. 2011-02568	2020 NY Slip Op 05464
People v Shulterbrandt	Ind No. 2274/13 1837/14 3294/14 Appeal No. 11955 Case No. 2018-2315	2020 NY Slip Op 05463
People v Castillo	Ind No. 616/14 Appeal No. 11953 Case No. 2015-02143	2020 NY Slip Op 05462
People v Jackson	Ind No. 4477/15 Appeal No. 11949 Case No. 2018-294	2020 NY Slip Op 05461
People v Moore	Ind No. 5365/10 Appeal No. 11962 Case No. 2018-2765	2020 NY Slip Op 05460
People v Andrew A.	Ind No. 2742/07 Appeal No. 11946 Case No. 2019-03584	2020 NY Slip Op 05459
People v Johnson	Ind No. 3595/14 Appeal No. 11967-11967A Case No. 2016-01498	2020 NY Slip Op 05458
Matter of Montgomery Realty NY, LLC v New York City Dept. of Hous. Preserv. & Dev.	Index No. 100139/19 Appeal No. 11970 Case No. 2020-00828	2020 NY Slip Op 05457
McCormick v NYU Langone Med. Ctr.	Index No. 155468/2016 Appeal No. 11971 Case No. 2020-00824	2020 NY Slip Op 05456
Matter of McKayla T.J. (Faith J.J.)	Docket No. B-24974/18 Appeal No. 11939 Case No. 2019-03580	2020 NY Slip Op 05455
Grant v United Odd Fellow	Index No. 26373/18 Appeal No. 11936 Case No. 2019-3679, 2019-03589	2020 NY Slip Op 05454
Gomez v Drew	Index No. 303752/10 Appeal No. 11944 Case No. 2019-334	2020 NY Slip Op 05453
Matter of Anais G. (Lionell M.)	Docket No. NA-34148/1 6 Appeal No. 11968 Case No. 2019-4891	2020 NY Slip Op 05452
Everett v Timmins	Index No. 108027/11 Appeal No. 11966 Case No. 2019-579	2020 NY Slip Op 05451
English v Board of Trustees of the Fashion Inst. of Tech.	Index No. 161860/18 Appeal No. 11956N Case No. 2019-4359	2020 NY Slip Op 05450
Matter of Empire Ctr. for Pub. Policy v New York City Off. of Payroll Admin.	Index No. 157651/18 Appeal No. 11969 Case No. 2019-4766	2020 NY Slip Op 05449
Effiwatt v New York City Dept. of Fin.	Index No. 101833/2017 Appeal No. 11954 Case No. 2019-3067	2020 NY Slip Op 05448
Matter of Kayla C. (Stephanie C.)	Docket No. NA-32217/16-18/16 Appeal No. 11947 Case No. 2019-4095	2020 NY Slip Op 05447
Matter of Benjamin v Department of Hous. Preserv. & Dev. of the City of N.Y.	Index No. 159615/17 Appeal No. 11957N Case No. 2019-4741	2020 NY Slip Op 05446
Avnet, Inc. v Deloitte Consulting LLP	Index No. 653146/19 Appeal No. 11948 Case No. 2019-04851	2020 NY Slip Op 05445
Atkins v Metronome Events, Inc.	Index No. 650203/14 Appeal No. 11973 Case No. 2019-05493	2020 NY Slip Op 05444
Alonso v Reed Elsevier, PLC	Index No. 152383/13 590443/13 590628/13 Appeal No. 11951-11952 Case No. 2019-5632	2020 NY Slip Op 05443
First Equity Realty v Harmony Group, II	Index No. 650273/15 Appeal No. 11964 Case No. 2020-01755	2020 NY Slip Op 05478

**Cases Decided October 1, 2020**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Castro v Yakobashvilli	Index No. 24069/2013 Appeal No. 11931 Case No. 2020-00442	2020 NY Slip Op 05281
Matter of Candice W. v Gary Y.	Index No. V-25094-18 Appeal No. 11907 Case No. 2020-00158	2020 NY Slip Op 05310
Stickney v Akhar	Index No. 158912/2012 Appeal No. 11919 Case No. 2017-1443	2020 NY Slip Op 05309
Shionogi Inc. v Andrx Labs, LLC	Index No. 651663/2019 Appeal No. 11926-11926A Case No. 2019-05533, 2019-05534	2020 NY Slip Op 05308
Schwalbe v Bar-Chama	Index No. 651072/2018 Appeal No. 11901-11901A Case No. 2019-04686, 2019-04687	2020 NY Slip Op 05307
Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J. v White Near Coastal Towing Corp.	Index No. 450945/2018 Appeal No. 11899 Case No. 2019-3794	2020 NY Slip Op 05306
Pizzarotti, LLC v FPG Maiden Lane LLC	Index No. 651697/2019 Appeal No. 11921-11922 Case No. 2019-04691 2019-04692 2019-04693	2020 NY Slip Op 05305
People v Gallardo	Ind No. 532/17 Appeal No. 11903 Case No. 2019-2986	2020 NY Slip Op 05304
People v Garcia	Ind No. 3600/17, 4893/17 Appeal No. 11924 Case No. 2019-4995	2020 NY Slip Op 05303
People v Moss	Ind No. 1231/13 Appeal No. 11916 Case No. 2018-4821	2020 NY Slip Op 05302
People v Arnoat	Ind No. 2751/16 Appeal No. 11933 Case No. 2018-2514	2020 NY Slip Op 05301
People v Narvaez	Ind No. 703/15, 1930/15, 2672/16 Appeal No. 11911 Case No. Case No. 2019-5401	2020 NY Slip Op 05300
People v Irvin	Ind No. 4884/15 Appeal No. 11918 Case No. 2018-2217	2020 NY Slip Op 05299
People v Collier	Ind No. 1738N/17 Appeal No. 11935 Case No. 2018-5286	2020 NY Slip Op 05298
People v Perez	Ind No. 7071/01 Appeal No. 11910 Case No. 2018-03572 2019-4210	2020 NY Slip Op 05297
People v Williams	Ind No. 1744/13 Appeal No. 11927 Case No. 2016-2320	2020 NY Slip Op 05296
People v Vintimilla	Ind No. 1608N/2015 Appeal No. 11902 Case No. Case No. 2018-1673	2020 NY Slip Op 05295
People v Sanchez	Ind No. 1365/15, 5391/15 Appeal No. 11898 Case No. 2018-3977	2020 NY Slip Op 05294
People v Reeves	Ind No. 1052/17 Appeal No. 11912 Case No. 2018-03741	2020 NY Slip Op 05293
People v Chambliss	Ind No. 4410/16 Appeal No. 11932 Case No. 2018-2698	2020 NY Slip Op 05292
People v Basurto	Ind No. 2399/2016 Appeal No. 11906 Case No. 2018-2481	2020 NY Slip Op 05291
Penthouse Global Media, Inc. v The Exec. Club LLC	Index No. 653291/2016 Appeal No. 11905 Case No. 2020-00614	2020 NY Slip Op 05290
NYCTL 1998-2 Trust & Bank of N.Y. v Reverend C.T. Walker Hous. Dev. Fund Corp.	Index No. 153500/2014 Appeal No. 11909-11909A Case No. 2018-5892	2020 NY Slip Op 05289
Minor v East Harlem Tutorial Program, Inc.	Index No. 153262/2017 Appeal No. 11904 Case No. 2020-00457	2020 NY Slip Op 05288
Landron v Wil-Cor Realty Co. Inc.	Index No. 302803/2013 Appeal No. 11908 Case No. 2019-03496	2020 NY Slip Op 05287
Jarmuth v Leonard	Index No. 152535/2018 Appeal No. 11925 Case No. 2019-3774	2020 NY Slip Op 05286
Matter of Fread	File No. 2015-4164 Appeal No. 11934 Case No. 2019-4232	2020 NY Slip Op 05285
Filho v Borges	Index No. 651935/2018 Appeal No. 11915-11915A Case No. 2019-3785	2020 NY Slip Op 05284
Epie v Herakles Farms, LLC	Index No. 159618/2017 Appeal No. 11930 Case No. 2019-274	2020 NY Slip Op 05283
Matter of Drew v O'Neill	Index No. 100870/2018 Appeal No. 11917N-11917NA Case No. 2019-04099, 2019-4626	2020 NY Slip Op 05282
Matter of Issiah C.	Docket No. D-07686/2017 Appeal No. 11900 Case No. 2019-03081	2020 NY Slip Op 05279
Matter of Tylaeya C. v Karl S.	Docket No. V-18987/17 Appeal No. 11920 Case No. 2019-05555	2020 NY Slip Op 05280