skip to main content
Law Reporting
Bureau Thomas J.K. Smith, State Reporter

Appellate Division, Fourth Department Motions

Current Month Archived Cases Decisions

January 2026 Archive

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

Motions Decided January 30, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
DARWIN S. PUTNAM V PATSY D. PUTNAM, AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF DARWIN L. PUTNAM, DECEASED, AND PATSY DARLENE PUTNAMCA 24-015272026 NY Slip Op 63059(U)
Motions Decided January 29, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF RAY KAMILA V MAUI C. WATERSCAF 26-000472026 NY Slip Op 61555(U)
Motions Decided January 28, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
DANIEL JONES, CLAIMANT- V STATE OF NEW YORKCA 25-001432026 NY Slip Op 61554(U)
Motions Decided January 27, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
MARLENA WRZOS V JASON HASKELL , RACEWAY ENTERTAINMENT, LLC, AND LANCASTER PROPERTIES, LLCCA 25-005972026 NY Slip Op 61553(U)
THE PEOPLE V KEITH J. WILLIAMSKA 22-014142026 NY Slip Op 61552(U)
US INCOME PARTNERS, LLC, V CYPRESS POINTE FL HOLDINGS, LLC, PHILLIPS LYTLE, LLP, ANTHONY M. CARELLO AND RYAN A. LOWN, .CA 25-014902026 NY Slip Op 61551(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOSEPH R. STEELEKA 24-006332026 NY Slip Op 61550(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHAHMELL S. ROBINSONKA 25-009442026 NY Slip Op 61549(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL A. ROBINSONKA 24-017342026 NY Slip Op 61548(U)
ACCOUNTING BY LINDA PERRY-HITCHINGS AND DONNA PERRY DEMONTE AS THE TRUSTEES OF THE ROBERT A. PERRY AND DORRIS R. PERRYCA 25-015372026 NY Slip Op 61547(U)
ROBERT D. KEHOE V HOLIDAY VALLEY RESORTCA 25-006002026 NY Slip Op 61546(U)
ROBERT D. KEHOE V HOLIDAY VALLEY RESORT (WIN-SUM SKI CORP.)CA 25-003582026 NY Slip Op 61545(U)
CARL WAYNE JAMES, CLAIMANT- V THE STATE OF NEW YORKCA 25-021212026 NY Slip Op 61544(U)
THE PEOPLE V DWAYNE FAUZEYKA 25-005142026 NY Slip Op 61543(U)
JULIE E. PASEK, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS A POWER OF ATTORNEY FOR JAMES G. PASEK V CATHOLIC HEALTH SYSTEM, INC. , TERUMOCA 25-013072026 NY Slip Op 61542(U)
JING CHEN V DAVID P. WILLIAMSCA 25-019782026 NY Slip Op 61541(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOENATHAN CASHKA 23-012242026 NY Slip Op 61540(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF DANIELLE DILL, PSY.D., EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF CENTRAL NEW YORK PSYCHIATRIC CENTER VCA 25-019632026 NY Slip Op 61539(U)
Motions Decided January 26, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF TODD C. CARVILLE, AS DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF COUNTY OF ONEIDA V HON. BERNADETTE T. CLARK, AS JUSTICE OFOP 25-013882026 NY Slip Op 61538(U)
Motions Decided January 23, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF LUCILLE A. DAVIDSON V PHILLIP RICECAF 25-019552026 NY Slip Op 61537(U)
Motions Decided January 22, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF TANEA L. HARTSFIELD V TERRON D. SMITHCAF 25-007062026 NY Slip Op 61536(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TANEA L. HARTSFIELD V TERRON D. SMITHCAF 25-007062026 NY Slip Op 61535(U)
Motions Decided January 21, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V JASON A. WEEKSKA 25-009992026 NY Slip Op 61304(U)
THE PEOPLE V STEPHEN WASHINGTONKA 23-012572026 NY Slip Op 61303(U)
PETER R. MORGAN V VILLAGE OF MOHAWK, MOHAWK, NEW YORK -.CA 24-002422026 NY Slip Op 61302(U)
VILLAGE OF HERKIMER V CECILA FAGAN POLIDORI, ALSO KNOWN AS CECILIA M. FAGAN, AND SHAWN R. GILBERT VILLAGE OF HERKIMER VCA 25-012302026 NY Slip Op 61301(U)
US INCOME PARTNERS, LLC V CYPRESS POINTE FL HOLDINGS, LLC,CA 25-019432026 NY Slip Op 61300(U)
PATRICIA A. SHANLEY, CLAIMANT- V STATE OF NEW YORK AND NEW YORK STATE CANAL CORPORATION HOLLY CURCIONE, CLAIMANT- VCA 25-006822026 NY Slip Op 61299(U)
LEO D. STAROWITZ, JR. V STAR GROWERS FARM, LLC, STAR GROWERS LAND, LLC, STAR GROWERS, INC., ANDREW M. STAROWITZ, FRANKCA 25-004772026 NY Slip Op 61298(U)
JAMES M. STANG V SADISHIV S. SHENOY, M.D., - .CA 25-010102026 NY Slip Op 61297(U)
PAUL RYAN V SUSAN CUNNINGHAM, ALAN LINCOLN, NANCY KERRIGAN, CHARLIE BERNET, KRISTA TASKEY, DIANA MARLEY, DAVID SMARTCA 25-009782026 NY Slip Op 61296(U)
PARTNERSHIP FOR THE PUBLIC GOOD, INC., HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES MADE EQUAL, INC., PEOPLE UNITED FOR SUSTAINABLE HOUSINGCA 25-003122026 NY Slip Op 61295(U)
THE PEOPLE, V AUGUSTIN OCASIOKA 20-003122026 NY Slip Op 61294(U)
MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF NIAGARA COUNTY.2026 NY Slip Op 61293(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOSEPH MURPHYKA 26-000262026 NY Slip Op 61292(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHAWN O. MOORE, JR.KA 19-008382026 NY Slip Op 61291(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF CHARLES MIXON V HAMBURG FOIL OFFICER, CLERK'S OFFICE RICHARD G. BOEHM, DEPUTY TOWNCA 24-015102026 NY Slip Op 61290(U)
THE PEOPLE V JONATHAN E. MELENDEZKA 25-010562026 NY Slip Op 61289(U)
THE PEOPLE V JONATHAN E. MELENDEZKA 25-010562026 NY Slip Op 61288(U)
THE PEOPLE V JONATHAN E. MELENDEZKA 25-010562026 NY Slip Op 61287(U)
ADRIAN MARTINEZ V DEANNIE RIVERACAF 25-020102026 NY Slip Op 61286(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TRAVIS M. KILLIAN, V CLAUDETTE STERN, .CAF 25-003912026 NY Slip Op 61285(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KERRY K. V STATE OF NEW YORKCA 24-017892026 NY Slip Op 61284(U)
MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF JEFFERSON COUNTY.2026 NY Slip Op 61283(U)
THE PEOPLE V TYWAYNE IVERYKA 24-014762026 NY Slip Op 61282(U)
THE PEOPLE V TERRANCE B. HINESKA 25-014572026 NY Slip Op 61281(U)
SHANE GRAVELLE V CITY OF BUFFALO, SICOLI CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC., - .CA 25-020722026 NY Slip Op 61280(U)
THE PEOPLE V JONATHAN SUSTACHE GONZALEZKA 25-020172026 NY Slip Op 61279(U)
JENNIFER G FLANNERY, ERIE COUNTY PUBLIC ADMINISTRATOR FOR THE ESTATE OF CATALINA FAITH TORRES, DECEASED V COUNTY OFCA 25-019022026 NY Slip Op 61278(U)
IN THE MATTER OF APPLICATION OF DANIELLE DILL, PSY.D., EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF CENTRAL NEW YORK PSYCHIATRIC CENTER VCA 25-019262026 NY Slip Op 61277(U)
PARTNERS & NAPIER INC. V JULIE DEROLLER, JENNIFER RAMPE, JOCELYN PORTER, JOSEPH HERBST, AND HEARD CREATIVE CORPORATIONCA 25-021292026 NY Slip Op 61276(U)
THE PEOPLE, V WILLIAM CRENSHAWKA 23-006462026 NY Slip Op 61275(U)
BRIAN CONDON, CLAIMANT- V STATE OF NEW YORKCA 25-006382026 NY Slip Op 61274(U)
THE PEOPLE V BOBBY L. CLEGG, IIIKA 24-01040 and KA 24-010412026 NY Slip Op 61273(U)
JING CHEN V DAVID P. WILLIAMSCA 25-01978 AND CA 25-020052026 NY Slip Op 61272(U)
JING CHEN V DAVID P. WILLIAMSCA 25-019782026 NY Slip Op 61271(U)
GLORIA CALVANESO V SHAWN K. MOCHOL, PAUL T. FOURNIER ENTERPRISES, INC., AND MODERN DISPOSAL SERVICES, INC.CA 25-006512026 NY Slip Op 61270(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOSHUA A. CAUFIELDKA 25-00527 and KA 25-005282026 NY Slip Op 61269(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANTOINETTE M. CASSONIKA 25-020252026 NY Slip Op 61268(U)
THE PEOPLE V TERRY L. BULKLEY, JRKA 25-01578 and KA 25-018462026 NY Slip Op 61267(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MADDOX B.S.CAF 25-017122026 NY Slip Op 61266(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JAYDEN B. AND MASON B.CAF 25-001672026 NY Slip Op 61265(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ZACHARIAH A.M.B.CAF 25-015842026 NY Slip Op 61264(U)
Motions Decided January 20, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
TINA M. BATTEY V VILLAGE OF YOUNGSTOWNCA 25-013702026 NY Slip Op 61263(U)
MATTER OF DEBORAH L. SINGLETON AND CHRISTOPHER J. SINGLETON V VILLAGE OF ADAMS ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS AND VILLAGE OFCA 25-004442026 NY Slip Op 61262(U)
TRI TREKKERS, LLC V SAFFI L. RIGBERG AND DANIEL F. RUSSELLCA 25-01749 AND CA 25-017502026 NY Slip Op 61261(U)
DANIELLE ANDALORA SHERMAN V SOMERS SHERMANCA 24-018052026 NY Slip Op 61260(U)
THE PEOPLE V MARLON SCOTTKA 22-018212026 NY Slip Op 61259(U)
IN THE MATTER OF NEW YORK STATE POLICE V DAVID J. KINGSLEY IICA 25-004432026 NY Slip Op 61258(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHARLES MAJORKA 24-014592026 NY Slip Op 61257(U)
MERIMA KAJTEZOVIC V HUSEIN KAJTEZOVICCA 24-015532026 NY Slip Op 61256(U)
CLEAN AND GREEN CNG TECHNOLOGIES CORP. AND DIAMOND BUILDERS CORP., V DIVERSIFIED ERECTION SERVICES, .CA 25-005872026 NY Slip Op 61255(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JAMES ALLARD, STEUBEN COUNTY SHERIFF, - V COUNTY OF STEUBEN, STEUBEN COUNTY LEGISLATURE, SCOTT VANCA 25-004732026 NY Slip Op 61254(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANTOINETTE M. CASSONIKA 23-007432026 NY Slip Op 61253(U)
THE PEOPLE V SYJESMAN T. BROWN, ALSO KNOWN AS JOHN DOEKA 19-014892026 NY Slip Op 61252(U)
THE PEOPLE V SYJESMAN T. BROWN, ALSO KNOWN AS JOHN DOEKA 19-014882026 NY Slip Op 61251(U)
THE PEOPLE V RICHARD P. AMESKA 25-002262026 NY Slip Op 61250(U)
Motions Decided January 14, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF TRINITY L.T.CAF 25-02066 and CAF 25-020672026 NY Slip Op 61249(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALLAOO R.CAF 25-001882026 NY Slip Op 61248(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DAVID A. DAILEY V ALICIA A. DAILEYCAF 25-021162026 NY Slip Op 61247(U)
IN THE MATTER OF FAITH C.CAF 25-021182026 NY Slip Op 61246(U)
IN THE MATTER OF BABY A. AND BABY B.CAF 25-017882026 NY Slip Op 61245(U)
Motions Decided January 12, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V JAMES WHITEKA 25-020142026 NY Slip Op 61244(U)
NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF CANNABIS MANAGEMENT V GEORGE F. WEST, INDIVIDUALLY AND D/B/A "JAYDEGA 7.0"CA 25-020642026 NY Slip Op 61243(U)
THE PEOPLE V FREDERICK S. WALKER, JR.KA 21-017302026 NY Slip Op 61242(U)
JASON HILL V FRANCINE C. VERHAGENCA 25-016882026 NY Slip Op 61241(U)
JASON HILL V FRANCINE C. VERHAGENCA 25-016872026 NY Slip Op 61240(U)
JASON HILL V FRANCINE C. VERHAGENCA 25-016692026 NY Slip Op 61239(U)
REBECCA A. BEISIEGEL V PINNACLE ORTHOPEDIC & SPINE SPECIALISTS, LLC , UBMD PHYSICIANS' GROUP, UNIVERSITY AT BUFFALOCA 25-012862026 NY Slip Op 61238(U)
KIMBERLY J. SALTER, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF AARON SALTER, JR., DECEASED - V META PLATFORMS, INC.CA 24-005332026 NY Slip Op 61237(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOHN SAUBERAN, ALSO KNOWN AS FULLAGARKA 23-008282026 NY Slip Op 61236(U)
THE PEOPLE V JAZMINE D.S.KA 20-011762026 NY Slip Op 61235(U)
IN THE MATTER OF NELSON L. RODRIGUEZ V HON. JOHN J. DELMONTE, ERIE COUNTY SUPREME COURT JUDGE, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITYOP 25-015622026 NY Slip Op 61234(U)
THE PEOPLE V JACKIE R. ROBINSONKA 23-018012026 NY Slip Op 61233(U)
THE PEOPLE V JAMES F. RAYMONDKA 25-020132026 NY Slip Op 61232(U)
DIONA PATTERSON, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF HEYWARD PATTERSON - V META PLATFORMS, INC.CA 24-005322026 NY Slip Op 61231(U)
THE PEOPLE V SANDRA L. PAVLOCKKA 25-020272026 NY Slip Op 61230(U)
THE PEOPLE V JESSE D. OUTLEYKA 24-012632026 NY Slip Op 61229(U)
THE PEOPLE V MALEEK A. ODUSANYAKA 23-009922026 NY Slip Op 61228(U)
RASHAD MUHAMMAD V AYEISHA R. SADDIQUE, RAMONITA SANTIAGO, AND GEICO INSURANCE COMPANYCA 25-001422026 NY Slip Op 61227(U)
LESSA EDHOLM V BOARD OF COOPERATIVE EDUCATIONAL SERVICES ERIE 1 BOCES AND EILEEN FLEMING, INDIVIDUAL AND AS HR DIRECTORCA 25-009232026 NY Slip Op 61226(U)
THE PEOPLE V QUARON J. LEWISKA 25-01312 and KA 25-013212026 NY Slip Op 61225(U)
JENA COPELIN, STEPHEN A. LANDS AND CARRIE A. BERGEY V TOWN OF LEWISTON AND AMY WITRYOLCA 25-007252026 NY Slip Op 61224(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ANDERSON ENRIQUE VASQUEZ JUAREZ,CA 25-012722026 NY Slip Op 61223(U)
THE PEOPLE V IZAYAH A. JOHNSONKA 25-020502026 NY Slip Op 61222(U)
THE PEOPLE V KARON JAMESKA 23-002892026 NY Slip Op 61221(U)
THE PEOPLE V JASON EVANSKA 24-010942026 NY Slip Op 61220(U)
EAST SIDE PARKWAYS COALITION - V NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, CITY OF BUFFALO,CA 25-008282026 NY Slip Op 61219(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHARLES DOZIERKA 25-020262026 NY Slip Op 61218(U)
JAMES BUSCH V COUNTY OF ERIE, GRACE MOKA, R.N., JULIA DIBIASE-JOHNSTON, R.N., ALLISON PARKER, HEIDI CORNELL, NP, - .CA 25-007142026 NY Slip Op 61217(U)
TARGET CORPORATION V COUNTY OF MONROE INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT AGENCY, 1733 RIDGE RD LLC, RIDGE TIAM LLC, SKYVIEW PHASE IOP 25-015312026 NY Slip Op 61216(U)
THE PEOPLE V SCOTT E. COOLEYKA 23-018452026 NY Slip Op 61215(U)
THE PEOPLE V JAMES E. COMFORTKA 03-02311 and KA 05-008202026 NY Slip Op 61214(U)
THE PEOPLE V LISBETH COLLADOKA 23-009252026 NY Slip Op 61213(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOHN C. COLEKA 25-019922026 NY Slip Op 61212(U)
STACHE INVESTMENTS CORPORATION V LEONARD J. CIOLEKCA 24-007312026 NY Slip Op 61211(U)
THE PEOPLE V DONALD BOVIOKA 23-009262026 NY Slip Op 61210(U)
THE PEOPLE V THOMAS BELLKA 25-019732026 NY Slip Op 61209(U)
THE PEOPLE V JASON D'AVOLIOKA 21-011652026 NY Slip Op 61208(U)
THE PEOPLE V JASON D'AVOLIOKA 21-011652026 NY Slip Op 61207(U)
AMBER WELL DRILLING, LLC, V TIMOTHY A. REED AND JENNIFER M. REED, .CA 24-013992026 NY Slip Op 61206(U)
NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF CANNABIS MANAGEMENT V GEORGE F. WEST, INDIVIDUALLY AND D/B/A "JAYDEGA 7.0"CA 25-020642026 NY Slip Op 63058(U)
Motions Decided January 5, 2026
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V CLIFTON A. STITHKA 23-004142026 NY Slip Op 61205(U)
THE PEOPLE V TREVOR SMITH IIIKA 24-010542026 NY Slip Op 61204(U)
THE PEOPLE V EARL ROBERTSKA 22-015572026 NY Slip Op 61203(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANTHONY LOVEKA 22-005922026 NY Slip Op 61202(U)
THE PEOPLE V LATREAL JONESKA 24-008932026 NY Slip Op 61201(U)
ANITA STEVENS-SWAN HUMANE SOCIETY, V RYAN HARVEY, .CA 25-019112026 NY Slip Op 61200(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MICHAEL CARROLL V MARA CARROLLCAF 25-002322026 NY Slip Op 61199(U)
THE PEOPLE V STEVEN BURRKA 24-018632026 NY Slip Op 61198(U)
ROBERT BIEBER V TOWN OF HAMBURGCA 25-005652026 NY Slip Op 61197(U)
THE PEOPLE V RAYSHAWN BETHANYKA 14-015042026 NY Slip Op 61196(U)
THE PEOPLE V ROGER ARROYO, ALSO KNOWN AS ROGER BEAVERKA 24-001332026 NY Slip Op 61195(U)
IN THE MATTER OF GIANNA A.CAF 24-019342026 NY Slip Op 61194(U)

Links to or from other sites do not signify endorsement or relationship with them.