Appellate Division, Fourth Department Motions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Motions Decided March 30, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V DERRICK WALTON	KA 11-00252	2012 NY Slip Op 69360(U)
THE PEOPLE V LUMARIO L. STRICKLAND	KA 10-00704	2012 NY Slip Op 69359(U)
THE PEOPLE EX REL., RICHARD MILLS V JOHN LEMPKE, SUPERINTENDENT OF FIVE POINTS CORRECTIONAL FACILITY; ERIC	KAH 11-01845	2012 NY Slip Op 69358(U)
THE PEOPLE V VICTOR GARCIA	KA 10-01288	2012 NY Slip Op 69357(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHIAL E. FOSTER	KA 10-02447	2012 NY Slip Op 69356(U)
THE PEOPLE V EDDIE D. ENNIS	KA 10-01378	2012 NY Slip Op 69355(U)
THE PEOPLE V DONIQUE BOYD	KA 10-01078	2012 NY Slip Op 69354(U)

**Motions Decided March 29, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V AARON STEVENSON	KA 12-00470 AND KA 12-00471	2012 NY Slip Op 69353(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHRISTOPHER STENSON Indictment No: 778/97	KA 99-05549	2012 NY Slip Op 69352(U)
THE PEOPLE V BRANCHAUNN L. RANGE	KA 12-00444	2012 NY Slip Op 69351(U)
THE PEOPLE V RICHARD F. MILLS Indictment No: 4639	KA 12-00445	2012 NY Slip Op 69350(U)
THE PEOPLE EX REL., LAWRENCE MCCREA V DALE ARTUS, ACTING SUPERINTENDENT, GOWANDA CORRECTIONAL FACILITY	KAH 11-02318	2012 NY Slip Op 69349(U)
MATTER OF PAULA L. MASON V AARON G. MASON	CAF 11-02089	2012 NY Slip Op 69348(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOSEPH JACKSON	KA 11-02386	2012 NY Slip Op 69347(U)
THE PEOPLE V DASHAWN DAVIS	KA 10-01825	2012 NY Slip Op 69346(U)
THE PEOPLE V FRANK CONNOR	KA 12-00479	2012 NY Slip Op 69345(U)
MATER OF JACOB BORGENICHT V SARAH BAKER	CAF 12-00355	2012 NY Slip Op 69344(U)
MATTER OF AUSTIN M. AND ANNA M.	CAF 12-00352	2012 NY Slip Op 69343(U)

**Motions Decided March 28, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V ROBERT MOTHERSELL	KA 12-00461	2012 NY Slip Op 69342(U)

**Motions Decided March 27, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V ADRIAN RILEY	KA 11-00482	2012 NY Slip Op 69341(U)

**Motions Decided March 29, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
GWENDOLYN HOOVER, M.D. AND EDDIE HOOVER, M.D. V JUREK & BROWN PROPERTIES, INC., HENRY JUREK AND JUREK CUSTOM BUILDERS	CA 12-00506	2012 NY Slip Op 68709(U)

**Motions Decided March 28, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V ISIAH WILLIAMS, JR.	KA 09-01187	2012 NY Slip Op 68708(U)
THE PEOPLE V PARIS SMITH	KA 10-01774 AND KA 11-02148	2012 NY Slip Op 68707(U)
ROUTE 104 & ROUTE 21 DEVELOPMENT, INC. V CHEVRON USA, INC. , AND WILLIAM J. ALLEN, JR. ROUTE 104 & ROUTE 21	CA 11-02424	2012 NY Slip Op 68706(U)
THE PEOPLE V ROBERT MOTHERSELL	KA 12-00461	2012 NY Slip Op 68705(U)
THE PEOPLE V NATHANIEL MOSS	KA 09-02285	2012 NY Slip Op 68704(U)
DEBRA J. MILLER, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF EDWARD M. MILLER, DECEASED V SAVARINO CONSTRUCTION	CA 12-00504	2012 NY Slip Op 68703(U)
MATTER OF MALIK S.	CAF 11-01663	2012 NY Slip Op 68702(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHAMALL KNIGHT	KA 08-02646	2012 NY Slip Op 68701(U)
PEOPLE V CLEMON JONES, ALSO KNOWN AS CLEMENT/CLEMONT JONES	KA 07-01929	2012 NY Slip Op 68700(U)
THE PEOPLE V CLEMON JONES, ALSO KNOWN AS CLEMENT/CLEMONT JONES	KA 08-02408	2012 NY Slip Op 68699(U)
MATTER OF THE ADOPTION OF JORDAN	CAF 11-01696	2012 NY Slip Op 68698(U)
MARK HESS AND GAIL HESS, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS PARENTS AND NATURAL GUARDIAN OF MARILYN HESS V GARY NELSON AND LYNN NELSON	CA 12-00513	2012 NY Slip Op 68697(U)
THE PEOPLE V ADAM J. HAMILTON	KA 10-01370	2012 NY Slip Op 68696(U)
THE PEOPLE V NICHOLAS J. FORNEY	KA 12-00190	2012 NY Slip Op 68695(U)
THE PEOPLE V VICTOR A. DEPONCEAU	KA 08-00634	2012 NY Slip Op 68694(U)
THE PEOPLE V BURNIE DANIELS	KA 09-02133	2012 NY Slip Op 68693(U)
MATTER OF DAHMANI M.	CAF 11-02140	2012 NY Slip Op 68692(U)
THE PEOPLE V HARRELL BONNER, ALSO KNOWN AS HARRELL WALLER THE PEOPLE V HARRELL BONNER, ALSO KNOWN AS DAMIEN PROPHET	KA 08-00631	2012 NY Slip Op 68691(U)

**Motions Decided March 27, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V CYRIL WINEBRENNER Indictment No: 393/03	KA 05-00172	2012 NY Slip Op 68690(U)
MATTER OF ERICA WILLIAMS V SHAWN EPPS MATTER OF ERICA WILLIAMS V SHAWN EPPS	CAF 11-02333	2012 NY Slip Op 68689(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHESTER W. WARREN	KA 12-00345	2012 NY Slip Op 68688(U)
STATE FARM FIRE & CASUALTY COMPANY V MATTHEW RICCI, RAYMOND PINK AND MICHELLE PINK	CA 12-00184	2012 NY Slip Op 68687(U)
THE PEOPLE V JASON SLISHEVSKY	KA 10-01850	2012 NY Slip Op 68686(U)
THE PEOPLE V ISAIAH MCCOY	KA 10-00800	2012 NY Slip Op 68685(U)
MARIA L. JAOUDE V MATTHEW E. HANNAH, L.P. PARNASSOS, AND RITA J. BIONDO	CA 11-02557	2012 NY Slip Op 68684(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICKEY A. JACOBS, ALSO KNOWN AS MICKEY JACOBS	KA 12-00412	2012 NY Slip Op 68683(U)
THE PEOPLE V PHILLIP HOLLOWAY	KA 10-01638	2012 NY Slip Op 68682(U)
THE PEOPLE V PAUL HENDERSON SCI No: 34398	KA 11-00796	2012 NY Slip Op 68681(U)
THE PEOPLE V JAMIE C. HARRISON	KA 10-01503	2012 NY Slip Op 68680(U)
THE PEOPLE V JEFFREY D. FINEOUT	KA 11-00493	2012 NY Slip Op 68679(U)
THE PEOPLE EX REL., TARHENE FINCH V DAWSON BROWN, SUPERINTENDENT OF GROVELAND CORRECTIONAL FACILITY, et at.	KAH 11-00862	2012 NY Slip Op 68678(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHERRI ERRINGTON Indictment No: 6189	KA 11-01128	2012 NY Slip Op 68677(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL CALDWELL	KA 10-02198	2012 NY Slip Op 68676(U)
THE PEOPLE V JESSIE J. BARNES	KA 09-02123	2012 NY Slip Op 68675(U)
THE PEOPLE V JESSIE J. BARNES	KA 09-02123	2012 NY Slip Op 68674(U)
THE PEOPLE V RICHARD E. AIKEY, JR.	KA 09-00903	2012 NY Slip Op 68673(U)
THE PEOPLE EX REL., THOMAS AIKENS V DAWSON BROWN, SUPERINTENDENT, GROVELAND CORRECTIONAL FACILITY	KAH 11-00998	2012 NY Slip Op 68672(U)

**Motions Decided March 26, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
MATTER OF MARIA M. VENUS V RYAN BRENNAN	CAF 11-01878	2012 NY Slip Op 68671(U)
MATTER OF YASIN TISDALE V JUDY ANDERSON MATTER OF JUDY ANDERSON V YASIN TISDALE	CAF 11-00654	2012 NY Slip Op 68670(U)
MATTER OF CHESTER J. THOMAS, SR. V GABRIELLE C. SMITH	CAF 12-00498	2012 NY Slip Op 68669(U)
MATTER OF PATRICIA PETRIE V DONALD PETRIE, JR.	CAF 11-01925	2012 NY Slip Op 68668(U)
MATTER OF NOAH V.P.	CAF 11-00442	2012 NY Slip Op 68667(U)
MATTER OF AMBER MURPHY V BRIAN WELLS	CAF 11-01212	2012 NY Slip Op 68666(U)
MATTER OF MALINDA A. PRINZING V PAUL G. GUCK, AND DORIS M. GUCK	CAF 11-01903	2012 NY Slip Op 68665(U)
MATTER OF DAWN FREY V WARREN MIMS	CAF 11-01519	2012 NY Slip Op 68664(U)
MATTER OF DAWN FREY V WARREN MIMS	CAF 11-01519	2012 NY Slip Op 68663(U)
JANERIO ALDRIDGE, M.D., HASHMAT ASHRAF, M.B.B.S., F.R.C.S., LUJEAN JENNINGS, PH.D., M.D., AND BUFFALO THORACIC SURGICAL	CA 12-00521	2012 NY Slip Op 68662(U)
MATTER OF ALEXIA L.	CAF 11-01028	2012 NY Slip Op 68661(U)

**Motions Decided March 23, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL W. LANHAM, ALSO KNOWN AS MICHAEL LANHAM, ALSO KNOWN AS MICHAEL L. LANHAM	KA 12-00404	2012 NY Slip Op 68660(U)

**Motions Decided March 16, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V BILLY G. WILLIAMS	538-09	2012 NY Slip Op 68659(U)
THE PEOPLE V JACK VAN DE VIVER	1007-08	2012 NY Slip Op 68658(U)
THE PEOPLE V NORMAN C. SONBERG	395-09	2012 NY Slip Op 68657(U)
KAREN L. SALVATO V LARRY P. SALVATO	CA 11-01069	2012 NY Slip Op 68656(U)
THE PEOPLE V JACOB ROUSE	758-10	2012 NY Slip Op 68655(U)
ROBERT PETHICK V ELIZABETH PETHICK, NOW KNOWN AS ELIZABETH CACCAMISE	CA 11-00838	2012 NY Slip Op 68654(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF CITY OF ROCHESTER FOR AN "INSPECTION WARRANT" TO INSPECT 187 CLIFTON STREET, CITY	NOS. CA 11-00181 AND CA 11-00363	2012 NY Slip Op 68653(U)
THE PEOPLE V TERRIS HANKS	994-11	2012 NY Slip Op 68652(U)
THE PEOPLE V DOLPH A. GRAYSON Indictment No: 2008-DC0085	KA 10-00191	2012 NY Slip Op 68651(U)
THE PEOPLE V DOLPH A. GRAYSON Indictment No: 2007-DC0424	KA 10-00190	2012 NY Slip Op 68650(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DOUGLAS J. GIAMBRONE AND MARCON ERECTORS, INC. V ALEXANDER B. GRANNIS, COMMISSIONER, NEW YORK STATE	TP 11-00377	2012 NY Slip Op 68649(U)
JOSEPH F. GAGNON, JR. AND SHARON GAGNON V ST. JOSEPH'S HOSPITAL, THROUGH ITS OFFICERS, AGENTS AND/OR EMPLOYEES, RICHARD	CA 11-00343	2012 NY Slip Op 68648(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANTONIO CLARK	1422-11	2012 NY Slip Op 68647(U)
THE PEOPLE V REGGIE CLARK	KA 09-01172	2012 NY Slip Op 68646(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF CITY OF ROCHESTER FOR AN "INSPECTION WARRANT" TO INSPECT 449 CEDARWOOD TERRACE	CA 11-00089	2012 NY Slip Op 68645(U)
THE PEOPLE V STEPHEN C. BADMAN	KA 11-01288 AND KA 11-01290	2012 NY Slip Op 68644(U)
PHILIP ARNO AND MARY ARNO V MARIA CIMATO AND CARMELO CIMATO	CA 11-00676	2012 NY Slip Op 68643(U)
A.J. BAYNES FREIGHT CONTRACTORS, LTD., AJAC TRUCKING, LLC, AND LENNON WILLIAMS V NORMAN L. POLANSKI, JR., AS MAYOR OF	CA 11-01428	2012 NY Slip Op 68642(U)

**Motions Decided March 22, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V TIMOTHY D. TOOLEY, ALSO KNOWN AS TIMOTHY DANIEL TOOLEY Indictment No: 5361	KA 12-00464	2012 NY Slip Op 68115(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOHN P. SMITH	KA 12-00450	2012 NY Slip Op 68114(U)
ALESSANDRO SACCHETTI V MICHAEL GIORDANO, DPM	CA 11-02555	2012 NY Slip Op 68113(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ONTARIO SQUARE REALTY CORP. V ASSESSOR OF THE TOWN OF FARMINGTON, DONNA LAPLANT	CA 12-00514	2012 NY Slip Op 68112(U)
JOHN O'DONNELL V ROBERT FERGUSON, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS CHIEF OF POLICE OF TOWN OF EVANS, ROBERT R. CATALINO, II	CA 12-00466	2012 NY Slip Op 68111(U)
JOSEPH MILES V GREAT LAKES CHEESE OF NEW YORK, INC. AND MURNANE BUILDING CONTRACTORS, INC.	CA 12-00460	2012 NY Slip Op 68110(U)
JESSE LUCAS, JR. V DR. ALAN WEINER, D.D.S.	CA 11-02061	2012 NY Slip Op 68109(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL A. KOEHLER, ALSO KNOWN AS MICHAEL KOEHLER	KA 12-00441	2012 NY Slip Op 68108(U)
THE PEOPLE V STANLEY L. HOWARD	KA 11-01824	2012 NY Slip Op 68107(U)
IN THE MATTER OF HOPEWELL VOLUNTEER FIRE DEPARTMENT AND CHRISANNTHA CONSTRUCTION CORP. V COLLEEN C. GARDNER, IN HER	CA 12-00478	2012 NY Slip Op 68106(U)
JAN M. HAYES V TEXAS ROADHOUSE HOLDINGS, LLC AND TEXAS ROADHOUSE MANAGEMENT CORP.	CA 12-00417	2012 NY Slip Op 68105(U)
PATRICIA CURTO V ZITTEL'S DAIRY FARM, JOHN ZITTEL, SANDY ZITTEL, THOMAS DEXTER, JEFFREY GASPER PATRICIA CURTO V	CA 11-02445	2012 NY Slip Op 68104(U)
NOUREEN ZAHID CHOHAN, V ZAHID MUNIR CHOHAN, .	CA 12-00472	2012 NY Slip Op 68103(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DAVID BURR V TIMOTHY B. HOWARD, SHERIFF OF ERIE COUNTY	CA 11-02283	2012 NY Slip Op 68102(U)
BAISCH, INC. V THE PIKE COMPANY, INC.	CA 12-00483	2012 NY Slip Op 68101(U)

**Motions Decided March 21, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V JOSHUA WILLIAMS, ALSO KNOWN AS JOSHUA K. WILLIAMS	KA 12-00485	2012 NY Slip Op 68100(U)
THE PEOPLE V JODYLYNN WETMORE	KA 12-00421	2012 NY Slip Op 68099(U)
THE PEOPLE V KIRBY WALL, ALSO KNOWN AS "JD", ALSO KNOWN AS KIRBY S. WALL Indictment No: 5261	KA 12-00422	2012 NY Slip Op 68098(U)
MATTER OF JEREMY WAWRZYNSKI V SHANTEL GOODMAN	CAF 11-02256	2012 NY Slip Op 68097(U)
THE PEOPLE V RONALD A. SMITH, ALSO KNOWN AS RONALD SMITH Indictment No: 5404	KA 12-00487	2012 NY Slip Op 68096(U)
THE PEOPLE V THOMAS FLOWER, ALSO KNOWN AS THOMAS S. FLOWER	KA 12-00453	2012 NY Slip Op 68095(U)
THE PEOPLE V PATRICK J. DONAHUE, ALSO KNOWN AS PATRICK DONAHUE Indictment No: 5434	KA 12-00406	2012 NY Slip Op 68094(U)
THE PEOPLE V ALAN J. DELANO, ALSO KNOWN AS ALAN DELANO Indictment No: 5358	KA 12-00423	2012 NY Slip Op 68093(U)
THE PEOPLE V TERRY BUCHHOLZ, ALSO KNOWN AS TERRY L. BUCHHOLZ Indictment No: 4542	KA 12-00486	2012 NY Slip Op 68092(U)
THE PEOPLE V DAVID R. BEEDHAM	KA 12-00402	2012 NY Slip Op 68091(U)
MATTER OF AUSTIN M. AND ANNA M.	CAF 12-00352	2012 NY Slip Op 68090(U)
MATTER OF ARIANNA M., GAUGE M., AND DYLAN C.	CAF 12-00442	2012 NY Slip Op 68089(U)

**Motions Decided March 20, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V ROLAND REED, JR., ALSO KNOWN AS ROLAND J. REED, ALSO KNOWN AS ROLAND J. REED, JR. -.	KA 12-00448	2012 NY Slip Op 68088(U)
MATTER OF WILLIAM J. REEVES V CASSIE J. PHILLIPS	CAF 11-00953	2012 NY Slip Op 68087(U)
THE PEOPLE V BOBBY L. MOBLEY, SR., ALSO KNOWN AS BOBBY MOBLEY, SR.	KA 12-00451	2012 NY Slip Op 68086(U)
THE PEOPLE V ISRAEL RIVERA MARRERO, ALSO KNOWN AS ISRAEL RIVERA, ALSO KNOWN AS ISRAEL R. MARRERO	KA 12-00455	2012 NY Slip Op 68085(U)
THE PEOPLE V ERIC D. H., ALSO KNOWN AS ERIC DANIEL H., ALSO KNOWN AS ERIC H.	KA 12-00457	2012 NY Slip Op 68084(U)
THE PEOPLE V ALICIA M. DESJARDINS, ALSO KNOWN AS ALICIA M. TOAL, ALSO KNOWN AS ALICIA DESJARDINS, ALSO KNOWN AS ALICIA	KA 12-00463	2012 NY Slip Op 68083(U)
THE PEOPLE V DOMINIC J. CORDELLO, JR., ALSO KNOWN AS DOMINIC CORDELLO, ALSO KNOWN AS D.J. CORDELLO Indictment No: 5395	KA 12-00452	2012 NY Slip Op 68082(U)
MATTER OF AUBREY A.	CAF 11-00619	2012 NY Slip Op 68081(U)

**Motions Decided March 19, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V CHARLES R. WILSON	KA 11-01197	2012 NY Slip Op 68080(U)
THE PEOPLE V VINCENT TORRES	KA 11-01388	2012 NY Slip Op 68079(U)
THE PEOPLE V LOUIS STAPLES, III	KA 12-00419	2012 NY Slip Op 68078(U)
THE PEOPLE V ERVIN J. SMALLS, JR. THE PEOPLE, V ERVIN SMALLS, JR.	KA 08-01315	2012 NY Slip Op 68077(U)
KIRK RUTHERFORD V SPENCER SPEEDWAY, INC., NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR STOCK CAR AUTO RACING, INC., JOHN WHITE AND JOHN	CA 12-00231	2012 NY Slip Op 68076(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL ROTTERMAN	KA 11-01340	2012 NY Slip Op 68075(U)
THE PEOPLE V RICKY L. MILLER, II, ALSO KNOWN AS RICKY MILLER, II, ALSO KNOWN AS RICKY LEE MILLER, II Indictment No: 5452	KA 12-00405	2012 NY Slip Op 68074(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHAQUILLE O. K., ALSO KNOWN AS SHAQUILLE K.	KA 12-00418	2012 NY Slip Op 68073(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANDRES P. GUTIERREZ	KA 10-01794	2012 NY Slip Op 68072(U)
THE PEOPLE V WESLEY A. GROUND, ALSO KNOWN AS WESLEY ALAN GROUND, ALSO KNOWN AS WESLEY GROUND Indictment No: 5336	KA 12-00465	2012 NY Slip Op 68071(U)
THE PEOPLE V CARL GOOSSENS	KA 09-01853	2012 NY Slip Op 68070(U)
THE PEOPLE EX REL., MICHAEL GONZALEZ V WAYNE COUNTY SHERIFF AND NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF PAROLE	KAH 11-01670	2012 NY Slip Op 68069(U)
THE PEOPLE V QUENTIN L. GIBSON, ALSO KNOWN AS QUENTIN M. GIBSON, ALSO KNOWN AS QUENTIN GIBSON Indictment No: 5340	KA 12-00403	2012 NY Slip Op 68068(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHRISTIAN J. FORD	KA 12-00433	2012 NY Slip Op 68067(U)
MATTER OF KENDALL L. DANNER V CHAD NEPAGE MATTER OF KENDALL L. DANNER V CHAD NEPAGE MATTER OF KENDALL L. DANNER V CHAD	CAF 11-01091	2012 NY Slip Op 68066(U)
JEFFREY CONSTANTINE, M.D. V STELLA MARIS INSURANCE COMPANY, LIMITED MARY SERIO AND NICHOLAS SERIO, AS PARENTS AND	CA 11-02521	2012 NY Slip Op 68065(U)
MATTER OF JAMES A. CHRISTIANSEN V TINA M. CHRISTIANSEN	CAF 12-00413	2012 NY Slip Op 68064(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHRISTOPHER BOMBARD, ALSO KNOWN AS CHRISTOPHER J. BOMBARD	KA 12-00449	2012 NY Slip Op 68063(U)
THE PEOPLE V DYLAN BARCLAY, ALSO KNOWN AS DYLAN A. BARCLAY Indictment No: 5411	KA 12-00447	2012 NY Slip Op 68062(U)

**Motions Decided March 16, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
MATTER OF JOSHUA R.S.	CAF 11-00069	2012 NY Slip Op 68061(U)

**Motions Decided March 15, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
JAMES WILLIAM SCHNITTER V FE MARIANN CARROLL-SCHNITTER (Index No. 2008/15188)	CA 12-00240	2012 NY Slip Op 68060(U)
MATTER OF JOSHUA BURRELL V ANGELA D. BURRELL	CAF 11-01551	2012 NY Slip Op 68059(U)
MATTER OF THE ADOPTION OF ANGELINA AND AMIYAH	CAF 12-00393	2012 NY Slip Op 68058(U)

**Motions Decided March 13, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
MATTER OF GENA S.	CAF 11-01187	2012 NY Slip Op 68057(U)
MATTER OF GENA S.	CAF 11-01187	2012 NY Slip Op 68056(U)

**Motions Decided March 14, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
KIRBY J. COLLING V FRONTIER FIBERS, INC. AND GLR OF NEW YORK, INC.	CA 12-00425	2012 NY Slip Op 67304(U)

**Motions Decided March 13, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
WILLIAM SMITH AND DIANE SMITH V CAROUSEL CENTER CO., LP	CA 12-00400	2012 NY Slip Op 67303(U)
MATTER OF VALENTINA RULINSKY V JERMAINE WEST	CAF 11-02192	2012 NY Slip Op 67302(U)
MATTER OF ROMAN E.A.	CAF 12-00301	2012 NY Slip Op 67301(U)
MATTER OF KAYLEE O.	CAF 12-00140	2012 NY Slip Op 67300(U)
RICHARD HARBY V AIMEE HARBY	CA 12-00414	2012 NY Slip Op 67299(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CLIFFORD GRAHAM V KEVIN WALSH, SHERIFF OF ONONDAGA COUNTY, AND GORDON J. CUFFY, ONONDAGA COUNTY	CA 12-00391	2012 NY Slip Op 67298(U)
MATTER OF EMERALD L.C.	CAF 11-02266	2012 NY Slip Op 67297(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MARK BLOND V SUPERINTENDENT LEMPKE	CA 12-00334	2012 NY Slip Op 67296(U)
MATTER OF ALEXIA L.	CAF 11-01028	2012 NY Slip Op 67295(U)

**Motions Decided March 12, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
VILLAGE OF ILION VILLAGE OF HERKIMER, AND TOWN OF FRANKFORT, AS MUNICIPAL CORPORATIONS AND ON BEHALF OF THEIR	NOS. CA 12-00086, CA 12-00087, AND CA 12-00088	2012 NY Slip Op 67294(U)
IN THE MATTER OF EDWARD TREAT	CA 11-00590	2012 NY Slip Op 67293(U)
THE PEOPLE V STANLEY STACHNIK	KA 09-01630 AND KA 10-00393	2012 NY Slip Op 67292(U)
EVELYN SONNELITTER, GARY SONNELITTER, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS SUCCESSOR TRUSTEE, AND SONNELITTER FAMILY TRUST, V JOSEPH	NOS. CA 12-00175 AND CA 12-00176	2012 NY Slip Op 67291(U)
THE PEOPLE V LASHAWN J. SCOTT	KA 11-00404	2012 NY Slip Op 67290(U)
JACKIE D. SCIPIO V WAL-MART STORES EAST, L.P. AND ANTHONY DESANTIS	CA 12-00382	2012 NY Slip Op 67289(U)
THE PEOPLE V CARLOS SANTIAGO, JR.	KA 08-01881	2012 NY Slip Op 67288(U)
RLI INSURANCE COMPANY V LESLIE SMIEDALA , REGIONAL INTEGRATED LOGISTICS, INC.	CA 12-00261	2012 NY Slip Op 67287(U)
JASON PALMER AND MANDY PALMER V COUNTY OF ERIE SHAWN PALMER V COUNTY OF ERIE (APPEAL NO. 2.)	CA 11-01725	2012 NY Slip Op 67286(U)
THE PEOPLE V JASON B. OSGOOD	KA 11-02325	2012 NY Slip Op 67285(U)
THE PEOPLE V NICHOLAS J. MORGAN	KA 07-01252	2012 NY Slip Op 67284(U)
JANNETTE MORALES V ASARESE MATTERS COMMUNITY CENTER, REES-ALLISON POOL, CITY OF BUFFALO PARKS AND RECREATION	CA 12-00458	2012 NY Slip Op 67283(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL G. MILCZAKOWSKYJ	KA 08-01383	2012 NY Slip Op 67282(U)
THE PEOPLE V PETER J. MEHMEL	KA 11-01496	2012 NY Slip Op 67281(U)
IN THE MATTER OF VICTOR MEDINA V WILLIAM F. HULIHAN, SUPERINTENDENT, MID-STATE CORRECTIONAL FACILITY	TP 11-01700	2012 NY Slip Op 67280(U)
THE PEOPLE V DOUGLAS K. MARTIN	KA 11-00293	2012 NY Slip Op 67279(U)
THE PEOPLE V STANLEY LOSTUMBO	KA 12-00106	2012 NY Slip Op 67278(U)
SALVATORE J. LICARI, ALSO KNOWN AS SAM LICARI, ANNA LICARI AND LACARI FAMILY HOLDINGS LLC V NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL	CA 12-00131	2012 NY Slip Op 67277(U)
THE PEOPLE V STANLEY R. KIMS, II	KA 11-00863	2012 NY Slip Op 67276(U)
MATTER OF KAYLEE O.	CAF 12-00140	2012 NY Slip Op 67275(U)
IN THE MATTER OF NAHSHON JACKSON V ALBERT PRACK, DIRECTOR, SPECIAL HOUSING/INMATE DISCIPLINARY PROGRAM	TP 11-02379	2012 NY Slip Op 67274(U)
RUSTIN R. HOWARD V BIOWORKS, INC.	CA 12-00432	2012 NY Slip Op 67273(U)
THE PEOPLE V JEREMY HASLEY	KA 11-00194	2012 NY Slip Op 67272(U)
GINA M. GRUNZWEIG AND CHARLES H. GRUNZWEIG V JAMES J. YAGER	CA 12-00399	2012 NY Slip Op 67271(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION OF DOROTHY E. GRAY TO DETERMINE THE VALIDITY OF ELECTION AGAINST THE LAST WILL AND	CA 11-02273	2012 NY Slip Op 67270(U)
LAURIE J. GERACE-MURDENT V LARKIN L. KIMMERER AND ROBIN W. KIMMERER	CA 11-02202	2012 NY Slip Op 67269(U)
KIMBERLY MITCHELL CONVERSE V DOLE FOOD COMPANY, INC. AND DOLE FRESH FRUIT COMPANY, INC. AND LEONARD'S EXPRESS, INC.	CA 11-02438	2012 NY Slip Op 67268(U)
ISAIAS BERMUDEZ, CLAIMANT- V STATE OF NEW YORK (CLAIM NO. 114663.)	CA 11-01708	2012 NY Slip Op 67267(U)
WILLIAM J. BABCOCK, JR. AND LORNA F. BABCOCK V H. ROBERT SCHOENBERGER	CA 12-00456	2012 NY Slip Op 67266(U)
STEPHEN ALIKES AND JANET ALIKES V ANDREW GRIFFITH DOING BUSINESS AS ANDY GRIFFITH REALTOR, RE/MAX PROPERTIES, AND SHARI	CA 12-00380	2012 NY Slip Op 67265(U)

**Motions Decided March 9, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V KENNETH L. THOMPSON	KA 10-01781	2012 NY Slip Op 67264(U)
PIA THOMAS V DUNKIRK RESORT PROPERTIES, LLC, RELIANCE MGT. CORP., W.D. ASSOCIATES, L.P.	CA 12-00358	2012 NY Slip Op 67263(U)
MATTER OF TIMOTHY SPARKS V COLEEN STEIN	CAF 12-00348	2012 NY Slip Op 67262(U)
MATTER OF PHILEMON GREENE V SHEILA HANSON	CAF 11-00707	2012 NY Slip Op 67261(U)
MATTER OF EMERALD L.C.	CAF 11-02266	2012 NY Slip Op 67260(U)
MATTER OF ELSA R. AND MIRACLE R.	CAF 11-01487	2012 NY Slip Op 67259(U)

**Motions Decided March 8, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
JAMES WILLIAM SCHNITTER V FE MARIANN CARROLL-SCHNITTER (Index No. 2008/15188)	CA 12-00240	2012 NY Slip Op 67258(U)
MATTER OF CINDY M. PHELPS, AND AUGUSTUS T. PHELPS V EUGENE DEXTER HUNTER	CAF 11-02240	2012 NY Slip Op 67257(U)
MATTER OF LILLIANNA G.	CAF 12-00247	2012 NY Slip Op 67256(U)
MATTER OF LANDEN D.	CAF 11-02393	2012 NY Slip Op 67255(U)
MATTER OF KQUAMERE R. AND SYRIA W.	CAF 11-02363	2012 NY Slip Op 67254(U)
MATTER OF DAVID BONNELL V KIMBERLY J. RODGERS	CAF 12-00300	2012 NY Slip Op 67253(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION UNDER ARTICLE 7 OF THE REAL PROPERTY TAX LAW BY DIANA SACHS AYLWARD, JOHN C.	CA 12-00328	2012 NY Slip Op 67252(U)

**Motions Decided March 9, 2011**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
MATTER OF ELIZABETH STORELLI V ANTHONY STORELLI	CAF 11-02003	2011 NY Slip Op 94226(U)

**Motions Decided March 7, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V SHAWN OBBAGY	KA 12-00320 AND KA 12-00321	2012 NY Slip Op 66581(U)
THE PEOPLE V RODNEY BANKS	KA 12-00219	2012 NY Slip Op 66580(U)

**Motions Decided March 6, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF THE VILLAGE OF ALBION, COUNTY OF ORLEANS, STATE OF NEW YORK V JAMES MCCARTHY AND	CA 11-02210	2012 NY Slip Op 66579(U)
KENNETH POLK AND CARA POLK V JOSEPH GUGINO, SR., INDIVIDUALLY AND DOING BUSINESS AS J. GUGINO CONSTRUCTION, JOSEPH	CA 12-00363	2012 NY Slip Op 66578(U)
MATTER OF NICHOLAS C.	CAF 11-01532	2012 NY Slip Op 66577(U)
SHARLENE MCKENZIE, AS EXECUTRIX OF THE ESTATE OF OSCAR MCKENZIE, JR., DECEASED V ONONDAGA COUNTY AND ONONDAGA COUNTY	CA 12-00397	2012 NY Slip Op 66576(U)
MATTER OF JOSEPH A.T.P.	CAF 11-02448	2012 NY Slip Op 66575(U)
JOHN HOGAN, CLAIMANT- V STATE OF NEW YORK (CLAIM NO. 116249.)	CA 12-00336	2012 NY Slip Op 66574(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CAROLYN E. GRIEVE V PERRY PUBLIC LIBRARY, COMMISSIONER OF EDUCATION OF STATE OF NEW YORK, RICHARD R.	CA 12-00347	2012 NY Slip Op 66573(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SHAWN G. GRANGER V BRIAN FISCHER, COMMISSIONER OF NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES	CA 12-00322	2012 NY Slip Op 66572(U)
MATTER OF JENNIFER S. DAVIS V ROBERT P. DRIGGS, III	CAF 12-00306	2012 NY Slip Op 66571(U)
PATRICIA CURTO V ZITTEL'S DAIRY FARM, JOHN ZITTEL, SANDY ZITTEL, THOMAS DEXTER, JEFFREY GASPER	NOS. CA 11-02445, CA 11-02446, AND CA 11-02447	2012 NY Slip Op 66570(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ROBERT CUMBERLAND V HAROLD D. GRAHAM, SUPERINTENDENT, AUBURN CORRECTIONAL FACILITY .	TP 11-02388	2012 NY Slip Op 66569(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOSEPH A. CAMARDO, JR. V CITY OF AUBURN	CA 11-01200	2012 NY Slip Op 66568(U)
MATTER OF KRISTINA A. BUSHNELL V MICHAEL S. BUSHNELL	CAF 11-00001	2012 NY Slip Op 66567(U)
LINDA BOTSFORD V US MAINTENANCE, INC., RITE AID , AND MPC, INC.	CA 12-00318	2012 NY Slip Op 66566(U)

**Motions Decided March 5, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V DAVID M. ZACHER Indictment No: 0303/05	KA 06-02623	2012 NY Slip Op 66565(U)
THE PEOPLE V JUSTIN T. WOODARD	KA 11-00357	2012 NY Slip Op 66564(U)
THE PEOPLE V BERNARD THOMAS, JR.	KA 10-01368	2012 NY Slip Op 66563(U)
MATTER OF SCOTT T. SWINSON V STAR DOBSON	CAF 11-01325	2012 NY Slip Op 66562(U)
THE PEOPLE V KENT D. SPRATLEY	KA 11-00486	2012 NY Slip Op 66561(U)
THE PEOPLE V RAFIQ SALIM	KA 10-01173	2012 NY Slip Op 66560(U)
THE PEOPLE V LANCE J. REED	KA 09-00281	2012 NY Slip Op 66559(U)
RAYMOND PINK AND MICHELLE PINK V MATTHEW RICCI MARK WILBUR, CHRISTIN WILBUR, ROME YOUTH HOCKEY ASSOCIATION, INC.	CA 12-00377	2012 NY Slip Op 66558(U)
RAYMOND PINK AND MICHELLE PINK V MATTHEW RICCI MARK WILBUR, CHRISTIN WILBUR, ROME YOUTH HOCKEY ASSOCIATION, INC.	CA 12-00377	2012 NY Slip Op 66557(U)
KATHLEEN P. MUELLER, INDIVIDUALLY, AND AS ADMINISTRATRIX OF ESTATE OF NATALIE C. DRUZBIK, DECEASED V ELDERWOOD HEALTH	NOS. CA 11-01755 AND CA 11-01756	2012 NY Slip Op 66556(U)
THE PEOPLE V VINCENT MILLER	KA 10-02512	2012 NY Slip Op 66555(U)
THE PEOPLE V DAVID MCCALLUM	KA 10-00667	2012 NY Slip Op 66554(U)
SARAH MATTESON V CANDICE A. SCHURR FORMERLY KNOWN AS CANDICE A. REYNOLDS AND PEOPLE, INC.	CA 12-00362	2012 NY Slip Op 66553(U)
JAMES LUPPINO, SUCCESSOR ADMINISTRATOR OF ESTATE OF MARIA V. LUPPINO, DECEASED V ACEA A. MOSEY, AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE	CA 11-02351	2012 NY Slip Op 66552(U)
THE PEOPLE V STANLEY R. KIMS, II	KA 11-00863	2012 NY Slip Op 66551(U)
IN THE MATTER OF WILLIAM B. JOHNSTON V GALEN D. KIRKLAND, COMMISSIONER, NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RIGHTS, SCOTT	TP 12-00005	2012 NY Slip Op 66550(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DONNELL JEFFERSON V JOSHUA STUBBE (Index No. 2011/06590)	CA 11-02452	2012 NY Slip Op 66549(U)
THE PEOPLE V MIGUEL A. JARAMILLO	KA 11-00972	2012 NY Slip Op 66548(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL A. JACKSON	KA 12-00327	2012 NY Slip Op 66547(U)
HAYWARD BAKER, INC., V C.O. FALTER CONSTRUCTION CORP., ZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY, AND FIDELITY AND DEPOSIT	CA 12-00398	2012 NY Slip Op 66546(U)
IN THE MATTER OF G & S MANAGEMENT, INC., DOING BUSINESS AS GUIDO SCIRRI AND GUIDO SCIRRI V BARBARA J. FIALA AND NEW	TP 11-02206	2012 NY Slip Op 66545(U)
THE PEOPLE V JESSIE J. BARNES	KA 10-01241	2012 NY Slip Op 66544(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANTHONY ADAMS	KA 09-00546	2012 NY Slip Op 66543(U)

**Motions Decided March 2, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
SUZANNE K. SAVAGE V ANDERSON'S FROZEN CUSTARD, INC. EMU AMERICAS, LLC, ALPHA CONTRACT FLOORING, INC., BUFFALO HOTEL	CA 12-00307	2012 NY Slip Op 66542(U)
SHARON MOORE V NIAGARA FALLS HOUSING AUTHORITY NIAGARA FALLS HOUSING AUTHORITY FAMILY TENANT'S ASSOCIATION, INC.	CA 12-00262	2012 NY Slip Op 66541(U)
GILBERTO AGUDO MARTINEZ V APRIL M. REMBERT	CA 12-00260	2012 NY Slip Op 66540(U)
CHARLES R. LIVECCHI V JOHN NACCA	CA 12-00284	2012 NY Slip Op 66539(U)
BRIAN W. HINT V ALFRED L. VAUGHN AND MELANIE P. HEMENWAY	CA 12-00302	2012 NY Slip Op 66538(U)
NIESHA HAYNES V KALEIDA HEALTH, CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL, KEVIN FITZPATRICK, M.D. AND MARGARET MULVIHILL, M.D.	CA 11-02507	2012 NY Slip Op 66537(U)
IN THE MATTER OF STATE OF NEW YORK V DANIEL FARNSWORTH	CA 12-00257	2012 NY Slip Op 66536(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CLAIROL DEVELOPMENT, LLC AND CRANE-HOGAN STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS, INC V VILLAGE OF SPENCERPORT; JACK CROOKS	CA 12-00356	2012 NY Slip Op 66535(U)
CHARLES BARONE, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF DONNA MARIE BARONE, DECEASED V HARTWIG BOEPPLE, M.D.	CA 12-00303	2012 NY Slip Op 66534(U)

**Motions Decided March 1, 2012**
Title	Motion No.	SlipOp No.
LEON WRIGHT V STRONG MEMORIAL HOSPITAL, AMBULATORY INTERNAL MEDICINE FACULTY/RESIDENT PRACTICE, UNIVERSITY OF	CA 10-00568	2012 NY Slip Op 66533(U)
DANIEL WILLIAMS AND EDWARD WILLIAMS V BEEMILLER, INC. DOING BUSINESS AS HI-POINT, CHARLES BROWN, MKS SUPPLY, INC.	CA 11-02092	2012 NY Slip Op 66532(U)
MARY ANN WERNER V KALEIDA HEALTH	CA 11-02456	2012 NY Slip Op 66531(U)
TOM THOMAS AND THOMAS ESTATES WEST V CYNTHIA L. BOHEEN DAVIS, ASSESSOR, AND BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW OF TOWN OF	CA 11-02181	2012 NY Slip Op 66530(U)
MATTER OF SCOTT T. SWINSON V STAR DOBSON	CAF 11-01325	2012 NY Slip Op 66529(U)
KENNETH M. SCHLAU, JR. V CITY OF BUFFALO , FREY ELECTRIC CONSTRUCTION CO., INC. KENNETH M. SCHLAU, JR. V CITY OF	CA 11-01153	2012 NY Slip Op 66528(U)
LARRY PLAC V VILLAGE OF ILION AND COUNTY OF HERKIMER	CA 11-01616	2012 NY Slip Op 66527(U)
JAKE K. HILL V SENECA NATION OF INDIANS , SENECA CONCRETE AND PAVING CO., LLC	CA 12-00053	2012 NY Slip Op 66526(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ANTHONY DEPERNO, INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF VICTORY SIGN, INC., V TOWN OF VERONA, OWEN E. WALLER	NOS. CA 11-02289 AND CA 11-02290	2012 NY Slip Op 66525(U)
MATTER OF KENDALL L. DANNER V CHAD NEPAGE MATTER OF KENDALL L. DANNER V CHAD NEPAGE MATTER OF KENDALL L. DANNER V CHAD	CAF 11-01091	2012 NY Slip Op 66524(U)
PATRICIA CURTO V ZITTEL'S DAIRY FARM, JOHN ZITTEL, SANDY ZITTEL, THOMAS DEXTER, JEFFREY GASPER PATRICIA CURTO V	CA 11-02445	2012 NY Slip Op 66523(U)
COUNTY OF ERIE V M/A-COM, INC., TYCO ELECTRONICS CORPORATION, INTERGRAPH CORPORATION AND KEVIN J. COMERFORD	NOS. CA 12-00075 AND CA 12-00076	2012 NY Slip Op 66522(U)
ANTHONY CHAVIS V SYRACUSE COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTER, INC. , PASQUALE SCUTARI, JR., D.D.S., INDIVIDUALLY AND DOING	CA 11-02292	2012 NY Slip Op 66521(U)
BARBARA ANDERSON AND DAN FAULKNER V RAY JUSTICE , STEVE EZARD	CA 12-00183	2012 NY Slip Op 66520(U)