skip to main content
Law Reporting
Bureau Thomas J.K. Smith, State Reporter

Appellate Division, Fourth Department Motions

Current Month Archived Cases Decisions

July 2025 Archive

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

Motions Decided July 28, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
TOWER DB VIII TRUST 2018-I V DANIEL J. WIK, DOING BUSINESS AS CINOLE HEATHER STEPHENSON, EXECUTRIX OF THE ESTATE OFCA 24-017112025 NY Slip Op 74431(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DANIEL M. HOEFLER, RENE STOBNICKE, JOANNE M. HOEFLER, BRENDA HOEFLER-KLINE, NATHAN B. KLINE, LISA M.CA 24-006172025 NY Slip Op 74430(U)
CITY OF BUFFALO POLICE DEPARTMENT V CLARENCE J. SEGARS, IIICA 25-003182025 NY Slip Op 74429(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANTHONY MORROWKA 22-01779, KA 22-01780 and KA 23-010982025 NY Slip Op 74428(U)
THE PEOPLE V TAJI S. HUNTKA 23-005002025 NY Slip Op 74427(U)
THE PEOPLE V DARIEN GOVANKA 22-00913, KA 23-01041 and KA 24-002072025 NY Slip Op 74426(U)
LOUIS SHATTUCK, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS ASSIGNEE OF CORY LISINSKI, DOING BUSINESS AS CNL CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE, VCA 24-017322025 NY Slip Op 74425(U)
THE PEOPLE V SYJESMAN T. BROWN, ALSO KNOWN AS JOHN DOEKA 19-014892025 NY Slip Op 74424(U)
THE PEOPLE V SYJESMAN T. BROWN, ALSO KNOWN AS JOHN DOEKA 19-014882025 NY Slip Op 74423(U)
Motions Decided July 25, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF PEARL G. SIMMONS, AS SETTLOR OF AN IRREVOCABLE LIVING TRUST OF EUGENE M. SIMMONS AND PEARL G. SIMMONSCA 23-016592025 NY Slip Op 74422(U)
RONALD PACE, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF GERALDINE M. PACE, DECEASED, V CROUSE HEALTH HOSPITALCA 24-015242025 NY Slip Op 74421(U)
IN THE MATTER OF HBC VICTOR LLC V TOWN OF VICTOR683-222025 NY Slip Op 74420(U)
Motions Decided July 24, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF PARIS UTHMAN V COURTNEY J. SAUNDERSCAF 25-005012025 NY Slip Op 74419(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ASHLEY N. SWENSZKOWSKI V KRISTINE SWENSZKOWSKI AND WILLIAM R. NICHOLSCAF 25-011092025 NY Slip Op 74418(U)
IN THE MATTER OF PRINCE-NOBEL B.CAF 25-001902025 NY Slip Op 74417(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SHAIQUIDA B. HAYES V JOHN A. PORTER, IIICAF 25-010632025 NY Slip Op 74416(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KELLY M. PAULSON V DOUGLAS P. PAULSON, SR.CAF 25-004882025 NY Slip Op 74415(U)
IN THE MATTER OF PATIENCE T.CAF 25-001922025 NY Slip Op 74414(U)
IN THE MATTER OF NOAH P.CAF 24-015012025 NY Slip Op 74413(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOSEPH MASCI V JESSICA ROMEROCAF 25-009302025 NY Slip Op 74412(U)
IN THE MATTER OF BETH LOCKHART, ESQ., ATTORNEY FOR THE CHILD V MELISSA MONICACAF 24-015142025 NY Slip Op 74411(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SARAH LOADHOLT AND WILLIE LOADHOLT V SHANIQUE S. NICHOLS AND SHIMEEK J. LOADHOLTCAF 25-011122025 NY Slip Op 74410(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JUNIPER T.CAF 25-006502025 NY Slip Op 74409(U)
IN THE MATTER OF FAITH B.CAF 25-001932025 NY Slip Op 74408(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CHERISH M.CAF 25-001942025 NY Slip Op 74407(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TYREASE CARTER V TRINA L. CARTER AND LARRY A. MANDER, JR.CAF 24-018032025 NY Slip Op 74406(U)
IN THE MATTER OF AMIYAH C.CAF 24-013972025 NY Slip Op 74405(U)
Motions Decided July 22, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF RASHAD H.CAF 25-012322025 NY Slip Op 73301(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SHAIQUIDA B. HAYES V JOHN A. PORTER, IIICAF 25-010632025 NY Slip Op 73300(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOHN A. PORTER, III V SHAIQUIDA B. HAYESCAF 25-010622025 NY Slip Op 73299(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MEILANI M.CAF 25-009142025 NY Slip Op 73298(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KARDAR S.CAF 24-011882025 NY Slip Op 73297(U)
Motions Decided July 21, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF WATERFRONT OPERATIONS ASSOCIATES LLC, DOING BUSINESS AS ELLICOTT CENTER FOR REHABILITATION ANDCA 24-016992025 NY Slip Op 73296(U)
THE PEOPLE V FREDERICK S. WALKER, JR.KA 21-017302025 NY Slip Op 73295(U)
VAN BUREN FARMS, LLC VERNE VAN BUREN AND WALTER VAN BUREN V HENDRIX FARMS , AND CONKLIN COMPANY, INC.CA 25-005222025 NY Slip Op 73294(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL J. RIVERA PEREZKA 24-003492025 NY Slip Op 73293(U)
HON. ACEA M. MOSEY V OFFICE OF COURT ADMINISTRATIONCA 25-005532025 NY Slip Op 73292(U)
THE PEOPLE, V WALTER C. GRAHAMKA 23-008372025 NY Slip Op 73291(U)
THE PEOPLE V STEVEN C. FORSHEYKA 22-009752025 NY Slip Op 73290(U)
GLENN FEDERMAN V TOWN OF LORRAINE, HIGHWAY SUPERINTENDENT JOSEPH WASILEWSKI, TOWN ATTORNEY DAVID GEURTSEN, ESQ., SOUTHCA 25-000922025 NY Slip Op 73289(U)
THE PEOPLE V DOUGLAS E. EGGERSKA 25-003362025 NY Slip Op 73288(U)
THE PEOPLE EX REL., ROBERTO CONCEPCION V AMY TITUS, SUPERINTENDENT, ORLEANS CORRECTIONAL FACILITYKAH 23-012352025 NY Slip Op 73287(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANTOINETTE M. CASSONIKA 23-007432025 NY Slip Op 73286(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOENATHAN CASHKA 23-012242025 NY Slip Op 73285(U)
Motions Decided July 18, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF KARLIL WILLIAMS V JULIE L. GRAUCAF 25-009092025 NY Slip Op 73284(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KARLIL WILLIAMS V JULIE L. GRAUCAF 25-009092025 NY Slip Op 73283(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JERMANIE D.CAF 25-001742025 NY Slip Op 73282(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CORA M., LEVI M., AND COLE M.CAF 25-009192025 NY Slip Op 73281(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALEJANDRA J. AND JULIO S.CAF 25-009272025 NY Slip Op 73280(U)
Motions Decided July 17, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF ROCHESTER POLICE LOCUST CLUB, INC. V CITY OF ROCHESTERCA 25-007262025 NY Slip Op 73279(U)
MATTER OF NEW YORK STATE POLICE V DAVID J. KINGSLEY IICA 25-004432025 NY Slip Op 73278(U)
FLORENCE LOUISE HARMS, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS EXECUTRIX OF THE ESTATE OF ROBERT L. HARMS, DECEASED V CLEMENTIA LEWIS, M.D.CA 25-009182025 NY Slip Op 73277(U)
MATTER OF NEW YORK STATE POLICE V MATHEW J. GALLIHERCA 25-004422025 NY Slip Op 73276(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF JULIANNE C. BAKER, ALSO KNOWN AS JULIANNE CLAS BAKER, ALSO KNOWN AS JULIE BAKERCA 25-009812025 NY Slip Op 73275(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF JULIANNE C. BAKER, ALSO KNOWN AS JULIANNE CLAS BAKER, ALSO KNOWN AS JULIE BAKERCA 25-009812025 NY Slip Op 73274(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF JULIANNE C. BAKER, ALSO KNOWN AS JULIANNE CLAS BAKER, ALSO KNOWN AS JULIE BAKERCA 25-009812025 NY Slip Op 73273(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF JULIANNE C. BAKER, ALSO KNOWN AS JULIANNE CLAS BAKER, ALSO KNOWN AS JULIE BAKERCA 25-009812025 NY Slip Op 73272(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF DANIELLE DILL, PSY.D, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF CENTRAL NEW YORK PSYCHIATRIC CENTER VCA 25-002822025 NY Slip Op 73271(U)
Motions Decided July 16, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V JIMMIE WRIGHTKA 19-013032025 NY Slip Op 73270(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANDEE WRIGHTKA 25-002132025 NY Slip Op 73269(U)
THE PEOPLE V HAROLD WEHRLEKA 25-008452025 NY Slip Op 73268(U)
THE PEOPLE V JASON A. WEEKSKA 25-009992025 NY Slip Op 73267(U)
WAFLER FARMS V TIMOTHY CONNICK, IN HIS CAPACITY AS CHAIRPERSON OF THE NEW YORK STATE PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARDCA 25-008922025 NY Slip Op 73266(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL VIOLAKA 23-001012025 NY Slip Op 73265(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL C. STEWARTKA 24-016132025 NY Slip Op 73264(U)
THE PEOPLE V CLINT M. SMITHKA 24-01065 and KA 24-010672025 NY Slip Op 73263(U)
THE PEOPLE V MARKEEF ROYALKA 23-014052025 NY Slip Op 73262(U)
THE PEOPLE V ERIC N. REYNOLDSKA 19-023432025 NY Slip Op 73261(U)
THE PEOPLE V ERIC N. REYNOLDSKA 19-023442025 NY Slip Op 73260(U)
IN THE MATTER OF BRADFORD MORSE V JULIE MORSECAF 24-016382025 NY Slip Op 73259(U)
IN THE MATTER OF BRADFORD MORSE V JULIE MORSECAF 24-016372025 NY Slip Op 73258(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TYRONE MORRIS V DOMONIQUE SMITH, , EVETTE BUNTLEYCAF 25-001262025 NY Slip Op 73257(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MEA V.CAF 25-005512025 NY Slip Op 73256(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MATTHEW J., MYLES J., MAX J., MATTALYEN J. AND MICHAEL J.CAF 24-014892025 NY Slip Op 73255(U)
THE PEOPLE V ERIC A. LYNCHKA 25-008422025 NY Slip Op 73254(U)
IN THE MATTER OF BETH LOCKHART, ESQ., ATTORNEY FOR THE CHILD V MELISSA MONICACAF 24-015142025 NY Slip Op 73253(U)
IN THE MATTER OF GREGORY A. LATTA V STEPHANIE HARTCAF 25-010702025 NY Slip Op 73252(U)
THE PEOPLE V STANLEY JOHNSON, JR.KA 25-009922025 NY Slip Op 73251(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANDREW E. JENSENKA 25-009062025 NY Slip Op 73250(U)
IN THE MATTER OF IVELISE P.T. AND NATALIA R.T.CAF 24-007502025 NY Slip Op 73249(U)
THE PEOPLE V BRANDON HALLKA 25-009102025 NY Slip Op 73248(U)
THE PEOPLE V TAYLOR E. GOODHINESKA 25-009082025 NY Slip Op 73247(U)
THE PEOPLE V WILLIAM PATRICK FRICKEKA 25-008782025 NY Slip Op 73246(U)
THE PEOPLE V KEITH ESCOBARKA 25-008522025 NY Slip Op 73245(U)
THE PEOPLE V MICHAEL J. ELMOREKA 25-008302025 NY Slip Op 73244(U)
THE PEOPLE V TRISTIN ELLIOTTKA 25-009852025 NY Slip Op 73243(U)
THE PEOPLE V WILLIAM M. DEANKA 24-007922025 NY Slip Op 73242(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DANAYELY P.E.CAF 24-004992025 NY Slip Op 73241(U)
THE PEOPLE V JORDAN P. BATCHELORKA 24-00433 and KA 24-004372025 NY Slip Op 73240(U)
THE PEOPLE V JASON D'AVOLIOKA 21-011652025 NY Slip Op 73239(U)
Motions Decided July 15, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
KATHLEEN ALGOE AND SHANNON BUFFINGTON, AS EXECUTRIX OF THE ESTATE OF THOMAS ALGOE, DECEASED V EASTERN NIAGARACA 24-018242025 NY Slip Op 73238(U)
Motions Decided July 14, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
THOMAS R. WHELAN AND JENNIFER S. WHELAN V BUFFALO MUNICIPAL HOUSING AUTHORITYCA 24-01890 AND CA 25-006352025 NY Slip Op 73237(U)
THE PEOPLE V AARON WELCHKA 23-017762025 NY Slip Op 73236(U)
ZAKKIYYA CARTER, - V KAPIL VARMA AND VAASTU ENERGY LLC, - .CA 24-016532025 NY Slip Op 73235(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SHANNON RANDS V SARAH (ALSO KNOWN AS KY'MERE) IMBLUM JOSEPH MCCLAM AND DERRICK HARRISCAF 25-01013 and CAF 25-010142025 NY Slip Op 73234(U)
THE PEOPLE, V SAMUEL MCCULLOUGHKA 22-016692025 NY Slip Op 73233(U)
MANUFACTURERS AND TRADERS TRUST COMPANY V GARY LEFKOWITZ, AND RYAN HERTZEL SCHILLER, KNAPP, LEFKOWITZ & HERTZEL, LLPCA 25-000802025 NY Slip Op 73232(U)
MERIMA KAJTEZOVIC V HUSEIN KAJTEZOVICCA 24-015532025 NY Slip Op 73231(U)
THE PEOPLE V EVERTON HIBBERTKA 00-029592025 NY Slip Op 73230(U)
ANNIE HARRIS V UPSTATE UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, PATIENT RELATIONS DEPARTMENTCA 25-008932025 NY Slip Op 73229(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CUBA LAKE COMMITTEE FOR FAIR ASSESSMENTS, HARRY W. KEELEY AND HARRY W. AND CYNTHIA KEELEY JOINTCA 25-000792025 NY Slip Op 73228(U)
THE PEOPLE, V JASON A. CHABOTKA 24-000312025 NY Slip Op 73227(U)
LOCAL GAS, LLC V CARDCONNECT, LLCCA 24-017472025 NY Slip Op 73226(U)
JOSEPH D. BURGDORF V BETSY ROSS REHABILITATION CENTER, INC.,DOING BUSINESS AS BETSY ROSS NURSING AND REHABILITATIONCA 23-016042025 NY Slip Op 73225(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CONNOR B. BUSHART V AZRAEL R. GIACALONECAF 24-013602025 NY Slip Op 73224(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ADELAIDE H.CAF 24-016832025 NY Slip Op 73223(U)
Motions Decided July 9, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF MELISSA EYGNOR V JASON LEPPERCAF 25-008822025 NY Slip Op 72487(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KATIE LYNN DOWLING V STEVEN MILLIOCAF 25-010162025 NY Slip Op 72486(U)
Motions Decided July 8, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF CATRINA SAPP, V PHILEMON GREENE, .CAF 25-010052025 NY Slip Op 72485(U)
IN THE MATTER OF EMMA DRAKE, V BRYAN J. OSEGUERA-CASTILLO, .CAF 25-006722025 NY Slip Op 72484(U)
Motions Decided July 7, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF KATHRYN WILLIAMS V JUSTICE CENTER FOR THE PROTECTION OF PEOPLE WITH SPECIAL NEEDSTP 25-008362025 NY Slip Op 72483(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CARLOS WHITE V DANIEL F. MARTUSCELLO, III, COMMISSIONER, NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS ANDTP 25-003592025 NY Slip Op 72482(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ARBITRATION BETWEEN KIA AMERICA, INC. V TSE-KIN TONGCA 24-016462025 NY Slip Op 72481(U)
THE PEOPLE V CLIFTON A. STITHKA 23-004142025 NY Slip Op 72480(U)
THE PEOPLE V BRITTANY J. SKINKLEKA 23-017902025 NY Slip Op 72479(U)
IN THE MATTER OF BRADY J. SCHULTZ V DARLA A. BERKE, TIMOTHY BERKE JEANETTE W. BERKECAF 24-001212025 NY Slip Op 72478(U)
IN THE MATTER OF BRADY J. SCHULTZ V DARLA A. BERKE, TIMOTHY BERKE JEANETTE W. BERKECAF 24-001212025 NY Slip Op 72477(U)
THE PEOPLE V JAVYON J. OGDENKA 23-012612025 NY Slip Op 72476(U)
PETER R. MORGAN V CITY OF UTICA, UTICA, NEW YORKCA 25-005792025 NY Slip Op 72475(U)
THE PEOPLE V DAVID LOFTONKA 24-000922025 NY Slip Op 72474(U)
MATTER OF JOHN P. V STATE OF NEW YORKCA 25-009472025 NY Slip Op 72473(U)
THE PEOPLE, V TASHEONIA M. HILLSKA 19-016452025 NY Slip Op 72472(U)
KATHLEEN GUMKOWSKI, AS ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF GREGORY GUMKOWSKI, DECEASED, AND KATHLEEN GUMKOWSKICA 24-011932025 NY Slip Op 72471(U)
THE PEOPLE, V LAWREN GOINSKA 23-006792025 NY Slip Op 72470(U)
DANIEL CHARCHOLLA V CHANNEL 13 NEWS, ALSO KNOWN AS 13 WHAM, AND DEERFIELD MEDIA (ROCHESTER), INC.CA 24-016502025 NY Slip Op 72469(U)
THE PEOPLE V LISBETH COLLADOKA 23-009252025 NY Slip Op 72468(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DAVID CHEUNG V KIM NYGEN THI TRANCAF 24-011352025 NY Slip Op 72467(U)
THE PEOPLE V MATTHEW D. CARPENTERKA 23-008212025 NY Slip Op 72466(U)
THE PEOPLE V MATTHEW D. CARPENTERKA 23-008212025 NY Slip Op 72465(U)
THE PEOPLE V RONZELL CAMBERKA 23-017662025 NY Slip Op 72464(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALEENA M.CAF 25-006682025 NY Slip Op 72463(U)
IN THE MATTER OF AKEEM M. AND AKEELAH M.CAF 24-015692025 NY Slip Op 72462(U)
Motions Decided July 3, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF BRADFORD MORSE V JULIE MORSECAF 24-016372025 NY Slip Op 72461(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOSEPH MASCI V JESSICA ROMEROCAF 25-009302025 NY Slip Op 72097(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOSEPH MASCI V JESSICA ROMEROCAF 25-009302025 NY Slip Op 72096(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TANEA L. HARTSFIELD V TERRON D. SMITHCAF 25-007062025 NY Slip Op 72095(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JAMES K. BARRETT V MURSTESE G. GAINES AND JOY COBBCAF 25-004752025 NY Slip Op 72094(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JAMES K. BARRETT V MURSTESE G. GAINES AND JOY COBBCAF 25-004752025 NY Slip Op 72093(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JAMES K. BARRETT V MURSTESE G. GAINES AND JOY COBBCAF 25-004752025 NY Slip Op 72092(U)
Motions Decided July 2, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION FOR DISCHARGE OF MARK M., CONSEC. NO. 249400 V STATE OF NEW YORKCA 25-008502025 NY Slip Op 72091(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JASIAH D.S. AND JASIR D.S., ALSO KNOWN AS BABY M. A AND BABY M. B., ALSO KNOWN AS BABY G. M.CAF 25-009792025 NY Slip Op 72090(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JA'MOURE D.S., YASIR D.S., AND ZEMOURA M.CAF 25-009802025 NY Slip Op 72089(U)
Motions Decided July 1, 2025
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF ZORAZENA S. AND KENKEV M.CAF 25-001592025 NY Slip Op 72088(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ZACHARY H.CAF 25-010862025 NY Slip Op 72087(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ETHAN K. SPRAGUE V ELIZABETH A. YOUNESCAF 24-017002025 NY Slip Op 72086(U)
PEOPLE OF THE STATE NEW YORK, BY LETITIA JAMES, ATTORNEY GENERAL OF STATE OF NEW YORK V PEPSICO, INC., AND FRITO-LAYCA 25-009172025 NY Slip Op 72085(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF ARCHIE J. MIELTY, ALSO KNOWN AS ARCHIE J. MIELTY, DECEASED.CA 24-01643 AND CA 24-016442025 NY Slip Op 72084(U)
RYAN DACKO V IRAKLI KILADZECA 24-020272025 NY Slip Op 72083(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JEREMY M. BATH V JENNIFER M. HOVEYCAF 25-011062025 NY Slip Op 72082(U)
IN THE MATTER OF AVALON P.CAF 25-010912025 NY Slip Op 72081(U)

Links to or from other sites do not signify endorsement or relationship with them.