skip to main content
Law Reporting
Bureau Thomas J.K. Smith, State Reporter

Appellate Term, First Department Motions

Current Month Archived Cases Decisions

March 2009 Archive

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

Motions Decided March 31, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
115 McLellan Realty, LLC v Araujo, Candy570309/092009 NYSlipOp 67992(U)
Wm. Westminister, LLC v Seley, Eliot/Maxine570308/092009 NYSlipOp 67993(U)
Hodson, Hope Elizabeth v Goldsmith, Jay P., DMD, et al.570097/062009 NYSlipOp 67994(U)
Karp, Marilyn, et al. v Catholic Health System/L.I., et al.570712/082009 NYSlipOp 67995(U)
Ostrowsky, Harold, et al. v Boston Rd. Equip., et al.570650/082009 NYSlipOp 67996(U)
259 W. 12th, LLC v Grossberg, Pearl570300/092009 NYSlipOp 67997(U)
ST Owner LP v Yeremenko, Alexander, et al.570470/082009 NYSlipOp 67998(U)
ST Owner LP v Yeremenko, Alexander, et al.570470/082009 NYSlipOp 67999(U)
People v Saavedra, Carlos570534/082009 NYSlipOp 68000(U)
First Pine View Realty Corp. v Morales, Janet570764/082009 NYSlipOp 68001(U)
Sedhom, Victor B. v Escarous, Janet, et al.570788/082009 NYSlipOp 68002(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging, P.C. (Ricketts) v State Farm Mut.570160/092009 NYSlipOp 68003(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging, P.C. (Gallagher) v State Farm Mut.570167/092009 NYSlipOp 68004(U)
People v Abejide, Bola570222/092009 NYSlipOp 68005(U)
People v Abejide, Bola570223/092009 NYSlipOp 68006(U)
Extell 607 W. 137th St., LLC v Geana, Alex570254/092009 NYSlipOp 68007(U)
Bigman, Shula v Sirota, David King, M.D.570262/092009 NYSlipOp 68008(U)
Broadway Portfolio I Owner LLC v Bello, Maria, et al.570293/092009 NYSlipOp 68009(U)
Motions Decided March 30, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
Tyroler, Sean v Bowman, Vincent570905/072009 NYSlipOp 67890(U)
106 Pinehurst Ave v Mohr, Laura I.570294/092009 NYSlipOp 67891(U)
400 W. 59th ST Partners v Edwards, Carole570789/082009 NYSlipOp 67892(U)
Beechwood Sedgwick LLC v Garland, Wanda570268/092009 NYSlipOp 67893(U)
Southbridge Towers v Pion, Jodi570757/082009 NYSlipOp 67894(U)
Park S. Towers v Cangro, Jennifer570663/082009 NYSlipOp 67895(U)
LA Prop. v Lee, Seunghee570229/092009 NYSlipOp 67896(U)
65 Morningside Ave HDFC v Bickley, Claude570301/092009 NYSlipOp 67897(U)
Roxborough Apts. v Kalish, Shira570667/082009 NYSlipOp 67898(U)
Harlem Canaan House v Thomas, Shantii570126/082009 NYSlipOp 67899(U)
Baxter St. Props. v Lee, Kimmy570297/092009 NYSlipOp 67900(U)
Holdridge/BK St. Inc v Lamson, R & Zeik, Edward570368/072009 NYSlipOp 67901(U)
Harlem Canaan House v Thomas, Shanti570126/082009 NYSlipOp 67902(U)
Motions Decided March 24, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
Costabile, Joseph A. v Damon G. Douglas Co., et al.570804/072009 NYSlipOp 67359(U)
People v Cvetkovski, Goce570357/082009 NYSlipOp 67360(U)
People v Mack, Laron570520/082009 NYSlipOp 67361(U)
Soloano, Mario v Perseus Mgt. LLC, et al.570286/092009 NYSlipOp 67362(U)
People v Khusial, Mahendra570139/092009 NYSlipOp 67363(U)
People v Martin, Samaire570138/092009 NYSlipOp 67364(U)
People v Cabrera, Angel570137/092009 NYSlipOp 67365(U)
People v Cruz, Jose A.570136/092009 NYSlipOp 67366(U)
People v Ware, Marc570135/092009 NYSlipOp 67367(U)
People v Richards, Tiffany570134/092009 NYSlipOp 67368(U)
People v Hargrow, Paul570139/092009 NYSlipOp 67369(U)
322 W. 57th Owner, LLC v Penhurst Prods.570020/072009 NYSlipOp 67370(U)
322 W. 57th Owner, LLC v Penhurst Prods.570020/072009 NYSlipOp 67371(U)
Banco Popular N. Am. v Lieberman, Aharon, et al.570218/072009 NYSlipOp 67372(U)
Louie, Ngar Kuen v Berdar Equities Co., et al.570411/072009 NYSlipOp 67373(U)
Costabile, Joseph A. v Damon G. Douglas Co., et al.570804/072009 NYSlipOp 67374(U)
Merditaj, Marija v Keoseian, Richard570826/072009 NYSlipOp 67375(U)
Isdahl, Finn G., et al. v Pogliani, Walter, et al.570860/072009 NYSlipOp 67376(U)
Calderon, Maria v Olonoff, Asen, et al.570520/082009 NYSlipOp 67377(U)
Motions Decided March 23, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
5-7 E. 17th LLC v Schwam, Frederick L., et al.570790/082009 NYSlipOp 67164(U)
People v Brown, Harold570244/092009 NYSlipOp 67165(U)
People v Hill, Jerome570245/092009 NYSlipOp 67166(U)
Dunkin 36 II LLC v Martinez, Mercedes570267/092009 NYSlipOp 67167(U)
People v Ramirez, Jesus570170/092009 NYSlipOp 67168(U)
People v Du, Zhao Xiong570169/092009 NYSlipOp 67169(U)
People v Burton, Christopher570168/092009 NYSlipOp 67170(U)
People v Cornelius, Abdul570141/092009 NYSlipOp 67171(U)
People v Harris, David570287/092009 NYSlipOp 67172(U)
People v Diaz, Pablo570288/092009 NYSlipOp 67173(U)
People v Giannicos, Vincent570283/092009 NYSlipOp 67174(U)
People v Brown, Donovan570284/092009 NYSlipOp 67175(U)
People v Negron, Alfredo570285/092009 NYSlipOp 67176(U)
People v Bradley, Wilson570140/092009 NYSlipOp 67177(U)
Rostant, Caroline v 790 RSD Acquisition LLC570288/072009 NYSlipOp 67178(U)
Southbridge Towers, Inc. v To, Jarmena570401/072009 NYSlipOp 67179(U)
422 E. 14th St. Assoc. LLC v Vlahos, Tasha M.570827/072009 NYSlipOp 67180(U)
People v Bell, Brian570314/082009 NYSlipOp 67181(U)
Strobel, Kalman v Rubin, Edward570022/092009 NYSlipOp 67182(U)
MH Residential I, LLC v Cohen, James570187/092009 NYSlipOp 67183(U)
Sherbansky, Rudi Oded v New Hampshire Ins. Co.570777/072009 NYSlipOp 67184(U)
Motions Decided March 19, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
721-735 Walton/Gerard LLC v Grant, Nathan570291/092009 NYSlipOp 66898(U)
Nguyen, Dolores v Brown-Daniels, Tisha570290/092009 NYSlipOp 66899(U)
People v Levons, Barnady570224/092009 NYSlipOp 66900(U)
1251 Ams. Assoc. II, L.P. v Rock 49th Rest. Corp., et al.570878/072009 NYSlipOp 66901(U)
85 Fourth Partners LP v Herbert, Barbara, et al.570080/082009 NYSlipOp 66902(U)
Turi, Marion L. v Kwan, Edmund570774/082009 NYSlipOp 66903(U)
People v Marchand, Inga570130/092009 NYSlipOp 66904(U)
People v Gjonbalaj, Nerim570129/092009 NYSlipOp 66905(U)
People v Timothus, Dallas570126/092009 NYSlipOp 66906(U)
People v Mayes, Tyrin570125/092009 NYSlipOp 66907(U)
People v Chew, Sean570124/092009 NYSlipOp 66908(U)
People v Price, William570123/092009 NYSlipOp 66909(U)
People v Gill, Arshad Igbal570122/092009 NYSlipOp 66910(U)
People v Benjamin, Susan570196/092009 NYSlipOp 66911(U)
People v Beattie, Melissa570195/092009 NYSlipOp 66912(U)
People v Ackerman, Patricia570194/092009 NYSlipOp 66913(U)
People v Sheehan, Cindy570193/092009 NYSlipOp 66914(U)
People v Massei, Louis570192/092009 NYSlipOp 66915(U)
People v Martinez, Wilbe570173/092009 NYSlipOp 66916(U)
People v Byrant, William570172/092009 NYSlipOp 66917(U)
People v Smith, James570171/092009 NYSlipOp 66918(U)
Motions Decided March 18, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
Melton, Myung-Ja v Kelman, Susan570236/092009 NYSlipOp 66874(U)
Abusbeth, Khalil v AKK, Inc., et al.570256/092009 NYSlipOp 66875(U)
1710 Popham LLC v Mejia, Angines Jimenez570272/092009 NYSlipOp 66876(U)
521 Assoc., Inc. v Whitaker, Barbara570273/092009 NYSlipOp 66877(U)
Estrada, Maribel, et al. v Fernandez, Bernardo, et al.570281/092009 NYSlipOp 66878(U)
People v Diaz, Hector570008/092009 NYSlipOp 66879(U)
People v Chun, Kyung570007/092009 NYSlipOp 66880(U)
People v Noel, Orson570006/092009 NYSlipOp 66881(U)
People v Casado, Desean570005/092009 NYSlipOp 66882(U)
People v Spencer, Robert570004/092009 NYSlipOp 66883(U)
People v Keefer, Jarel570003/092009 NYSlipOp 66884(U)
People v Bush, Nyla570121/092009 NYSlipOp 66885(U)
People v Reyes, Kelvin570120/092009 NYSlipOp 66886(U)
People v Lopez, Mariah (2)570119/092009 NYSlipOp 66887(U)
People v Cook, Julius570107/092009 NYSlipOp 66888(U)
People v Taveras, Juan570106/092009 NYSlipOp 66889(U)
People v Otray, Idris570105/092009 NYSlipOp 66890(U)
People v Brandley, Christopher570104/092009 NYSlipOp 66891(U)
People v Clinton, Jeffrey570103/092009 NYSlipOp 66892(U)
People v Law, Jane570102/092009 NYSlipOp 66893(U)
People v Vergara, Patrick570101/092009 NYSlipOp 66894(U)
People v Brunson, Robert570100/092009 NYSlipOp 66895(U)
People v Esquvel, Jose570132/092009 NYSlipOp 66896(U)
People v Vierra, Victor570131/092009 NYSlipOp 66897(U)
Motions Decided March 17, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
Metropolitan Radiological aao Fitzgerald, O. v State Farm Ins570161/092009 NYSlipOp 66670(U)
Metropolitan Radiological aao Shah, S. v State Farm Ins570166/092009 NYSlipOp 66671(U)
Metropolitan Radiological aao Azor, M v State Farm Ins570156/092009 NYSlipOp 66672(U)
MH Residential 1 LLC v Dreste, Patricia570011/092009 NYSlipOp 66673(U)
Motions Decided March 16, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
Tranel, Inc. v Fashion Insitute/Technology570178/092009 NYSlipOp 66616(U)
LGS Realty Partners LLC v Kyle, William, et al.570775/082009 NYSlipOp 66617(U)
Jarvis, Leoney v Hemmings, Francis570128/092009 NYSlipOp 66618(U)
216 E. 10th St. Corp. v Sypher, Don, et al.570237/092009 NYSlipOp 66619(U)
Beaux Arts II, LLC v Arrey, Clifford A.570242/092009 NYSlipOp 66620(U)
Fisk Bldg. Assoc. LLC -V- Kaplan, Leopold, et al.570243/092009 NYSlipOp 66621(U)
Extell 609 W. 137th St., LLC -V- Santana, Altagracia, et al.570277/092009 NYSlipOp 66622(U)
Motions Decided March 12, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
People v Harrison, Darren570348/082009 NYSlipOp 66262(U)
Anderson, Nyree v Solomon Page Group LLC570653/082009 NYSlipOp 66263(U)
Town House Mgt., A Partnership v Belinsky, Joseph, et al.570109/092009 NYSlipOp 66264(U)
People v Jiminez, Carlos570080/092009 NYSlipOp 66265(U)
People v Martinez, Max570079/092009 NYSlipOp 66266(U)
People v McDougall, Robert570078/092009 NYSlipOp 66267(U)
People v Mendez, Enrique570077/092009 NYSlipOp 66268(U)
People v Pier 63 Mar. Inc.570076/092009 NYSlipOp 66269(U)
People v Kuznetsova, Natalya570075/092009 NYSlipOp 66270(U)
People v Lamar, Eddie570074/092009 NYSlipOp 66271(U)
People v Haimovitch, Amin570046/092009 NYSlipOp 66272(U)
People v Shemesh, Menashe570045/092009 NYSlipOp 66273(U)
People v Sheiman, Dimitry570044/092009 NYSlipOp 66274(U)
People v Chan, Hok T.570043/092009 NYSlipOp 66275(U)
People v Caitlin, Rasheed570042/092009 NYSlipOp 66276(U)
People v Campblin, Craig570041/092009 NYSlipOp 66277(U)
People v Mejia, Luis570040/092009 NYSlipOp 66278(U)
People v Holloway, Danny a/k/a Miller, Danny570032/092009 NYSlipOp 66279(U)
People v Holloway, Danny a/k/a Miller, Danny570031/092009 NYSlipOp 66280(U)
People v Holloway, Danny a/k/a Miller, Danny570030/092009 NYSlipOp 66281(U)
People v Holloway, Danny a/k/a Miller, Danny570029/092009 NYSlipOp 66282(U)
People v Brand, Miguel570028/092009 NYSlipOp 66283(U)
People v Valera, Jose570027/092009 NYSlipOp 66284(U)
Motions Decided March 11, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
New York City Mgt., LLC v Santos, Edita O., et al.570676/062009 NYSlipOp 66118(U)
200 W. 112th Street-HDFC v Freeman, Natalie570266/092009 NYSlipOp 66119(U)
Stratford Five Realty LLC v McGeachy, Tomasina570265/092009 NYSlipOp 66120(U)
Strobel, Kalman v Rubin, Edward570022/092009 NYSlipOp 66121(U)
St. Louis W., Inc. v Pickard, Todd S., et al.570179/092009 NYSlipOp 66122(U)
3720 Homes Inc. v Hyman, Murray, et al.570188/092009 NYSlipOp 66123(U)
Alvarez-Haddad, Jessica v Thompson, Mark R., et al.570231/092009 NYSlipOp 66124(U)
MH Residential I, LLC, et al. v Cohen, James H.570234/092009 NYSlipOp 66125(U)
Riley, Jan Hudgins v Ansis, Karen570248/092009 NYSlipOp 66126(U)
Tillamock, N.V. v Nakanishi, Chizuko570249/092009 NYSlipOp 66127(U)
Motions Decided March 10, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
People v Melendez, Jesus570092/092009 NYSlipOp 65959(U)
People v Shaffer, Mark570091/092009 NYSlipOp 65960(U)
People v Matamores, Carlos570090/092009 NYSlipOp 65961(U)
People v Cox, Keith570089/092009 NYSlipOp 65962(U)
People v Cox, Keith570088/092009 NYSlipOp 65963(U)
People v Kroon, Robert570087/092009 NYSlipOp 65964(U)
People v Doughty, Edward570086/092009 NYSlipOp 65965(U)
People v Torres, Dennis570083/092009 NYSlipOp 65966(U)
People v Castro, Gabriella570082/092009 NYSlipOp 65967(U)
People v Fields, Tavi570081/092009 NYSlipOp 65968(U)
230 E. 14th St. LLC v Klufas, Victoria, et al.570402/062009 NYSlipOp 65969(U)
315 E. 72nd St. Owners, Inc. v Siegel, Mark Allen, et al.570461/062009 NYSlipOp 65970(U)
319 W. 48th St. Realty Corp. v Almeida, Sandra, et al.570329/072009 NYSlipOp 65971(U)
Halle, Harold, et al. v Abduljaami, Saboor H.570442/072009 NYSlipOp 65972(U)
Saul, Joseph E., et al. v Yaffa, Robert, et al.570654/082009 NYSlipOp 65973(U)
MacArthur Props., LLC v 305 E. 72nd Rest. LLC570048/092009 NYSlipOp 65974(U)
140 E. 46th St., LLC v Lavorgna, Jill570112/092009 NYSlipOp 65975(U)
Wellington Fee LLC v Cotter, Bruce, et al.570218/092009 NYSlipOp 65976(U)
450 7th Ave. Assocs., LLC v Global Economic Transaction, Inc., et al.570220/092009 NYSlipOp 65977(U)
People v Abejide, Bola570222/092009 NYSlipOp 65978(U)
People v Abejide, Bola570223/092009 NYSlipOp 65979(U)
562 Assoc., L.P. v Unique People Servs., Inc.570230/092009 NYSlipOp 65980(U)
900 8th Ave. Condo. v Hallet, Darrell M., et al.570232/092009 NYSlipOp 65981(U)
79 Co., LLC v Heng Shing Rest. Inc.570235/092009 NYSlipOp 65982(U)
Motions Decided March 6, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
New Amsterdam Assoc. v Taylor, Patricia2009 NYSlipOp 65824(U)
Lupo, Elaine v Cass, Alan, et al.570225/072009 NYSlipOp 65825(U)
Spira, Robert v Carnival Corp.570184/092009 NYSlipOp 65826(U)
Spira, Shirley v Carnival Corp.570183/092009 NYSlipOp 65827(U)
Otufale, Adegboyega, et al. v Whetstone, Francisca, et al.570456/082009 NYSlipOp 65828(U)
Villareal, Jean-Claude v Pristine Pictures, Inc.570665/082009 NYSlipOp 65829(U)
Wilton Estates, Inc. v Quinn, Marianne570761/082009 NYSlipOp 65830(U)
New Amsterdam Assoc. v Arias, Dominga, et al.570202/092009 NYSlipOp 65831(U)
People v Herrara, Jonathan570203/092009 NYSlipOp 65832(U)
Gheith, Sawsan v Williams, Kayon570221/092009 NYSlipOp 65833(U)
People v Howard, Nathaniel570226/092009 NYSlipOp 65834(U)
Carmine Ltd. v Zimic, Edward570228/092009 NYSlipOp 65835(U)
ADC/Ennis Francis HDFC v Woodburn, Eileen570233/092009 NYSlipOp 65836(U)
Motions Decided March 5, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
219 Grand Prop. LLC v Yue Fung USA Enters., Inc., et al.570252/092009 NYSlipOp 65316(U)
Kempf, Jessica v Lodato, Anthony570251/092009 NYSlipOp 65317(U)
Gouverneur Gardens Hous. Corp. v Lee, Albert Brown, et al.570182/092009 NYSlipOp 65318(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Song) v State Farm Insur. Co.570155/092009 NYSlipOp 65319(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Azor) v State Farm Insur. Co.570156/092009 NYSlipOp 65320(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Berry) v State Farm Insur. Co.570157/092009 NYSlipOp 65321(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Bruno) v State Farm Insur. Co.570158/092009 NYSlipOp 65322(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Orona) v State Farm Insur. Co.570159/092009 NYSlipOp 65323(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Ricketts) v State Farm Insur. Co.570160/092009 NYSlipOp 65324(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Fitzgerald) v State Farm Insur. Co.570161/092009 NYSlipOp 65325(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Berenguer) v State Farm Insur. Co.570162/092009 NYSlipOp 65326(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Ospina) v State Farm Insur. Co.570163/092009 NYSlipOp 65327(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Tavarez) v State Farm Insur. Co.570164/092009 NYSlipOp 65328(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Spezzano) v State Farm Insur. Co.570165/092009 NYSlipOp 65329(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Shah) v State Farm Insur. Co.570166/092009 NYSlipOp 65330(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Gallagher) v State Farm Insur. Co.570167/092009 NYSlipOp 65331(U)
Metropolitan Radiological Imaging (Choe) v State Farm Insur. Co.570250/092009 NYSlipOp 65332(U)
5th & 106th St. Assoc. v Manning, Steve570247/092009 NYSlipOp 65333(U)
Motions Decided March 4, 2009
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
NYCHA-Bronx Riv. Houses v Shekmem El Bey, Yashua570240/092009 NYSlipOp 65261(U)
Zevrone Realty Corp. v Cole, Mohamed570239/092009 NYSlipOp 65262(U)
NYCHA-Wise Towers v Burgan, Bernard570238/092009 NYSlipOp 65263(U)
Ardolic, Naslije, et al. v New Water St. Corp., et al.570050/092009 NYSlipOp 65264(U)
People v Yu, Quiong570291/052009 NYSlipOp 65265(U)
240 W. 37 LLC v Europa Moda, Inc., et al.570464/082009 NYSlipOp 65266(U)
East Hattan Realty Corp. v Antonio, Elma, et al.570772/082009 NYSlipOp 65267(U)
Quisqueya Hous. Co., LLP v De La Cruz, Teofila570019/092009 NYSlipOp 65268(U)
Capital One Bank v Thompson, William P.570219/092009 NYSlipOp 65269(U)
Shneyer, Paul, et al. v Ramirez, Ana570227/092009 NYSlipOp 65270(U)
Annibale, Charles v Dex Car Corp., et al.570229/092009 NYSlipOp 65271(U)

Links to or from other sites do not signify endorsement or relationship with them.